10 ms·
Low pay and the rise of the machines
- mberning 13y agoIt is distressing that so many have become 'useless' in this modern economy. I think we are all very aware of the problem as well as the fact that it is likely to get worse. What can be done? I have seen very little on this subject. Guaranteed basic income is probably a step in the right direction. At least such a system offers a real opportunity to drop what you are doing currently and sincerely try for a new career.
- ahoy 13y agoI like the universal basic income idea too, but haven't we gone through a similar crisis during the industrial revolution? How did we pull out of that? This is a genuine question, I'm a poor student of history.
- mberning 13y agoI think that the general consensus is that the industrial revolution did end up replacing many of the jobs that it eliminated, and then some, it just took time. This new revolution in automation may do the same, or it may not. I like to look at the very real possibility of self driving cars and trucks. How many truck drivers are employed today? They will be made obsolete very quickly once self driving trucks hit the market. Where are they going to turn for work? Are they going to suddenly become a programmer, writer, graphic designer, etc? I don't think so. Manual labor jobs were much more interchangeable than labors of the mind.
- marcosdumay 13y agoWe let people get hungry, and die of overworking. The survirvours inherited a more productive society.
- Radim 13y agoActually, it brought unprecedented power to the workers, balancing the power between employer/employee significantly. It certainly was a tough period (hardly alone in that respect!), but the romanticised images of starving children chained by ankles in sweltering mines, whereas they had happily capered about their sunny villages all day long prior to the revolution, are way off [0]. [0] http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-03-19/why-workers-welcomed-long-hours-of-industrial-revolution.html http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-03-19/why-workers-welcome...
- pessimizer 13y agoIf you restrict your survey of the condition of the working class to those who have published autobiographies and memoirs, you will have a distorted view of the condition of most workers during the period.
- Radim 13y agoIf you're referring to the linked article: it's true I haven't read her books, but I hope that a leading UK scholarly expert on the industrial revolution would have taken your point into account!
- rayiner 13y agoIt's not clear that we ever did pull out of it. A certain small class of people who couldn't move away from agriculture, say Native Americans who wanted to maintain their traditional lifestyles, suffered tremendously as the country industrialized and the valuable land was taken over for industrial agriculture. They have never recovered, and are the poorest people in the U.S. to this day. What this means is that people need to move to whatever is next, and those who don't, or more importantly can't, will be left behind. But what's next? During the industrial revolution, people moved to cities to go work in factories. But what's the way forward today? Arguably the key difference between today and back then is that the industrial revolution caused a change in where labor was demanded, while the automation revolution reduces the need for labor across almost all sectors of the economy. Yes, some people need to program the machines, but not that many. After all, during the industrial revolution it wasn't mechanical engineering that offered job opportunities for the masses. To me, the obvious "what's next" is this: those whose jobs are obsoleted by automation personally service those whose jobs aren't. It's possible that the future of America is 2/3 of the population acting as nannies, personal assistants, etc, to the 1/3 whose jobs haven't been automated. I bet there are a ton of people even now who would cook/clean/etc for $5/hour + board. You'd already see this in the U.S. if it wasn't for the minimum wage/welfare. What happens when automation drives the price of unskilled labor down to $2-3/hour? The U.S. becomes Bangladesh is what happens. I think it's a social disaster in the making, but I struggle to think of alternatives.
- jonnathanson 13y agoEssentially, this is the road back to serfdom. The key difference being that Medieval serfs worked land on behalf of landowners, whereas in this scenario, they simply provide services. I agree that it's a social disaster in the making, but I suspect it's a real possibility.
- LiweiZ 13y agoI believe the key to this issue is to have more middle-class to increase the needs for a certain quality service. We all know good service is more than just fulfilled the basic needs. To make it more clear, there has to be more people with middle class consuming capability. We are hitting a bottleneck. If it cannot be raised in a certain period, bad things could happen. Human society has its own way to force the rebalance. However, it's quite ugly. And I wish we can avoid this.
