4 ms·
I’m scared of our government and I’m disgusted by what little Silicon Valley has done to fight it. No! This is so, so wrong. I totally get the sentiment, but t
by pron 13y ago
I’m scared of our government and I’m disgusted by what little Silicon Valley has done to fight it.
No! This is so, so wrong. I totally get the sentiment, but the reaction is misdirected and might do more harm than good. A (centralized) government is a major power base in society, but it is not the only one. What democracy has done is try and take power away from disparate parties, and concentrate much of it in the hands of an elected body. This doesn't always work well, but this main idea is a good one. Government, like any large human undertaking, is an ongoing endeavor that has to be constantly maintained and reformed. But fighting it rather than fixing it is a terrible notion.
I know Americans are inherently distrustful of government – this has to do with America's peculiar history – and in itself, a healthy skepticism towards government is healthy for a democracy. But a general "anti-government" stand will take us back to a much less free, less just, form of organization: feudalism. In feudalism, power is held by private individuals (lords) or organizations (noble families, the church, and I guess in modern times - corporations) that accrue it by amassing money and/or other forms of influence. These power bases form alliances that suit them, with the implicit goal of maintaining their power and withholding it from others. And one thing is certain: these powers are hardly accountable to the public; not even like the most sinister of democratic governments.
The author's particular grievance is mass aggregation of personal information; (almost) everyone agrees that's really bad. But is government the only guilty party? Is it even the biggest offender? I'm pretty sure Google collects and analyzes more personal information than the US government, and it's far less accountable. It doesn't even have secret courts. It's also far more dangerous as a power because of something I've mentioned before: Power is far more dangerous when it manipulates people into surrendering it voluntarily; a truly dangerous power inspires love, not suspicion (as is the case of Big Brother: he is loved, not feared and hated).
To fight things like personal data gathering we should work with the government to fix it rather than fight it, because the universe hates a vacuum, and by trying to fight the government and take away its monopoly on some forms of power, we may find that we've simply put it in far worse hands.
- sseveran 13y agoGoogle can't collect my information if I don't give it to them. They can't install splitters at major NAPs, demand that Microsoft give them their data on my or use it to prosecute me. If they engaged in a campaign against their users by leaking embarrassing data they would be prosecuted since doing that is illegal. If the government does it there is basically no recourse.
- pron 13y agoLike I said, the most dangerous forms of power are obtained by manipulating people to surrender it voluntarily. The fact that Google is, at the moment, not nearly as vilified as the US government allows it to grow its particularly dangerous form of power uninterrupted. The fact that Google cannot force Microsoft into handing over your data is insignificant. Either Microsoft will eventually become a non-power, or both Google and Microsoft (and Facebook and others) will share power as it suits them – just like feudalism. The fact that Google cannot currently directly use violence or incarceration against you is circumstantial. When the federal government was week, the robber barons commonly used violence against people (the Pinkertons, for example), and the robber barons never had as much power as Google does now (knowledge is power). Weaken government enough, and this, too, may come to pass. But the worst part is that it doesn't have to: in modern Western society, information alone can often be used almost as effectively as physical violence, at a much greater scale and at a lower cost. With the power and influence Google holds, I'm not entirely sure they will always be so readily prosecuted for their transgressions. I assume that even now they're trying to remove whatever regulations apply to them, and are certainly fighting any future regulation that may inhibit their aggregation of power.
- richcollins 13y ago* power is held by private individuals (lords) or organizations (noble families, the church, and I guess in modern times - corporations) that accrue it by amassing money and/or other forms of influence. These power bases form alliances that suit them, with the implicit goal of maintaining their power and withholding it from others* Government is the best tool they've found to help them do this.
- pron 13y agoThat they're doing this right now, as you're right to point out, only shows the forces and dynamics at play – that individuals and small groups always attempt to gain power for themselves. But the historic fact is that they were much more successful at achieving their goals before the rise of a central government. Feudalism did exist (almost universally), and for many more years than democracy has.
- skylan_q 13y agoWhat democracy has done is try and take power away from disparate parties, and concentrate much of it in the hands of an elected body. This doesn't always work well, but this main idea is a good one. Government, like any large human undertaking, is an ongoing endeavor that has to be constantly maintained and reformed. But fighting it rather than fixing it is a terrible notion. So we've built a system where large and powerful lobbies represented by small groups of people fight against each other for their cut of the nation's resources at the expense of other small groups and individuals. It doesn't sound like that great an idea to me...
- api 13y agoThis is a good counterpoint. One of the important roles of government is in defending the otherwise defenseless. Without government, nobody protects the powerless from decentralized local tyranny.