4 ms·
I really don't get the anti-religion sentiment here. If you find in religious teachings a way to live happily, productively, in a socially positive way, why is
by ams6110 13y ago
I really don't get the anti-religion sentiment here. If you find in religious teachings a way to live happily, productively, in a socially positive way, why is that a problem or anything to apologize for?
- CrankyPants 13y agoBecause this is HN and we're all expected to apologize for being anything but categorically dismissive of religion.
- MartinCron 13y agoI have one place, just one, where being a nonbeliever doesn't make me feel like a deviant distrusted outsider. I don't approve of disrespectful dismissals, but I understand why some people are seduced by it.
- dasil003 13y agoWow, time to move.
- devcpp 13y ago...and these are the most upvoted comments. HN is really a parody of itself.
- runn1ng 13y agoAs a person who is still kind of atheistic, I can understand that sentiment. Basically, scientific thinking forces constant verification of everything and encourages questioning, while religious thinking (even with buddhism) has far more dogmas and forces acceptance and, to a certain degree, discourages questioning. What drove me to zen-buddhism is the fact that the religious part is kept rather small and it is far more focused on daily practice.
- jjb123 13y agoOut of curiosity, why did you choose the words "still kind of atheist"?
- runn1ng 13y agoBecause I cannot really believe in a higher power. I don't believe in ghosts and try not to ve superstitious. I think most of the religious texts (even in buddhism) is bullshit. I constantly try to question everything. And yet I ended up in a zen group, basically a religious organization. (A little like Ivan Karamazov.)
- abhimir 13y agoupvoted for the Dostoevsky reference
- johnchristopher 13y ago> I think most of the religious texts (even in buddhism) is bullshit. I constantly try to question everything. Doubt is the beginning of wisdom, not the end. Most of the religious texts aren't bullshit. Especially the bible, which is anchored in a very old tradition and way of thinking. Theology is really an interesting body of knowledge. Out-of-context quotes of the bible, it is almost always cited like that, aren't relevant and detrimental. Running from judeo-christian tenets to a softened-up "occidentalised" Buddhism isn't more enlightening. Context: I am an atheist, my mother is a protestant pastor, her husband is a die-hard science chemist and that make for some interesting and heated winter evening discussions :)
- runn1ng 13y agoNo doubt buddhism in the west is "softened up", but you know what, maybe it works better that way. Christianity never made sense to me, with its insistence on guilt. You are supposed to feel guilty for what Adam did, guilty for what people did to Jesus, guilty for your inner thoughts, guilty for your supposed sins that the Satan put there. That's the opposite of what I need, thank you.
- crassus 13y agoIndeed, religion makes you happier[1], so its strange the author left it out of his ten points ""[9] and a review of 498 studies published in peer-reviewed journals concluded that a large majority of them showed a positive correlation between religious commitment and higher levels of perceived well-being and self-esteem and lower levels of hypertension, depression, and clinical delinquency.[12] A meta-analysis of 34 recent studies published between 1990 and 2001 found that religiosity has a salutary relationship with psychological adjustment, being related to less psychological distress, more life satisfaction, and better self-actualization.[13] Finally, a recent systematic review of 850 research papers on the topic concluded that "the majority of well-conducted studies found that higher levels of religious involvement are positively associated with indicators of psychological well-being (life satisfaction, happiness, positive affect, and higher morale) and with less depression, suicidal thoughts and behavior, drug/alcohol use/abuse."[14]" [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religion_and_happiness http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religion_and_happiness
- marcosdumay 13y agoI'd try an hypothesis that religion gives a huge fixed amount of happiness, at the cost of a small amount of unhappiness that slowly accumulates through the entire life, and even through generations. Looks like the most logical outcome for me, but I don't know how to test it - or even if there is enough data in the world to test it now. Anyway, the usual correlation is not causality applies here.
- crassus 13y agoGiven that the vast majority of all people that have ever lived have been religious, your hypothesis is going to be very hard to test. Now what do we call untestable beliefs?
- nbouscal 13y ago> religion makes you happier In this case the distinction between correlation and causation is actually very important. The alternative causal chain, that happy people are more likely to become religious, is highly plausible. Further, there are myriad plausible confounding variables. In many cases correlation can be taken as evidence of causation, but in this particular case it really should not be.
- hnriot 13y agoBecause those same set of teachings often differ very slightly from someone else's and usually ends in a war, or at the very least, a great deal of wasted bloodshed. See history for examples. Why you're supposed to apologize is because your religion - no matter which particular mythology you subscribe to, has likely caused an immeasurable amount of sorrow for many others.
- crassus 13y agoWhere are the peaceable, prosperous, and happy atheist nations hiding?
- marcosdumay 13y agoThey have been conquered. Literally. At older times religion was one of the biggest tools used to create armies, and conquer the neighbors' land.
- crassus 13y agoName some of them.
- CaptainZapp 13y agoYou may want to educate yourself by looing into the 30 year war, as one of many, many exmples.
- crassus 13y agoI'm sorry, which were the atheist nations participating in the 30 years' war?
- vukmir 13y ago>"Where are the peaceable, prosperous, and happy atheist nations hiding?" In Scandinavia, perhaps?
- Dewie 13y agoI guess it's the same reason why the top recommendations in places like this for feeling better when you're down is things like exercise: the effects of exercise is well-documented and fairly reproduce-able. You put activity in and then you get dopamine out. You get to talk about your well being as a (seemingly) easily measured and to a degree manipulable brain chemistry. As soon as you start to wander into territory where the effects are harder to measure and the science behind it (if there is any empirical schience behind it) is not as hard as sciences like biology, like psychology (or, god forbid, self development literature), all of a sudden that's too "wooey" and shrinky. As for religion; if they don't believe in it, then it's just some placebo-like effect if you get anything positive out of the "wooey" practices. And placebos are even more finnicky and is (by it's very nature) not something that you're well served trying to find the cause and effect for.
- yaddayadda 13y agolayperson cite for finicky placebos: http://asserttrue.blogspot.com/2013/01/are-placebos-really-sugar-pills.html http://asserttrue.blogspot.com/2013/01/are-placebos-really-s...
- rorrr2 13y agoBecause most religious teachings are horrible at best. Most religious people don't even read their religious texts, yet they try to force them onto everyone. Meditation is actually different from religion, since it demonstrably works, there are scientific studies. Sam Harris, for instance, strongly supports it.