- slurry 13y agoPicture a herd of elephants crossing the savannah. Each elephant carries 50 monkeys on its back. A sudden mutation makes it so that each elephant can now only carry 30 monkeys, but also doubles the number of elephants in the herd. This is terrible news for two-fifths of the monkeys currently riding. Some may never be able to climb back up an elephant and a few unfortunates may find themselves trampled underfoot. On the other hand, the monkey-carrying capacity of the herd is now 20% greater than it was before. Assuming we can sort out the logistics properly, there is enough room for all current monkeys and their offspring, plus maybe a few monkeys from outside who hadn't had a chance to ride yet. KEY: Fewer monkeys per elephant = displaced jobs due to automation. More elephants in the herd = economic growth due to automation. Monkeys = workers. Elephants = "the economy" or "the means of production". People who tell you that automation is going to lead to long-term net job losses from are betting on something that has a very drastic job-displacement effect (WAY fewer monkeys per elephant) while having a very small effect on economic growth (few if any additional elephants). That doesn't make sense to me. The implausibly perfect technologies they tend to talk about would create a massive amount of new value in the economy, i.e. a great deal more elephants for us monkeys to ride on, even if only four abreast. It's much easier to predict the jobs that will be displaced than the new jobs that will be created, so it's cognitively simpler to take the pessimist's side.
- rayiner 13y agoIt's not implausible at all. The displacement effect is the fact that the skill and education bar keeps getting ratcheted higher, making it ever more difficult for people to crawl onto a new monkey. The growth-limiting effect is both intrinsic and extrinsic. Intrinsic, because with depressed labor wages there is no internal demand for more growth, and extrinsic as you run up against natural resource and energy limits.[1] [1] I think the fact that oil is 4x more expensive than it was a decade ago is a dramatically under-appreciated reason for the tepid economic growth we have faced in that time.
- svachalek 13y agoConsider instead the scenario where the elephants don't really enjoy how smelly and messy the monkeys are and replace them with nice clean robot monkeys, who actively discourage the bio monkeys from climbing back up. That's a lot of trampled monkeys. That's the "very drastic job-displacement effect". We're moving into a future where elephants just don't need monkeys anymore.
- a-priori 13y agoIt's mostly speculation at this point what will happen to the labour economy over the next few decades. Certainly it has gone through upheavals in the past and yet there's still a demand for labour today. It's even possible that Jevrons' paradox (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox) may come into play, whereby increasing the efficiency with which we use labour will actually increase demand for it. I think that is at least a partial explanation for the labour boom of the industrial revolution. We could see a similar thing happen again. Or it could cause the value of labour to drop dramatically. But whichever happens I think basic income is worth exploring, because it offers other, immediate benefits: 1) It replaces the existing needs-based social assistance with something that's less intrusive and paternal, and that doesn't leave welfare traps: working more always means you take home more and do not risk what you currently have. 2) It adds financial security for the unemployed and students, which means that more people may pursue higher education and job training. That would help people adjust to a changing labour market. 3) It makes the labour market voluntary. In order for price discovery to work properly in a market, transactions must be voluntary for both parties. If the seller (i.e, the worker) cannot exit a market because they or their family will die or become homeless, then the price (i.e, the hourly wage) will be driven to zero. (Aside: The same logic applies to patient-pays private healthcare systems, except in this case the buyer cannot exit, which means that the price is driven to infinity. This may explain the insane cost of healthcare in the United States.) 4) Relatedly to point #3, basic income would remove the need for minimum wage laws. Currently, they're necessary because the value of unskilled labour may be less than the cost of living.
- nickpinkston 13y agoFully with you - it would seem that the trifecta of a modern and most productive society is: - Education for all: To increase your productivity / fulfillment - Healthcare for all: To keep you productive / happy for as long as possible - Basic Income for all: To remove the risk that you can't earn your "living credits", thereby allowing greater risk taking and social beneficial / poorly compensated work to be paid (like volunteering, etc.)
- chris_mahan 13y agoYou've just described Soviet Communism.
- bcoates 13y agoNot without central planning and state ownership of enterprise he hasn't. What he's describing is just a somewhat 'Social' Liberalism.
