4 ms·
> Advocates of DSD are often skeptical of double-blind experiments, which itself is a red flag. Exactly. There's a lot of wackos out there in the music biz th
by busterarm 13y ago
> Advocates of DSD are often skeptical of double-blind experiments, which itself is a red flag.
Exactly. There's a lot of wackos out there in the music biz though. People have religious beliefs about certain products/technologies/sounds without any solid reasoning behind it.
- alan_cx 13y agoWhats wrong with that? We don't question tastes in art, why audio? I don't need logic or research or the agreement of others, I just know what sounds right to me, and that is perfectly solidly reasonable. Ears are as weird and personal as eyes, as is our interpretation. You wont necessarily hear what I hear. On top of that, over time they change. No need for words like wacko and religious. Unless of course you doing mind if I fire back with a few judgmental words of my own?
- Dylan16807 13y agoI think you have a different sort of 'taste' in mind than busterarm does. It is a very reasonable thing to prefer record over CD. They have different sounds, people have different likes, easy, done. But if someone tells you they prefer the look of HDMI when you use gold-plated wires, they're clearly deceiving themselves, because as a digital signal there is no difference whatsoever. So the important question to ask is whether people can hear the difference. I will accept that some people have better/different ears from others, but the best way to demonstrate that ability is a double-blind test. Your standard is what 'sounds right'. Well, if you can reliably tell me that X technology sounds better than Y technology, without labels on the two sets of headphones in front of you, then great, that's all I wanted. I don't need any kind of research showing that a format is objectively 'better'. I just want someone to show that it's objectively different to human ears. If someone says they have a preference, but doesn't actually prefer either one in a blinded test, then the labels 'wacko' and 'religious' fit.
- busterarm 13y agoRight. I'm trying to refer to the self-deception that people have when it comes to audio gear. A really common example is how many musicians and audiophiles end up buying power filters and claim they make the sound better. Often these people don't need the power filters and you can prove with documentation and test equipment that they a) don't need them and b) aren't doing anything to the sound. Are you playing out live in random clubs? Sure get a power filter (but that's not as important as a surge protector). Are you playing at home with modern wiring and not overloading your circuit? Don't waste your fucking money. So many musicians end up developing biases about what certain equipment is supposed to sound like. There are a few videos floating around comparing guitar amp/cab modeling gear to the real thing. A lot friends of mine have trouble picking them apart or getting them right in a blind listening test. Frequently the model has some tweaks that make it sound better... or a better description would be to say that it sounds more like what the musician expects that gear to sound like. Some amp X was used on such and such album and has Y sound and the model sounds like that amp does on the album. I'm frequently right in these blind tests and I end up telling people is that it's because I don't care about the gear and don't have any preconceived notions about what it should sound like. I just listen to the timbre and make my best guess.
- derleth 13y agoBecause Monster Cables use those emotions to rip people off. Unless you really and truly think there's no moral problem with selling cables at a multi-thousand-percent markup based on claims which are trivially disproven, in which case I doubt we'll be able to have a reasonable conversation.
- bathat 13y agoWhat's wrong wrong with it is simple: The question "Is PCM transparent?" is not subject to taste. It either is or it isn't. If listeners can't tell the difference between a source that is being reproduced from PCM or one that is being reproduced from DSD, then we can objectively state that PCM does not degrade sound quality. You and I can disagree about whether impressionism is a "good" style of painting. The art world spent a good deal of energy debating that point. That is something which is subject to taste. But if you say "yes" and I say "no" to the question of whether van Gogh created his impressionist painting on canvas, then only one of us can be right. In this case, my insistence that van Gogh didn't paint on canvas would put me squarely in the loony or wacko category.
- radicaldreamer 13y agoHigh end audio delivers an experience which cannot be easily quantified for the listener. It's just like wine, most people (even many wine experts) can't tell wines apart, let alone rank them in double blind experiments, but drinking wine, from the presentation to the bottle to the company you're keeping at the time is what brings it together. It could be anything in that bottle at that point, but the emotions of that holistic experience are what matter.
- afhof 13y agoIf you are summing up the whole experience rather than the audioformat, then you really don't have anything comparable. If one format really is better (and even that is subjective), then there needs to be a repeatable experiment that proves it.
