4 ms·
As someone who does work in this industry, a spike before the number is completely explainable without anyone having early knowledge. Lots of market participan
by kasey_junk 13y ago
As someone who does work in this industry, a spike before the number is completely explainable without anyone having early knowledge.
Lots of market participants are speculators. If you are speculating on the results of the number, you need to make sure your orders are in before it. Everyone in the low latency game knows when the number is coming, so it makes sense for speculation orders to go in when they do.
Now if Nanex wanted to prove something, they could show that a high percentage of those orders are consistently on the "right" side of the number, something they haven't done.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoNot only that, but if market makers know volatility is about to increase, they will jump in early to get to the top of the queue.
- theorique 13y agoAbsolutely true. A spike in orders in advance of an "important" time implies that people are trading in anticipation of market movements around that time. It does not, on its own, imply that anyone has material, non-public information in advance of anybody else.
- deveac 13y agoI think that the unethical (illegal?) problem is already inked in black and white where the three tiers of market information recipients exist. I didn't make that clear at all in my comment, but yeah, I agree that the 4th tier is definitely speculation at this point. I agree that it would be interesting to look for the payout skew for the numbers; that would just verify an additional transgression in my book. Unfortunately nobody reads my book so to speak :)
- theorique 13y agoIt's neither illegal nor unethical for a private entity to invest money and manpower to compile statistical data, to release it in a staggered fashion, and to charge purchasers for early access.
- Incinr8r 13y agoIt sounds innocuous enough with absolutely no context, but the fact is that they are selling market-moving data, and they know it. They know exactly what staggered release of this data does: create an uneven playing field for all but the wealthiest investors. This causes the creation of false profits that don't come from actual risk, or underlying value of securities, but by screwing retail investors, pension funds, and anyone else who doesn't start off with absurd amounts of money to begin with. Sure sounds unethical to me.
- theorique 13y agoOf course they are selling market moving data. If it weren't market-moving, why would anybody pay a premium price for it? Just because something is market-moving does not make it "material, non-public information" about a specific company. And just because something is market-moving doesn't mean that a trader or hedge fund or whoever makes use of this data will gamble correctly and win every time. You see people paying for privileged access to information all over the place. For example, on a slower time scale, industry analysts hawk expensive monthly newsletters or one-time reports. Bloomberg terminals provide news feeds and market data for the bargain price of ~$2000 a month.
- Incinr8r 13y agoI'm no financial or legal expert, but by market moving I am referring to data that moves the aggregate market in a fairly predictable direction. If jobs or the consumer confidence numbers go up, the market follows and vice versa. If your system gets this data before everyone else you essentially have a money-printing machine (at the expense of everyone else). If you report data that's valuable because the federal government uses it in monetary policy decisions, then just push it to your customers as soon as its available for a flat rate. When a company intentionally holds back data to make money on an incremental time difference, I'm sorry, that seems scammy and unethical to me. As to Bloomberg consoles, that seems like a slightly different case, but if they similarly tier, then it is also unethical IMO. Don't pit your customers against each other.
- danielweber 13y agoI don't want to dismiss the problem, but if the report is supposed to come out at 9:55:23, anyone who is willing to be on the other side of the trade at 9:55:22 is either being greedy or stupid. Refuse to trade for the 10 seconds before 9:55:23 and you know you won't be a victim. You might also miss out on something big, but you can't have it both ways.
- Daniel_Newby 13y ago> ... anyone who is willing to be on the other side of the trade at 9:55:22 is either being greedy or stupid. Or they have paid for their own research and analysis.