- chris_mahan 13y agoAnd how do you achieve education for all, healthcare for all, and basic income for all without central planning? And how do you achieve basic income for all without heavy regulation? Heavy regulation is the same as state ownership, except that the state then uses private investors as owners, but the owners don't get a say in the way the company is run (because of the heavy regulation).
- bcoates 13y agoTaxes? There doesn't seem to be a very high correlation between how many of these social programs a country implements and how heavily the state involves itself in businesses. I'm not even arguing that these projects are good ideas, just that they're fundamentally from an entirely different political and economic philosophy than the actual system that existed in the Soviet Union.
- wutbrodo 13y ago
- andrewvc 13y ago100% in favor of guaranteed minimum income. I think its doable. All the research seems to say that people make poor decisions when in dire straits. It seems like a great optimization.
- JamesArgo 13y agoI've never seen the numbers worked out. Also, you'd certainly need to adjust birthrate globally to keep ahead of Malthusian pressures. I'll remain sceptical until I see an actionable proposal. Have a link?
- mberning 13y agoIn Our Hands by Charles Murray
- wutbrodo 13y agoThere have been a few pilot programs in places like Namibia, India, etc. There's a couple of reasons to take early reports with a grain of salt: These programs are implemented with varying degrees of completeness (i.e. they're only regional, or they're only a partial basic income), and it's still early and on a relatively small scale. That being said, early reports have been extremely positive: Variously, crime rates have plummeted, education has risen sharply, child malnutrition has dropped, new startups have skyrocketed, community income has risen by a substantial amount more than the grant amount, etc. Given that anyone with a rudimentary knowledge of economics understands that a basic income is at least _theoretically_ sound, the (few and flawed) data points that we have so far are slightly encouraging. EDIT for source link: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income#Examples_of_implementation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income#Examples_of_implem...
- DougN7 13y agoIt is distressing. I'm in favor of a living wage for everyone that works or is disabled/retired. What I can't decide on is what to do with those that will choose not to work. What if it was 1% of the population? Or 5%? Or...?
- Avshalom 13y agoWell seeing as the current unemployment is well over 5% I'm not sure that's a real issue.
- strongvigilance 13y agoIndeed. In fact, when economists talk about full employment, they don't even mean 100% - it's thought that at least some unemployment is needed to control inflation. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Full_employment http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Full_employment
- dnautics 13y agohow do you figure out who is choosing not to work, versus disabled? Who gets to choose this moral standard on behalf of the whole state?
- scrabble 13y agoWho pays for the basic income? What if working would provide you with a basic income? Would it then not make sense for people working poor jobs to quit and just get the guaranteed basic income along with all their free time?
- pessimizer 13y agoShouldn't they?
- scrabble 13y agoNo. I mean, I would. But there still needs to be someone to work those jobs. Also, a lot of times people gain a sense of self-worth from doing work that is appreciated. Whether they are getting it or not, or whether it's right or not, I believe this continues to hold true.
- pessimizer 13y agoI think that if those jobs can't pay a worker enough to maintain that worker, they should end. Business models based on slavery/poverty should be deprecated.
- thedufer 13y agoIn most proposals, basic income is covered by dropping the programs it replaces (social security, disability, etc.) and raising income taxes in all brackets. Basic income is something you get regardless of whether you work, so there is still incentive to work - if you want anything other than what basic income (which should cover little more than food + shelter in a relatively inexpensive area) can get you. Because this gives low-income people more power over their employers than before (they don't need to work), it probably allows you to repeal minimum wage laws, and let the wage fall somewhere reasonable.
- prostoalex 13y ago> raising income taxes in all brackets With basic income you wouldn't have that many - motivation to work at the lower bracket would suddenly decrease.
- kingmanaz 13y agoA guaranteed minimum income may heighten the importance of citizenship. Rather than a state being little more than a place to make money for any and all that arrive within a state's borders - in other words, a global free market - the state's prosperity would be tied to an individual's well being through ties of relation. Proof of citizenship would be of paramount in a guaranteed minimum income scheme, and yet the concept of citizenship seems to have been discarded for the notion of global citizenship in recent decades. It will be interesting to see how a guaranteed basic income survives in the age of border-less states.
