5 ms·
"On Wednesday night, after a long work day, I got into my car" That's his first mistake. Many (most?) people on food stamps can't afford a car. When you have l
by peterwwillis 13y ago
"On Wednesday night, after a long work day, I got into my car"
That's his first mistake. Many (most?) people on food stamps can't afford a car. When you have little money for food, and you just got off the late shift of your second job, you have an even longer trip to the store, costing you more money.
Many of these people also may live in food deserts, where the most common type of store is a liquor store, followed maybe by a payday loan place and a gas station, or a bar. That's where I live anyway.
The closest grocery store is a very poorly maintained Aldi, and some people I know take a cab there and back once a week so they don't have to spend an hour or more traveling by bus.
- shitlord 13y agoJust curious, where do you live? I ask because the only time I've ever had to take taxis constantly was when visiting NYC, and it still wasn't cheap (although, cheaper than a taxi to the airport 10 mins away).
- carlob 13y agoI'm curious as well: why did you take cabs constantly when visiting NYC? My take is that you enjoy the neighborhoods much more if you just walk, and when you just need to go from point A to point B fast, the subway works very well (with the exception of going from the museum mile to anywhere else).
- shitlord 13y agoWhen I visited, it was freezing cold outside, and half the people in my group were drunk. We were really just trying to get from one party to another, which is why we decided to take a cab, because it would require minimal effort. Anyway, my point was that when you have a limit of about $30 per week for groceries, you probably can't afford to take a cab there and back.
- peterwwillis 13y agoBaltimore City. We don't have to take taxis constantly, but it can be a better choice than the alternatives if you don't have a car: 1. Do I walk the 45 minutes each way (carrying groceries on the way back) through dangerous neighborhoods and probably get mugged or worse? (Baltimore is among the 10 most dangerous cities in America) 2. If I have a bike with a basket, do I bike and take the same risk? (People get mugged off their bike frequently here) 3. Do I wait the 80-120 minutes round trip for the bus? (This is often preferable to walking the dangerous neighborhoods, not to mention you can put your bags down) 4. Do I take a taxi, once per week (or less if you buy in bulk) to the store to save time and hassle? The young women I know in the area who live in a food desert often take the taxi option as it's just less of a risk and they don't want to spend the time and hassle of other options. You spend more money to be safe and get things done after a long day of work.
- thejulielogan 13y agoHe's not trying to walk in another person's shoes, simply live by the same constraints.
- sigh400 13y agoConstraints? You mean like not owning a car and the increased insurance premiums from living in a high risk area with no credit to speak of? Which is why it's complete and utter bullshit. You sleep in horribly shitty conditions, where noise is a constant problem. You do this day in and day out and with poor nutrition, lack of heating/cooling, and a shitty mattress. All in a attempt to save up for a car, insurance, maintenance costs and gas? Yet it's just about budgetary constraints. Right you are sir. Right you are.
- humbledrone 13y agoDid you read the article? Quoting from it: > My goal is merely to help bring awareness to the issue He's not trying to do some kind of "poor simulation," and to accomplish his goal, he doesn't have to. Even by just doing a simple exercise like strictly limiting his food budget for a week, he has brought some light upon the difficulty that many people face.
- sigh400 13y agoYes and clearly they are not the same constraints. It's ridiculous to think this raises any sort of awareness to the real issues that poverty presents. It's trite and ignorant to think anything otherwise.
- randac 13y agoI had never heard of 'food deserts' for example. This stunt raised my awareness. You're wrong.
- icebraining 13y agoCharities seem to think that small, one-line ads with a tidbit of information can raise awareness and spur some people into action; I don't see why this couldn't. Raising awareness is not the same as getting people to even begin to understand the issue, it's just making people realize there is an issue.
- mortenjorck 13y agoA lot of people on food stamps have no choice. They live in communities with little or no public transit infrastructure, and are forced to own and maintain a personal vehicle to get to and from their minimum-wage job. They live in places designed for a twentieth-century middle class supported by high-paying factory jobs and an infinite supply of petroleum.
- Dylan16807 13y agoHow long is the taxi ride? And does the bus pass by any properly-maintained grocery stores? I'm really interested in this because the bus near me goes from suburbs to the middle of downtown in about half an hour, going by quite a few groceries. I didn't know it was possible to be that far from anywhere to buy food in a non-rural area.
