8 ms·
How to Make School Better for Boys
- gz5 13y agoWhy aren't they being implemented? Because votes can be won in the US on girls education but not on boys education. For now. Agree there will be a tipping point. Outside of politics, all US education needs to be addressed, independent of any segmentation.
- DamnYuppie 13y agoIt appears anything that is pro-boys is immediately seen as "anti-girls" which shouldn't be the case. If we want true equality we need to have equal opportunities but be aware that gender has different methods, motivations, and desires.
- russelluresti 13y agoOkay, I was willing to read this and keep an open mind. But then I got to the fourth paragraph and saw this: " Officials at schools ... are helplessly watching as their campuses become like retirement villages, with a surfeit of women competing for a handful of surviving men." Is the argument here that women only go to college compete for men? And that colleges with more women are "retirement villages" because there aren't enough young men to hook up with? Yep, done with this article.
- jiggy2011 13y agoThat might be an extreme interpretation but I don't see it as unlikely that romantic possibilities are a factor for college aged people when choosing a place to spend several years of their lives. Somewhere with a healthy gender mix feel more inviting overall than somewhere with a "bro club" atmosphere (or the opposite of that).
- mabhatter 13y agoThat's where we have a bit of a double standard of expectations. We expect a girl to go to college ZPRIMARILY to get an MRS. Degree, preferably ABOVE her social standing. When guys go to school we expect WORK first, Mrs. Second. You end up with this situation where women should compete with men fairly, all the time... Except when they want to stop competing and get married. Even then, men are competing for FOOD ON THE TABLE, every day, the next 40 years. Women don't have the same "skin in the game" because Daddy pays for school until hubby marries them.
- lutusp 13y ago> ... women should compete with men fairly, all the time... Except when they want to stop competing and get married. There are a number of problems with your post, but this one stands out. When a woman marries a man, the competition doesn't end, it's just starting. Many women don't plan to marry well, they plan to divorce well. Not judging, just saying. Marriage is not the absence of competition, it's competition taken to a new height -- or do I mean depth?
- jiggy2011 13y agoI don't know if that is necessarily true. At least amongst my peer group, men would place a high weight on non academic factors in university choice. As long as the the university offered a course they wanted and had enough prestige to match their perceived social standing and families expectations factors like distance from home, cost of living , party reputation and where their friends were going were the big factors. From my recollection the women tended to be more conscientious about their studies too and often had added pressure from being the first woman in their immediate family to have attended higher education.
- wvenable 13y ago> Is the argument here that women only go to college compete for men? It doesn't have to mean only. It's not unreasonable to expect that men and women, in the late teens and early twenties, would want to go to college to find people to date. Since when it college just about academics? Given two colleges, one with a healthy balance of genders and one without, I would except most people would rather go to the healthy-balance college.
- russelluresti 13y agoMaybe it's just me, then. I know when I was looking at schools I didn't even consider the gender breakdown of the school. It wasn't anywhere near my top concerns - it wasn't even a factor I looked at. Also, I'm not sure how valid the author's statement actually is. I didn't spend a ton of time researching it, but I was curious. Here are the application numbers for two recent years (couldn't find University of North Carolina): Boston College | 38.2k -> 41.7k (+9%) Brandeis University | 7.7k -> 8.9k (+15%) New York University | 38k -> 42.2k (+11%) University of Georgia | 17.4k -> 18k (+3%) Each college continued to receive an increase in applications that was (with the exception of the University of Georgia) on par with other colleges. If people are still applying to those schools, and they aren't seeing decreased applications, doesn't that mean the whole "tipping point" argument where no one will want to go to those schools is invalid?
- sseveran 13y agoColleges seeing a decrease in enrollment and "no one will want to go" are completely different things. If colleges are worried about it they probably have some market research to back up their worrying. Whether it will end up being true is a completely different story. However even a modest decrease in the percentage of the population going to college would have a huge effect on the money available to universities.
