9 ms·
Australian opposition vows to implement Internet filter by default
- Wingman4l7 13y agoThe Australian government is always threatening to implement draconian filter, censorship, or data-logging plans; luckily, in true government form, they never carry through on it. It's a pity that such things are the only exposure the tech crowd has to Australia, instead of more compelling things like the massive and ambitious National Broadband Network fiber-to-the-home infrastructure project.
- nwh 13y agoThreatening? We already have a mandatory filter[0] with no auditing of the ban list, and a government who gives full NSA access to all our data. [0]: Includes child porn and "morally offensive" sites, whatever that means.
- Wingman4l7 13y agoHunh... never heard of anyone bumping up against it. How is it mandatory -- ISPs required to implement it upon pain of fines? Or did they just tell Telstra to do it, since they own all the lines? As far as the data-logging goes, I meant it as done by the native government -- although I agree that's largely a "tomato, tomahto" distinction.
- tomflack 13y agoHe's referring to the AMCA blacklist, which while not a filter in the sense we usually discuss is a kind of internet censorship.
- prawn 13y agoThe existing filter is supposedly for the vilest, illegal things. It has however caught some pretty plain stuff in the past, though is largely forgotten now.
- tomflack 13y agoIf the Liberal/National Coalition manages to achieve a majority in the Senate, I think this will be the time we see a filter become law.
- gilgoomesh 13y ago> fiber-to-the-home Or, as it will be known on Saturday evening: copper to the "good luck with that".
- Wingman4l7 13y agoUgh, don't remind me -- so shortsighted! (Some context: the opposition party -- which apparently is going to win? I don't follow politics too closely -- was suggesting that the NBN project could be done more cheaply if it was fiber-to-the-node instead... thus completely defeating the purpose of the network upgrade.)
- vacri 13y agoThat's the thing that puzzles me. Fast internet benefits businesses more than residents, and it's the 'business party' that's against it. A colleague says that there are Murdoch's hands in the till on this one, given that fast internet threatens his TV offerings.
- jsmeaton 13y agoWE NEED TO CONTROL THE SPENDING!!!!!!!!! That's basically all it comes down to. Not enough people care about what a fast network can do for the country, and they've been brainwashed to think that the economic management of the last few years has been appalling. It's really really strange. People all of a sudden seem to give a shit about how much we are spending and think it's a bad thing, when every economic commenter has said it's been managed brilliantly. It looks like a lot of people are trying to be smart and are failing hugely.
- Wingman4l7 13y agoWell it doesn't help that all those pits have asbestos in them -- but that's not the project's fault. That would have to have been cleaned up eventually anyway. It's the same problem the US has IMO: no one wants to support grand, forward-looking projects that are going to take longer than a term in office. That's why poor NASA has its funding yoyo-ed around a 4-year presidential election cycle, and can't ever follow through on the bigger projects anymore.
- prawn 13y agoAnd as the article notes, this pledge has been snuck into a document that will be read by few, and released after an "advertising blackout" point has been passed which prevents TV advertising (and thus critical ads) for the final couple of days before the election. Can anyone explain to me how this isn't a really low move?
- THE_PUN_STOPS 13y agoNo. It's a really low move.
- stephenaturner 13y agoOh it's nothing but a low move, introduced by a vile bunch who would prefer Rupert Murdoch controlled all media.
- westicle 13y agoAs a citizen, this is impossible to fight. This issue is regularly floated by both "sides" of politics, usually to much criticism (on both technical and moral grounds). It is like the Hydra - chop off one head and it will simply grow two more. This time the policy announcement is especially reprehensible, coming 48 hours before an election which is all but decided in advance and buried in fine-print. No doubt the new government will announce that it has "a clear mandate" to implement the filter as it was tucked away in their last-minute policy announcements.
- Wingman4l7 13y agoIt's really depressing -- I recall when I used to browse Slashdot a few years ago, all you would ever see tagged "Australia" was censorship and filter proposals. EDIT: Also depressing is how long the relevant Wikipedia article is: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_censorship_in_Australia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_censorship_in_Austral...