- busterarm 13y agoUnlike wine, music really comes down to knowledge, experience and training. Sound and our interpretation of it by the human ear have had rigorous study. Much of it is quantifiable. We know the optimum frequency response of our ears is around 85dBSPL, for example. Things that are just peoples perceptions (like "brightness") have technical terms (amplitude of harmonics). Sound engineers aren't doing black magic. If you reduce dynamic range too much through compression you can end up with a sound that people find "boring". I'm sorry but there are things that very quantifiably sound terrible. (I am a musician, I have run live sound and mix my own music.)
- radicaldreamer 13y agoI totally agree, there's certainly going to be stuff that most people, audiophiles included, would consider better or worse. What I mean though is there are certain aspects that can't be reduced to technical terms- like going to listen to a live performance from an artist who isn't going to perform any longer or listening to a piece on a rare, hard to produce system. The value isn't coming directly from the technical aspects of the production for the listener at that point.
- afhof 13y agoIts painful sometimes to read audiophile forums. Often you'll see people claim that FLAC audio doesn't sound as good as raw PCM. Some people seem so proud of their ignorance that they ignore the benefits instead of trying to understand.
- busterarm 13y agoThat stuff is funny in a sad way but easy to ignore. I find it hardest to deal with the people who think that spending more money on something makes it better. My little $100 tripath amp and the cheap but appropriate speakers that I picked for it absolutely smoke a lot of $3000 amps (and similarly expensive speakers) that I come across and people tend to not believe unless they're blindfolded (and still try to poo-poo it when they find out how little my setup cost). Also it crushes my spirit when people have some $10k HiFi setup and the speaker placement/room accoustics aren't right at all.
- briancaw2 13y agoI believe there's a good bit of psychological evidence that spending more money actually makes you perceive things as better.
- busterarm 13y agoFor sure, but that's a cognitive bias. These people go out claiming these things as fact...and unfortunately there's an entire industry out there supporting and benefiting from their claims.
- briancaw2 13y agoRight, saying something is better because it's quality - absent price - is better than something else's quality is different than saying something is just plain old better (which it might be just because it's more expensive). Seems to me that there is something people want - a better audio experience. They may actually get that by paying more, but the preferable outcome would be to get better objective quality. In fact, I think it would be preferable to even pay more to get the better objective product and know you weren't duped. I think there is probably a market for consulting: value1 = objective_value1 + value_of_knowing_you_werent_duped value2 = objective_value2 + cognitive_bias_for_paying_more If it's true that objective_value2 is actually << objective_value1, and cognitive_bias_for_paying_more is not too significant, value_of_knowing_you_werent_duped could be a lucrative business.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoI loved that fact that Monster Audio cable was designed with an 'arrow' telling you which end should be on the speaker and which at the amplifier because they were optimized for sound flowing "to" the speaker.
- afhof 13y agoIt doesn't even stop at audio cable. Ever seen those "High quality HDMI cables? The bits on THOSE wires are purer than any other 1s and 0s. There is real money to be made in selling the emperor his clothes.
- lsc 13y agoWhat I find interesting is the positioning. Fry's has the $150 hdmi cable at eye level, then a $15 hdmi cable a little bit below that, and then on the bottom shelf, you can dig around and find a $1.50 hdmi cable. I suspect that the $150 cable is there to make the $15 cable look like the "reasonable" or "middle of the road" choice. (from experience, the $1.50 cable works just fine.)
- busterarm 13y agoYou're lucky. Back when I still worked in an electronics store, the $15 was your only other option. Except back then it was a $30-45 cable. Aside: Anybody else remember $50 6' USB A-B cables?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- lsc 13y agoI bet best buy and office depot still have $15 as the minimum price for a cable. Last time I really needed an ethernet cable and everything but office depot was closed.... I paid like $15 for a 6' cable. I think that's just the best buy/office depot "minimum price" Fry's is one of those places that targets, well, me; They are more expensive than monoprice, but not by so much that I would delay a project to get the monoprice price. I think they are pretty good at pricing high enough that they are making some money (I mean, I /expect/ to pay more in person) but low enough that I can still go in and buy a hundred cables for a project without it being thousands of dollars.