4 ms·
I read the book and while I enjoyed it, I must point out one thing that really drove me crazy, and that appear common to cory doctorow's YA fiction (e.g. also
by riffraff 13y ago
I read the book and while I enjoyed it, I must point out one thing that really drove me crazy, and that appear common to cory doctorow's YA fiction (e.g. also in "pirate cinema").
People have zero depth.
All the good people are perfectly good and identify with an absolute shared good idea. E.g. if two people want free wifi for everyone they'll also share the same ethics, political views, aesthetic sense.
There is never disagreement in the book between two of the good guys that goes on more than a paragraph.
A YA demographic doesn't justify that and I deeply believe this is the wrong lesson to teach kids.
But still, they are good stories, and the world would probably be better if more people read them.
- viraptor 13y agoI agree with the lack of depth, but let's not take it too far. (Sorry, can't recall the names) The farther was definitely a "good person" who didn't share the views with or understand the protagonist. Their conflict goes on for many chapters, even if only in short bursts. The girl also left because she disagreed about the importance of resisting, even though she was also a "good person".
- api 13y agoThis is unfortunately common in sci-fi and related genres, where characterization and other aspects of literary craft take a back seat to nifty ideas and plot. Good characterization is a complex exercise that requires that the writer spend a lot of time dissecting the motives and mindset of each character, as well as an ability to exercise a kind of multiple personality disorder while writing and view each scene from each characters' perspective. Lit-fic has the opposite problem: excellent characters, beautiful prose, but ho-hum ideas and/or plot. VERY few works manage both craft and meaning.
- Jehar 13y agoI found this to be an astute observation about Little Brother, but it's not something I'd apply to the genre as a whole, or even Doctorow. I was highly impressed by the characterization in Makers, which was only published a year later. Little Brother was written in haste[1] with an explicit focus on the ideological, at the expense of more human characters. I would urge anyone who felt the characterization in LB to be lacking to check out Makers. [1]:http://www.sfcenter.ku.edu/GunnLecture/Cory_Doctorow-Little_Brother.htm http://www.sfcenter.ku.edu/GunnLecture/Cory_Doctorow-Little_...