- ballard 13y agoThat might ax a few plans for US -> AU citizenry. What country without US extradition is the most socio-libertarian/anarchist friendly?
- Wingman4l7 13y agoGood luck with that -- it's a royal PITA to get citizenship in AU. Usually the countries without US extradition treaties have much more worrying issues, like abysmal civil / human rights records, IIRC. Also, it doesn't stop the US from leaning on them to extradite you as a special case, anyway.
- ballard 13y agoSometimes what is good is difficult to attain. Otherwise everyone would. (It's a good thing a dear friend is an immigration atty.)
- 13y ago
- damncabbage 13y agoSnuck in less than 48 hours before the federal election, in the media blackout[1] period that immediately precedes it. Disgusting. 1. http://www.aec.gov.au/faqs/election_advertising.htm#blackout http://www.aec.gov.au/faqs/election_advertising.htm#blackout
- lessnonymous 13y agoThe sneaky fucks think they have carte blanche from the electorate and so are releasing policies either after the blackout or possibly not at all. "Vote for us to end the deficit. We'll work out how if you vote for us." (IMHO more likely to send us into the recession we've avoided thus far)
- ryan-allen 13y agoA recession might be good for rich programmer geeks like us. We can keep on working getting paid through the wazoo and start buying up properties when everyone else is suffering and defaulting. Just sayin'.
- Wingman4l7 13y agoI really wish your average Joe in AU would quit playing Real Estate Tycoon -- it drives up the prices and makes homes too costly to afford for those who want to own a home and have it paid off earlier than 30 years.
- ryan-allen 13y agoWell in my case, currently having exactly 0 houses a drop in the market would be welcome.
- InclinedPlane 13y agoThat is absolutely reprehensible. This is precisely why blackouts are such a bad idea. It turns out they are extraordinarily easy to game.
- acd 13y agoDanger will robinson! This is internet censorship. Going down the slippery slope of restricting free speech on the Internet. Is it that the politicians themselves who can't stop surfing to those adult sites and want to stop it by censoring it for everybody?
- stephenaturner 13y agoWell they snuck this in at the last minute hoping no one would notice and their supporters would be too dumb to care... Based on current opinion polls sadly good assumptions. Add this to killing the NBN as another stake in the heart of our digital future...
- supercoder 13y agoUgh... we're stuffed.
- malbs 13y agoThere is already a filter in place. It was utilised most recently earlier this year. ASIC maintains a database of fraud/scam websites, and blocks them so as to minimise the impact on unsuspecting victims. "The Federal Government has confirmed its financial regulator has started requiring Australian Internet service providers to block websites suspected of providing fraudulent financial opportunities, in a move which appears to also open the door for other government agencies to unilaterally block sites they deem questionable in their own portfolios." (http://delimiter.com.au/2013/05/15/interpol-filter-scope-creep-asic-ordering-unilateral-website-blocks/ http://delimiter.com.au/2013/05/15/interpol-filter-scope-cre...) And direct press release from ASIC: "ASIC has already blocked access to these websites." http://www.asic.gov.au/asic/asic.nsf/byheadline/13-061MR+ASIC+warns+consumers+about+Global+Capital+Wealth?openDocument http://www.asic.gov.au/asic/asic.nsf/byheadline/13-061MR+ASI...
- Fuxy 13y agoWill they cut with the porn bullshit we all know this is all about power and controlling what people can see. Once a filter is set up it's very easy to block any website they want. Porn/sex shouldn't be taboo to begin with it's how we all got on this planet. I grew up on the internet without filters and I'm happy to report I'm just fine stop filtering my shit.
- XorNot 13y agoOnce the filter is setup its free political muck to ask a politician if their home connection is "opted in to pornography".
- goombastic 13y agoSomeone needs to start doing version control systems for legislative bills and documents in governments everywhere. Most lawmakers are ugly sneaks and we will need to watch their every move.