- snowwrestler 13y agoDo you really think 18 year olds (male or female) don't take the social scene into account when deciding which college to attend? In business you have to know your customers. If you're selling to 18 year olds, you can't ignore dating and sex. Especially if you're asking them to spend most of 4 years of their lives and $100,000.
- TwiztidK 13y agoI thought that was a bit off putting too. The school I go to is ~75% male and I've overheard women complaining several times about how they wish there were more girls for them to hang out with. I hear pretty much the same thing from the guys, but that is to be expected. Overall, I think most students would prefer a college to have nearly equal amounts of each gender and any imbalance will cause complaints.
- throwaway344 13y agoTo me, one of the easiest ways to boost male achievement in education is really simple. Have male teachers. An incredible 84% of teachers are female. [1] This has led to a dearth of male role models in schol for all the guys there. I have 1 male teacher. (I'm in high school) And he's the computer teacher, a stereotypical male field. [1] http://www.edweek.org/media/pot2011final-blog.pdf http://www.edweek.org/media/pot2011final-blog.pdf
- mhurron 13y agoFirst, isn't the article about higher education, most professors are male. Second, is that really a problem? Honestly so much of the world is becoming if you can't physically see someone similar to you doing something you are disadvantaged. Do you really need to see a male teaching a subject for you to press yourself to do your best? I had primarily women teachers too, probably everyone did. It didn't do anything positive or negative to me. If you can not drive yourself, you are going to be at a significant disadvantage when you move on to the working world.
- barry-cotter 13y agoDo you feel the same way about male over representation among surgeons, CEOs, law firm partners? Are you indifferent to gender balance or indifferent to gender balance when women are in the majority?
- mhurron 13y agoI do not put weight on gender as an indicator of anything. I did not think I would have a better chance at becoming a Lawyer because many men are lawyers or that I would have a worse chance at becoming a Teacher because most of my teachers were Women. I don't believe there need to be more women in tech, or more male teachers. There needs to be the best at what they do doing it. Gender is not a measure of merit.
- barry-cotter 13y ago
- adt2bt 13y ago"Young men in Great Britain, Australia, and Canada have also fallen behind. But in stark contrast to the United States, these countries are energetically, even desperately, looking for ways to help boys improve. Why? They view widespread male underachievement as a national threat: A country with too many languishing males risks losing its economic edge." As an American, I may be unplugged from many of these happenings, but I feel like this is a stark difference between America and other countries. We seem to have a laissez-faire attitude that "If there's a problem, and a deadline for the problem, someone will just magically figure it out at the last second." And we often attribute that someone to the free market. On a broader note, as with any issue people seem to have significant worries about, what is a good way to actually begin solving it, assuming this general American attitude? I honestly don't know.
- mattlutze 13y agoI'm not certain we attribute "that someone" with the free market in many cases. Education is quite solidly considered the purview of the federal and state governments these days, which I think contributes to that last second feeling. When an opportunity for work appears in the free market, there is quite often a surge of responses. I hope it doesn't come across as cynical, but, I think often when there's an opportunity for work in the public market, there's quite often a surge of analysis and discussion and waiting until a response has to be given.
- abracar 13y agoThe author seems to call for a very American solution: lobbying... but I think all it takes is for teachers to be willing to test new practices. See for instance this TEDx talk on reengaging boys in learning through gaming: http://www.ted.com/talks/ali_carr_chellman_gaming_to_re_engage_boys_in_learning.html http://www.ted.com/talks/ali_carr_chellman_gaming_to_re_enga...
- belorn 13y ago"Officials at schools at or near the tipping point are helplessly watching as their campuses become like boy clubs, with a surfeit of men competing for a handful of surviving women. Henry Broaddus, dean of admissions at William and Mary, explains the new anxiety: “[M]en who enroll … expect to see women on campus. It’s not the College of William and William; it’s the College of William and Mary.” Just me who feel that it is slightly offensive and paint a picture of women as sex objects? I wonder how they were allowed to print it without massive outcry.