- dnautics 13y agowhy should citizenship be important? Isn't this effectively nationalism, which is what drove WWI?
- kingmanaz 13y agoOver six billion people inhabit earth, the majority of which do not live in a state with a guaranteed minimum income. An open border policy coupled with free money will likely lead to increased economic migration. A life boat is only so big.
- rayiner 13y agoSimply more proof that "global citizenship" is a elitist idea incompatible with the basic welfare of people.
- clicks 13y agoI am an emigrant to the United States. I had to flee the place I'm from for political reasons (the place was unsafe for me and my family). But yet still I want the people of that place to do well... for two reasons I guess: 1) I just simply want everyone on this earth to do well, no matter what country they're citizens to and 2) because the people I left behind, a lot of them were family, friends. I knew them well, I still keep in touch with them. They're still among my closest friends. I want them to live the remainder of their lives peacefully, happily, prosperously. I know that you've got a somewhat similar background story as me... you/your family left Bangladesh for a better life. You were lucky in that you were privileged enough to have the means to get out of that place -- you know that a good half of the country did not. So, what about the people still there... surely you care a non-zero amount for their welfare. Right? We live in an interconnected world. Our actions, business decisions, political decisions have an effect on the entire world -- sometimes it's good, sometimes it isn't. An argument could be made that there are people out there in the world who are not doing well because of something that our country did. Right now you have Obama on a tour trying to drum up support for a war. His main reasoning is that America is the police of the world... 400 children were supposedly gassed, and so we have to step in to stop this injustice. There are injustices of different kinds being perpetrated in other countries... what makes them so different from Syria, that they don't deserve our help? I can understand prioritizing ... first comes the welfare of our own American citizens, and then the rest of the world... but completely ignoring the other world seems like a cruel and selfish thing to do. How is this not obvious?
- StandardFuture 13y agoYou say that you have seen very little on this subject yet somehow you are able to judge what is a step in the right direction? What is baffling is how many HNers who are apparently eager to downvote anyone in disagreement with the basic income argument and ask for counter-arguments yet fail to prove it in details (or even links) that the idea will work.
- wutbrodo 13y agoI think this stems from the fact that basic income is theoretically sound to anyone with even a rudimentary knowledge of economics. Now of course, it's DEFINITELY dangerous to assume that "theory supports it" is a slam-dunk case for anything, but preliminary results with pilot programs have also been encouraging[1] (the results have been fantastic, but the reliability of the data is not completely sound given how limited the programs are and how early it is). Between the fact that theory supports basic income and preliminary pilot programs provide (on-balance) cause for cautious optimism, it seems that the burden of counter-proof is squarely on the side of those saying "Of course it could never work", particularly since I personally have never seen an HN comment providing anything to back that up beyond "It's just obvious, can't you see". I haven't seen any data OR plausible theoretical explanation provided as a counter to basic income. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income#Examples_of_implementation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income#Examples_of_implem...
- StandardFuture 13y agoAh! A Link! Well after some review of the information on that Wikipedia article it is clear that all income pilot programs have only been administered to a minor degree in third world countries. The ideas of administering this system on a LARGE SCALE in a 'well-developed' country such as the US would probably bring many of the problems Friedrich Hayek theorizes it would. From Wikipedia: "It is obvious that for a long time to come it will be wholly impossible to secure an adequate and uniform minimum standard for all human beings everywhere, or at least that the wealthier countries would not be content to secure for their citizens no higher standards than can be secured for all men. But to confine to the citizens of particular countries provisions for a minimum standard higher than that universally applied makes it a privilege and necessitates certain limitations on the free movement of men across frontiers... we must face the fact that we here encounter a limit to the universal application of those liberal principles of policy which the existing facts of the present world make unavoidable." In other words people would flock from all over the world in DROVES to secure a spot in the unconditional free money system.
- kaa2102 13y agoEconomic models would show that low wage jobs are such due to lack of specialization and supply/demand for that job. Nonetheless, articles like this make "the Economy" sound more and more like the Matrix. Do humans exist merely to serve the Economy?