- Wingman4l7 13y agoI don't know if this would really fix anything, but it sure would be awesome to see the one-line pork additions to a bill tied directly to a Senator's name.
- tlrobinson 13y agoIf only we had "git blame" for legislation.
- jacques_chester 13y agoThe Australian lawmaking process is more transparent than the US. Bills cannot be amended in committee behind closed doors. All amendments must be moved by an MP, from the floor of the House or Senate. We also have the strictest party discipline in the world, so there's very little room for back-scratching. Finally, our Constitution bans any bill about appropriations from dealing with any other subject. So you can't tack riders onto other subjects.
- Wingman4l7 13y agoNot to mention that you give third parties a fighting chance for representation with your preferential voting system. That's a really clever appropriations bit in your Constitution. I've often thought that the US needs some sort of Kevin Bacon Law -- all the measures within a bill have to be related to each other with only a few degrees of separation. No more banning internet poker in a port security bill! (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SAFE_Port_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SAFE_Port_Act)
- vaughan 13y agoThere are some problems with preferential voting in the Senate though as Antony Green raises (http://www.abc.net.au/news/2013-08-29/green-senate-ballot-system-threatens-more-than-our-eyesight/4921966 http://www.abc.net.au/news/2013-08-29/green-senate-ballot-sy...). 95% of Australians will defer to their parties' chosen preferences, rather than stating their preferences explicitly. This is mostly because you have to number hundreds of boxes if you chose to vote "below the line". Some argue that parties' preferences will not always reflect the intention of the voter - but they get away with it because its too difficult to vote preferentially.
- otikik 13y agoI point my finger at you and laugh, Australia.
- contingencies 13y agoClearly, vote Wikileaks.
- westicle 13y agoI upvoted this, but I can't agree with it enough. Whatever you think about Assange, at least he can be relied upon to oppose: internet censorship, technologically retarded broadband infrastructure and sexual consent laws.
- michh 13y agoWait what? Opposing sexual consent laws is a good thing? I could see why Assange is in favor of legalizing rape given his own personal history with the crime, but still...
- westicle 13y agoOff-colour joke... I'm pretty sure his policy platform makes no mention of criminal law reform. It was more a meta-comment on "Think what you will about Assange".
- mehwoot 13y agoWikileaks preferenced One Nation ahead of the Greens, Labor and Liberals in the senate. Since the final senate seat will likely come down to One Nation / Greens in 1 or more states, the only effective outcome of voting for them is a vote for One Nation.
- sspiff 13y agoIt's so easy to convince someone who understands nothing about how computers and the Internet works that "filtering out (child) pornography" is a good thing, easy to do and won't cause any collateral damage. I wonder if all these spying scandals and the rise of censorship in the West will lead to an noticeable increase in the size of tor/i2p/...
- Wingman4l7 13y agoWhat is needed is a simple "throwing the baby out with the bathwater" analogy that effectively communicates how it's a) impossible to effectively filter out such things and b) how easy it is to abuse said filters once they're in place. Maybe something using cars? =P
- sspiff 13y agoUnfortunately, for the vast majority of voters (or people in general), counter arguments don't really matter if they liked what they heard in the first place. Then they just think "what you're saying makes things more difficult, I'd rather not hear it".
- Wingman4l7 13y agoDon't forget the studies implying that, when presented with evidence to the contrary, people will hold their original beliefs stronger. The more I learn about everything, the less certain I am about anything; I wish more people were the same. The idea is to come up with a metaphor that is as short and sweet as it is compelling. As much as the idea of "selling" truth disgusts me, we need to "market" the unpleasant realities of a filter as effectively as politicians have sold the lie of it being "for the children" in order to have a fighting chance of preventing it.