- jules 13y agoInteresting contrast with russelluresti's comment...
- mhurron 13y agoI fail to see how that statement is any different than any other affirmative action plan, or the popular drive for more women in tech.
- dlokshin 13y agoOne response is to get offended. Another response is to realize that college is as much a social exercise as it is an academic one. Men expect there to be women on campus, women expect there to be men on campus (even at an all women's college, as I found out by dating one at Wellesley). Ultimately students are customers of a service. The service that universities provide is part academic, part social.
- belorn 13y agoYes. The point I tried to surreptitiously make was to hint that while campus is known as the place where people find their life partners, the bluntness of how we express it differ when talking about men and when talking about women. The way to go forward in a equality way, might be to bring the language we use for women to men, or bring both to a more middle point. The "It’s not the College of Mary and Mary; it’s the College of William and Mary." might have been a bit over the top in my taste, but everything else in a perfect world should have no emotional difference if it's women meet man, or man meet woman.
- pingou 13y agoBoys are born tinkerers,” she said. “They have a deep-seated need to rip things apart, decode their inner workings, create stuff.” Fortunately it was a woman who made that statement, it would have been sexist otherwise, right?
- cobrausn 13y agoNo, because she immediately points to scientific studies backing up her statements. Facts can't really be sexist, so if there is a problem with the statement, then we need to determine why the study is invalid.
- abracar 13y agoPlus she makes it very clear that it's a generalization that doesn't necessarily apply to individuals: "Of course, there are female tinkerers who like to work with things and gladly enter occupations such as pipefitting and metallurgy. But the number of men eager to enter these fields is substantially greater."
- barry-cotter 13y agoPlease google "hatefacts". Alternatively go to the criticism section of Stephen J. Gould's Wikipedia article or read the article on the Bellcurve followed by the American Psychological Association's statement on same. For a third possible example read the Full Text of the speech that got Larry Summers fired from the presidency of Harvard. Being right and having the evidence on your side will not protect you if the mood of the times is against you. "The truth will set you free" is as true as "Build a better mousetrap and the world will beat a path to your door."
- _delirium 13y agoThe studies are generally very careful to frame their conclusions narrowly, as pointing out empirically measured differences in particular populations, not showing that something is a "deep-seated need" of boys or that they are "born tinkerers". People doing those studies are usually agnostic on whether the cause is biological, due to parenting, due to other aspects of social environment, etc. The stronger interpretations, like in this article, tend to come from pop-science commentators.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- d0m 13y ago>> How to Make School Better for Boys? Make them run more, damnit.
- jskonhovd 13y agoAs a person who attended a Title 1 high school, I saw a lot guys who came from single parent homes get kicked out after freshman year. I mean a lot them didn't understand the concept of not talking, but at times I felt like a lot teachers where just out to get them.
- mabhatter 13y agoThe biggest difference is that boys are about DOING and girls are about TALKING. That's not about just schools, but the last 400 years of men's and women's role on society. Boys don't typically learn by talking, they learn by pulling things apart and doing skills. In addition, because of all the push to "score" children, we've taken away the basic "boy" traits almost entirely. When I was in elementary school it went form 9am to 3pm with sn hour of recess AND half hour of lunch. There was plenty of time for boys to wiggle and make noise and stuff. My kids current schools were from 8am to 3:30pm with about 45 minutes between one recess and lunch/recess. That's more "chair time" than most office workers are expected in a workday. All the "hands on" things have been removed for cost... Art, music, shop, gym are all drastically scaled back to maybe one of each one time a week if at all. School is strictly "listen and repeat" and MOST boys in history don't learn that way. As modern skills like computers, machining, manufacturing,etc require equipment folks just don't have at home, most boys never have a shot at the typical "boy jobs" until they are 16 and go to a career center or go to college or start working.