- beyondarmonia 13y agoNo they exist to serve the other humans who, in turn, serve them. What happens when other humans don't need their service? Who will serve them then?
- chamblin 13y agoI am not a slave, and I won't have any.
- programminggeek 13y agoWhat exactly is the difference between a guaranteed minimum income and welfare? Are people talking about you get paid X regardless of what you do, because if you want to see what that kind of thing looks like, look at life on an indian reservation. In many cases, that doesn't really solve the problems of poverty, alcoholism, etc. even if there is humungous opportunity to work, get a free education, etc. Some people don't want to do what society asks of them. How do you solve that?
- rayiner 13y agoMy wife worked on an Indian reservation. There is no "humungous opportunity to work, get a free education, etc." It's subsistence.
- netcan 13y agoPeople get very attached to their theory of how economies and civilizations work. On one side we have "Luddites" who think that machines are taking over. We have no use for most people's labour and we need to start dealing with that by having a guaranteed basic income or somesuch. Seems like common sense. What use are all the people that were working in factories or data entry or whatnot in the robot age! On the other side we have Misans? Ludwigians? (I dunno, I need a name for Ludwig von Mises people). They point out that this current crop of Luddites are just following in the footsteps of historical Luddites that think everyone will be unemployed because of tractors or looms. The sky never fell. Economies sort themselves out. Realistically, we don't know. Technology has been moving very fast for a long time and its accelerating. We don't know what this does to economic paradigms. How can anyone be as confident as so many people seem to be about this stuff.
- wutbrodo 13y agoActually, the Luddites in the current conversation are the ones decrying technological advancement itself. On the policy side, they tend to favor propping up old, inefficient industries (essentially subsidizing them at the expense of the rest of the population). A basic income has been considered common sense in economic theory for a long, long time (as in, it's been discussed by economists for at least a century). It has less to do with the obsolescence of human labor than it does to the fact that it's simply grossly inefficient to tie "the ability to take entrepreneurial risk" to "I was born middle-class or higher".
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoAnd thank you for crystallising that thought in my head - we are seeing a boom in entrepreneurship because the cost and risk of being one is dropping. And drop it further still will see an increase also - put your faith in human's need to do creative productive work. No matter what.
- AJ007 13y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Austrian_economics http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Austrian_economics
- drcode 13y agoIt's really distresses me whenever I read economic discussions on HN because basic economics is relatively simple and objective and because most folks on HN have the chops to understand this stuff, but it seems like many don't. In particular, one big facet of economics is equilibrium as it pertains to markets and most discussions here completely gloss over this (even though everyone here is completely comfortable with the concept of equilibria in other domains.) I think a lot still needs to be done, and can be done, to educate the public about basic economic principles. I hope to do my part to help by creating quality online resources for this in the near future. To give a more concrete example of what worries me: It should be obvious to everyone here that an idea like "minimum guaranteed income" is a very dangerous idea. Yes, there are credible economists that believe these things are a good idea (and it might even be a correct idea) but they believe this for very different, and much better informed reasons than the arguments being bandied about in this forum. Many of the arguments made here in favor of "minimum guaranteed income" are wrong and even the Economists who support these things would agree that your arguments are wrong. Anyway, as I said, I hope to create some online resources soon that will show more clearly what the difficulty is with these types of ideas. EDIT: For those asking me what the precise problem is with "minimum guaranteed income", I can't give you a satisfying answer, because I can only make an obvious qualitative argument right now (i.e. people will stop taking minimum wage jobs if they can get the same income without working, or by working in some less efficient fashion prescribed by a "guaranteed minimum income" scheme.) What needs to be done is to bring this discussion into the realm of mathematical "economic models" so we can quantify these things and ask questions like "How much will a guaranteed income help people?" and "How much will poor people be hurt indirectly by putting such a scheme in place?" (and of course ask additional meta questions such as "Is this model appropriate?") But these types of questions can't be addressed in an HN thread and require a more in depth treatment.
