6 ms·
Since this is HN, let's try an analogy. Pretend you have two clients: One that actively engages in the process and gives you feedback and responds to questions
by joezydeco 13y ago
Since this is HN, let's try an analogy.
Pretend you have two clients: One that actively engages in the process and gives you feedback and responds to questions, and one that crosses their arms, never gets back to you with answers to questions and says "just give me what I want when I want it".
Which would you be happier to work with? Which do you think would be more forgiving if there's a problem? Which would you work with again?
My wife and I volunteer heavily at our childrens' school. From my experience teachers know, consciously or subconsciously, which families care about their kids' performance in school and which families acknowledge the teachers as people and not automatons that turn tax dollars into educated children.
When that day comes where your child is struggling and the teacher is making a decision in their head to try one more time or just give up for the day, I'd rather they opt for the former and not the latter. It happens and I've seen it first hand.
- mikeash 13y agoSince this is HN, let's go for analogies and anecdotes instead of science? If what you say is true, why doesn't it appear in the data?
- xaa 13y agoFrom the original study: The children of parents who are more involved in school activities, like parent-teacher meetings or volunteering in the school, also show poorer reading performance. This is probably because parents of children who are having behavioural difficulties or who are progressing slowly in school are more likely to call the teacher to seek ways to improve their child’s performance, or to receive a call from the teacher to discuss the child’s school work. Similarly, parents of low-achieving students are more likely to seek further engagement with the school to find ways to improve their child’s progress or behaviour. This is indeed a good strategy: other research with longitudinal data highlights how more parental involvement in the school improves children’s performance because teachers may pay more attention to children of involved parents, and school may become more important to children if they see that their parents are also invested in their progress (Pomerantz et al.,2007) (Table 3.1b). So I would say that Slate somewhat misrepresented the data.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- swanson 13y agoBut wasn't that a big point in the article? That caring about your children's academic performance certainly is important, but that spending 6 hours baking cookies doesn't equate to helping them learn at home? Your comment seems very dismissive but only offers anecdotal evidence that the article is directly addressing. In your example, it seems equally likely that a teacher who knows the parent(s) will help a child practice areas of deficiency at home would not "give up for the day". If you were to ask me, it seems more futile to spend extra time helping a child if I know they aren't going to be in an environment that fosters learning just because their parent helped cut out bingo cards.
- dalke 13y agoIf it's an analogy you want: You ask both clients specific questions related to the project, some of which require them to do research and investigate which solution they want. You also ask them to participate in the ping-pong tournament and the restocking of the sodas. Client 1 answers the project-related questions fully, but not the others, and complains that you should pay someone to stock the sodas from the fees they pay you. Client 2 does the social-related tasks and as a result spends less time working on resolving the project-related questions. Which project do you think will be more successful? Now for the hard part - which client will be happier with the result? In the latter, they know more about the developers, are more likely to be friends with the developers, and know how hard the developers worked, so might be lenient with subpar results. While the former is more likely to be mad if the results aren't as good as expected. The thesis is that your time is better spent teaching your kid at home than volunteering heavily at the schools. If you spend, what, 5 hours per week at school? That's an extra hour of at-home teaching you could spend with your children. Probably more, because there's less travel overhead. What teacher would say that such a family does not care about their kids' performance in school? The thesis is the teacher would send you information about how your child is struggling, along with advice on what you could do to help at home, rather than this indirect approach you prefer, where the teacher uses the proxy information of your physical involvement at school as encouragement for trying harder with a student.
- jack-r-abbit 13y ago> If you spend, what, 5 hours per week at school? That's an extra hour of at-home teaching you could spend with your children. This makes the assumption that time spent at school is also the same time you would be available to help with studies at home. But most volunteering at school is during school hours (while your child is also at school) and is not mutually exclusive to you also helping with studies at home, after school.
- dalke 13y agoWithout hard numbers I of course have to make some assumptions on the situation. I don't mean for it to apply to any one specific person. We are talking, after all, on general trends on the nation-wide scale. I submit that it's uncommon for both parents have free time during school hours, and also have free time at home in the evening to help with studies. When do the parents work?
- cafard 13y agoOn my way to work I see many kids going to school. Some are neighbors' kids. They are almost all from two-parent households, they are all children of college-educated parents, they are all from families who can free up time to volunteer now and then, some have parents who are or have been teachers. Other kids I see on the bus. They are from families with a good deal less money. In many cases the parents are working long hours, perhaps at two jobs. In most cases, the parents are not college educated. In a fair number there is only one adult in the household. Probably the parents haven't much time to volunteer. I suspect that if anything the parents of the second group think more highly of teachers: the teachers who are not positively incompetent are teaching their children something that the parents likely cannot. The parents of the first group often think that in many cases they know better than the teachers. Some such parents--not, that I know of, my neighbors--regard the teachers as servants to be kept in order. So I think that as a proxy for respect, volunteering has its drawbacks.