3 ms·
Doesn't it stand to reason that if it were ever possible to travel back in time and kill Hitler that this would've already happened?
by aaronbrethorst 13y ago
Doesn't it stand to reason that if it were ever possible to travel back in time and kill Hitler that this would've already happened?
- twiceaday 13y agoWhat if by killing Hitler all future timelines ended a lot worse than this one? If it were ever possible to travel back in time, then we are living on the most optimal timeline according to some metric.
- pearjuice 13y agoThis so much. If time travel would ever become reality, wouldn't we already know?
- praptak 13y agoMaybe it happened, sort of. I mean our timeline being the result of killing Megahitler and replacing him with the Hitler we know and find him totally evil only because we can't compare him to Megahitler.
- lutusp 13y ago> Maybe it happened, sort of. I mean our timeline being the result of killing Megahitler and replacing him with the Hitler we know and find him totally evil only because we can't compare him to Megahitler. That might be a little tongue in cheek, but in fact, Hitler made a number of very bad decisions, like invading Russia, that a MegaHitler might have avoided. The history of that time could have been much worse with someone a little less nutty in charge. I bet someone from the so-called "History Channel" is reading this and planning to turn it into a pseudo-historical TV series.
- 1123581321 13y agoIt does not necessarily, though it is possible. 1. If it is possible to go back in time to kill Hitler, it is possible to go back in time to defend Hitler. There may be a stalemate. 2. We may be living in a timeline that is the result of killing another evil person. Hitler may be an acceptable result of that. 3. We may be at the forefront of time, i.e., there may be no future ahead of us to have already invented the time machine. Similarly, time travel may branch time so create a Hitler-less timeline for copies of ourselves (i.e. no causality.)
- ollysb 13y agoIt may not be possible to have a stable timeline that involves time travel i.e. if time travel exists, someone always ends up travelling back and messing up the timeline so that time travel isn't discovered. If timelines which include time travel are inherently unstable then the timeline(assuming there's only) would stabilise when time travel isn't used at any point. This does leave the door open for time travel tourism though, where you just go back and observe but without changing history in any way. The method of time travel would actually have to prevent changing the past though otherwise the potential for abuse would lead you back to the unstable timeline issue.
- lutusp 13y ago> Doesn't it stand to reason that if it were ever possible to travel back in time and kill Hitler that this would've already happened? No, because all the idealists who went back in time to kill Hitler (believe me, they were lined up around the block, and with no expectation of a safe return), according to multiple witnesses suddenly and inexplicably vanished just as they were pulling the trigger. Theorists say that outcome may have had something to do with the fact that their own existence depended in some perverse way on Hitler's uninterrupted existence. All except Martin Bormann, who (I bet you didn't know this) went down into the bunker and killed Hitler and his girlfriend Eva Braun -- and even shot Hitler's dog Blondi -- then made up something about Hitler committing suicide, then disappeared without a trace. Of the top Nazis who survived to the end of the war, most eventually were located, but Bormann totally disappeared. There's obvious speculation the Bormann was the time traveler we all imagined could have done it, and wished we could be. Too bad he didn't act sooner -- every month that Hitler lived caused the deaths of tens to hundreds of thousands. Okay, I just made that up. Ordinarily I wouldn't have to say that, but there are so many crazy ideas uncritically embraced these days that I realize someone might take this seriously.
- qbrass 13y agoI wouldn't use the word 'ever'. Time travel might be discovered so far into the future that time travelers simply don't care about changing things that happened in ancient history.
- Shorel 13y agoI would have killed Muhammad instead.