- johnchristopher 13y agoFrankly, I am still waiting for a good introduction to general economic principles. I literally feel like an idiot when following economic discussions: it seems to me like it's all a long infinite chain of valid arguments and counter-arguments that are perfectly valid, true and completely opposite. Hope you get something online soon.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoFor an interesting counterpoint : http://www.technologyreview.com/view/519016/stop-saying-robots-are-destroying-jobs-they-arent/ http://www.technologyreview.com/view/519016/stop-saying-robo...
- kingmanaz 13y agoThe pool of idle and unwanted labor will likely increase until the assumptions underlying the industrial revolution are questioned. Great public works of art and architecture are scarcely being erected today as their mere existence is seen to be "inefficient". Efficiency is a means rather than an end. From Tawney's "Acquisitive Society": "Such societies may be called Acquisitive Societies, because their whole tendency and interest and preoccupation is to promote the acquisition of wealth. The {30} appeal of this conception must be powerful, for it has laid the whole modern world under its spell. Since England first revealed the possibilities of industrialism, it has gone from strength to strength, and as industrial civilization invades countries hitherto remote from it, as Russia and Japan and India and China are drawn into its orbit, each decade sees a fresh extension of its influence. The secret of its triumph is obvious. It is an invitation to men to use the powers with which they have been endowed by nature or society, by skill or energy or relentless egotism or mere good fortune, without inquiring whether there is any principle by which their exercise should be limited. It assumes the social organization which determines the opportunities which different classes shall in fact possess, and concentrates attention upon the right of those who possess or can acquire power to make the fullest use of it for their own self-advancement. By fixing men's minds, not upon the discharge of social obligations, which restricts their energy, because it defines the goal to which it should be directed, but upon the exercise of the right to pursue their own self-interest, it offers unlimited scope for the acquisition of riches, and therefore gives free play to one of the most powerful of human instincts. To the strong it promises unfettered freedom for the exercise of their strength; to the weak the hope that they too one day may be strong. Before the eyes of both it suspends a golden prize, which not all can attain, but for which each may strive, the enchanting vision of infinite expansion. It assures men that there are no ends other {31} than their ends, no law other than their desires, no limit other than that which they think advisable. Thus it makes the individual the center of his own universe, and dissolves moral principles into a choice of expediences. And it immensely simplifies the problems of social life in complex communities. For it relieves them of the necessity of discriminating between different types of economic activity and different sources of wealth, between enterprise and avarice, energy and unscrupulous greed, property which is legitimate and property which is theft, the just enjoyment of the fruits of labor and the idle parasitism of birth or fortune, because it treats all economic activities as standing upon the same level, and suggests that excess or defect, waste or superfluity, require no conscious effort of the social will to avert them, but are corrected almost automatically by the mechanical play of economic forces. "Under the impulse of such ideas men do not become religious or wise or artistic; for religion and wisdom and art imply the acceptance of limitations. But they become powerful and rich. They inherit the earth and change the face of nature, if they do not possess their own souls; and they have that appearance of freedom which consists in the absence of obstacles between opportunities for self-advancement and those whom birth or wealth or talent or good fortune has placed in a position to seize them. It is not difficult either for individuals or for societies to achieve their object, if that object be sufficiently limited and immediate, and if they are not distracted from its pursuit by other considerations. The temper which dedicates itself to the cultivation of opportunities, and leaves obligations to take care of themselves, is set upon an object which is at once simple and practicable. The eighteenth century defined it. The twentieth century has very largely attained it. Or, if it has not attained it, it has at least grasped the possibilities of its attainment."
- kaonashi 13y ago>It means fixing inequality without the need to resort to redistributive taxation. National taxation in Britain doesn't redistribute, it regulates demand. The British government does not need to tax a pound to spend a pound. The limits on spending are inflation and real resources.
- kingmanaz 13y agoIt's interesting that this article has garnered so much interest on hacker news. Automation, streamlining, and outsourcing appears to have worked its way "up" to the STEM fields. The technical minded may soon received a taste of what the factory labor received in the eighties. http://www.vdare.com/print/17686 http://www.vdare.com/print/17686 Perhaps in another decade lawyers will face the chopping block, and thereafter the politicians who outsourced their nation.