- sspiff 13y agoI hadn't heard that before, can you provide any reference or source for this? I think I'll need it in future discussions :)
- beedogs 13y ago"The filter will be contained in software installed in either people's smartphones or modems ... which can be disabled at their option." - Malcolm Turnbull (Liberal party shadow communications minister) on Hack[1] tonight. Fucking scumbags. 48 hours before we go to the polls. And apparently they plan on hacking our devices in order to implement it? They have no clue. [1] 27:05 at http://mpegmedia.abc.net.au/triplej/hack/daily/hack_thurs_2013_9_5.mp3 http://mpegmedia.abc.net.au/triplej/hack/daily/hack_thurs_20...
- Wingman4l7 13y agoTo be fair that was probably just an ad-libbed statement by a politician who has absolutely no clue how software and filters work. Politician: "It'll be like an iPhone app, only somehow mandatory, right?" IT Consultant: "Uh... kinda sorta..."
- progx 13y agoWho is next: Canada, New Zealand, USA ? Make sense, this 5 Countries work really close together, as we know it from PRISM.
- joedj 13y agoAccording to a radio interview I just heard with the opposition shadow minister Malcolm Turnbull on TripleJ, this is a "software filter" that ISPs will install and enable on "home broadband routers and smartphones" by default, and there will be "no server-side filter". While this of course sounds terribly stupid, pointless, costly and technically infeasible, it also sounds fairly innocuous as far as these types of proposals go. It sounds like users would be able to enable/disable it whenever they like, without adding their name to a central database at the Ministry for Censorship (unlike the UK proposal?). He declared that the point was to enable this kind of filtering for people who aren't technical enough to set it up for themselves, and that ultimately the decision and responsibility lies with parents. In fact, it sounds a lot better than the system the current government (who is of course already criticising this policy) tried to ram down our throats recently. (Disclosure: I just heard about this policy on the way home from voting early, and the intent of my vote was to benefit the current governing party more than the opposition proposing this system, after my preferred minor candidates are eliminated...I like Malcolm Turnbull a lot, but I don't like his party's policies any more than I suspect he does, at the moment.)
- resdirector 13y agoTo anyone not familiar with the Australian Constitution, we do not have a bill of rights and no explicit guarantee of freedom of expression. (AFAIK freedom of expression is an implied right http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Australian_constitutional_law#Freedom_of_political_communication http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Australian_constitutional_law#F...).
- jacques_chester 13y agoFreedom of expression about political matters is implied. Other subjects? Nope.
- Wingman4l7 13y agoThis blew me away when I first heard about it. My favorite WTF example of the AU government trampling on freedom of expression? The banning of a TV ad arguing for the legalization of voluntary euthanasia[1], and, even more alarmingly, the "crime" of using a "a telephone, fax, email or the internet to discuss or research assisted suicide."[2] [1]: http://www.theage.com.au/national/proeuthanasia-tv-ad-ban-a-violation-of-free-speech-20100912-1570f.html http://www.theage.com.au/national/proeuthanasia-tv-ad-ban-a-... [2]: http://www.theaustralian.com.au/news/suicide-drug-of-choice-in-mail/story-e6frg6no-1111119129660 http://www.theaustralian.com.au/news/suicide-drug-of-choice-...
- nwh 13y ago"The Coalition said it would work with mobile phone operators to install the filters onto handsets." Yeah, that's going to happen.
- peterkelly 13y agoI've lost count of the number of times various parties have tried to implement Internet filtering in Australia. It almost seems to be a seasonal cycle, whereby some legislation gets proposed/approved, the IT industry and civil liberties advocates explain why it's both wrong and can't work, and then it sort of fades away from view. Both sides have said everything they have to say on the issue. I'm of the belief that it's only for point scoring with various conservative groups that the idea even continues to be floated. I think even Tony Abbott (the opposition candidate and almost-certain victor) probably understands how it can't possibly be made to work but is just going along to placate certain segments of the electorate.
- Wingman4l7 13y agoA cycle! Seriously! I recall when I used to browse Slashdot a few years ago, all you would ever see tagged "Australia" was censorship and filter proposals. Not a good look for Australia. Let's hope that you're right and they're not actually ever taking it seriously.