- xxpor 13y agoIt is absolutely a huge problem. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Food_desert
- 001sky 13y agoExample: Total Trip: 85 minutes. This is 20 mintes each way, plus wait times. Bus comes 30 minutes on some routes, every 60 on others. A median wiat time would be 30-60 minutes for a round trip.
- peterwwillis 13y agoYes, exactly. As funding gets pulled from public transit budgets, routes run less and less frequently. In Florida (where I lived before Baltimore) it can take two and a half hours by bus to travel what takes around 20 minutes by car, but there the grocery stores are plentiful because of the immense urban sprawl. In Baltimore and DC, there are literally almost no grocery stores in large swaths of the city, and not a lot of bus lines, because why would buses run often to places with no commerce? Some heavily traveled lines are between a half hour and an hour late, regularly. -- This[1] is a map of food deserts in DC, which doesn't include Prince George's County (where most of the gentrification is pushing lower-to-middle-class [almost entirely black] families that can't afford living in DC anymore). Note that children are highly affected. There have been studies showing the lack of nutrition for children severely affects their development. This[2] page from Baltimore City Planning lays out the numbers, in which 1/3 of Baltimore neighborhoods lie in a food desert (we're not as well off as DC's metro-accessible gentrified and developed areas; our metro is a joke). It's much easier to find Ramen noodles than it is a piece of fruit, or non-fried foods. Walmart has been trying to break into DC and Baltimore for years, and is coming very close, partly on the argument that it would lessen food deserts. But the reality shows that they are pushing hard for long, large flat parking lots and super-centers, which 1. increases car traffic to an already congested urban neighborhoods, 2. removes store space and convenience for small businesses, which in turn 3. reduces the number of small businesses available to sell healthy food to locals, because they can just get everything at Walmart. This results in no additional relief for the majority of residents in food deserts, while reducing the number of small businesses that could have provided better food service, and making traffic worse for public transit (which is already stressed). The USDA had a map of food deserts from 2010 but it's not working for me. Maybe someone can download the data from here[3] and plot it in some JavaScript library? -- [1] http://dcentric.wamu.org/2011/05/mapping-d-c-s-food-deserts/index.html http://dcentric.wamu.org/2011/05/mapping-d-c-s-food-deserts/... [2] http://www.baltimorecity.gov/Government/AgenciesDepartments/Planning/BaltimoreFoodPolicyInitiative/FoodDeserts.aspx http://www.baltimorecity.gov/Government/AgenciesDepartments/... [3] http://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/food-access-research-atlas/download-the-data.aspx http://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/food-access-research-a...
- yummyfajitas 13y agoI don't know about people on food stamps specifically (the data doesn't slice by it), but most (70%) poor people have at least one car. 25% have two or more cars. http://www.census.gov/prod/2008pubs/h150-07.pdf http://www.census.gov/prod/2008pubs/h150-07.pdf Also, most poor people (78%) don't have even one job, let alone two (nor are they even looking for one). http://www.bls.gov/cps/cpswp2011.pdf http://www.bls.gov/cps/cpswp2011.pdf
- cpleppert 13y ago>>Also, most poor people (78%) don't have even one job, let alone two (nor are they even looking for one). First of all, that isn't right from the data you linked to. 59% of people below the poverty line don't have a job or aren't in the labor force(Table 6). Secondly, it turns out that not everyone in a family is a wage earner so there is no way to extrapolate from that data point to how many are just living off welfare. If you look at table 1 in the bls report you can see that those in poverty & and in the labor force without a job were 17%.
- yummyfajitas 13y ago10.4 million working poor / 46.2 million poor == 22% in the labor force. You get up to 37% if you count people who looked for a job at least once a year, but less than half the year. In the past I've corrected for the fraction of children. It makes no real difference. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2130441 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2130441 The fact of the matter is that peterwillis's description of the poor is simply inaccurate for most poor people, most of the time.
- D9u 13y agoThere are many US military families who receive SNAP benefits. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/06/19/food-stamps-military_n_3462465.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/06/19/food-stamps-militar...