4 ms·
Obviously complaints about spying are questioning whether the agency's purpose itself is just. Fulfilling one's purpose is still unethical if that purpose is u
by nitrogen 13y ago
Obviously complaints about spying are questioning whether the agency's purpose itself is just. Fulfilling one's purpose is still unethical if that purpose is unethical. Nobody excuses murder when the story is "Murderer commits murder. News at 11."
- Aloisius 13y agoThe agency's purpose is espionage. Espionage, last I checked, was illegal everywhere. Yet every country has spies. Being just or unethical doesn't factor into it. We know spying is unfair, but it is also something people have been doing since the dawn of civilization in order to get a leg up on the competition.
- CamperBob2 13y agoTechnically, the 'S' stands for 'Security,' not 'Spying.'
- mpyne 13y agoYou don't really think that an entire agency's remit can be specifically summed up within three generic words, do you? Hell, the Navy used to run their personnel management out of the "Bureau of Navigation".
- jlgreco 13y agoWhat the hell are you talking about, of course ethics factors into it! We, as a society, tolerate espionage so long as it is a necessary evil. One of the terms in the assessment of "necessary evil" is the ethics of what they are doing, the other term is how necessary it is. If your evil:necessary ratio goes to high then it program stops being something that any reasonable person can support. As an extreme example to demonstrate the point, if the CIA were installing cameras in the showers of randomly chosen UK citizens, that would be wildly unethical and have next to no benefit, thus making it wildly unacceptable. You can't just dismiss ethical criticism of a spy agency by saying "well they operate illegally anyway". Excluding the ethical term would be giving them a license to do anything they please.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Zigurd 13y agoPart of the problem is that "target" and "adversary" have been defined-down to "everyone" and "anyone who isn't naked to pervasive surveillance." In this case the topic is economic espionage. So who gets the information? Oil companies? Hedge funds? That's a bit different than intelligence on actual military threats. Just oil? Or can Embraer count on Boeing having their bid numbers? And, if so, is maintaining a friendly relationship with the US in Brazil's interests?
- marcosdumay 13y ago> ...is maintaining a friendly relationship with the US in Brazil's interests? Honestly, what alternative do we have? As a side note, I'd like to acknowledge the genial strategy of our leaders and voters when they removed any signal of intelligence from the higher positions in the government, and fouled the US plans of gaining any insight. I judged you badly, people, sorry.
- Apocryphon 13y agoThis sounds like Charles Stross's description of the future cold war in his novel Halting State. Instead of the "twentieth-century model, an electronic Pearl Harbor", the attacks are subtle. "Footnotes inserted in government reports feeding into World Trade Organization negotiating positions. Nothing we'd notice at first, nothing that would be obvious for a couple of years. You don't want to halt the state in its tracks, you simply want to divert it into a sliding of your choice."