- Divinite 13y agoLooks like someone started a petition! https://www.change.org/petitions/liberal-party-of-australia-stop-the-internet-filter https://www.change.org/petitions/liberal-party-of-australia-...
- lostsock 13y agoMalcolm Turnbull (@TurnbullMalcolm) tweeted at 7:43 PM on Thu, Sep 05, 2013: Policy released today wrongly indicated we supported an opt out system of internet filtering. That is not our policy and never has been. (https://twitter.com/TurnbullMalcolm/status/375554766153068544 https://twitter.com/TurnbullMalcolm/status/37555476615306854...)
- lostsock 13y agoMalcolm Turnbull (@TurnbullMalcolm) tweeted at 7:43 PM on Thu, Sep 05, 2013: Policy released today wrongly indicated we supported an opt out system of internet filtering. That is not our policy and never has been. (https://twitter.com/TurnbullMalcolm/status/375554766153068544 https://twitter.com/TurnbullMalcolm/status/37555476615306854...)
- lostsock 13y agoMalcolm Turnbull (@TurnbullMalcolm) tweeted at 7:43 PM on Thu, Sep 05, 2013: Policy released today wrongly indicated we supported an opt out system of internet filtering. That is not our policy and never has been. (https://twitter.com/TurnbullMalcolm/status/375554766153068544 https://twitter.com/TurnbullMalcolm/status/37555476615306854...)
- resdirector 13y agoAnd now the would-be communications minister, Malcolm Turnbull, has said it's all a big misunderstanding: https://twitter.com/TurnbullMalcolm/status/375554766153068544 https://twitter.com/TurnbullMalcolm/status/37555476615306854....
- Wingman4l7 13y ago"Oops, turns out people were actually paying attention... and they really didn't like it... quick! Backpedal!" Classic.
- ryan-allen 13y agoWait nope! They're backtracking http://www.abc.net.au/news/2013-09-05/no-internet-filter-says-turnbull/4939156 http://www.abc.net.au/news/2013-09-05/no-internet-filter-say...
- resdirector 13y agoLooks like they've just posted a correction: http://www.liberal.org.au/latest-news/2013/09/05/coalitions-policy-enhance-online-safety-children http://www.liberal.org.au/latest-news/2013/09/05/coalitions-... Sweet Jesus....playing it fast and loose with freedom of expression just hours before an election.
- tomflack 13y agoBreaking news: on ABC News 24 right now Abbott just said he doesn't support a filter and got the policy wrong.
- maxden 13y agohttp://www.abc.net.au/news/2013-09-05/no-internet-filter-says-turnbull/4939156 http://www.abc.net.au/news/2013-09-05/no-internet-filter-say... "The correct position is that the Coalition will encourage mobile phone and internet service providers to make available software which parents can choose to install on their own devices to protect their children from inappropriate material." === Sounds more reasonable if accurate.
- tomflack 13y agoIt's indeed VERY different to "opt-out" as they had stated. What a mistake!
- damncabbage 13y ago"Mistake". It was likely just testing the waters.
- jacques_chester 13y agoThat's actually the policy they had when they were last in government. It had very low takeup.
- shadowmint 13y ago"We had no intention of accidentally releasing this policy decision so close to an election. We will correct the version online immediately with our temporary watered down version until we've won." great.
- DigitalSea 13y agoThe Australian election just keeps on getting better and better. I cannot believe Tony Abbott is actually going to win if the polls are to be believed... I get Kevin Rudd messed up, but I think he was honestly trying his best to right his wrongs after recently becoming leader again. The NBN and the fact Labor aren't for a mandatory Internet filter are two good reasons alone to vote for Labor. I believe this is Abbott letting his Catholic views get in the way of policy. Much like his opinions on gay marriage and abortion align with that of other Catholics, he's a puppet. And even if Kevin was a puppet, at least he went about hiding it a bit better. In six months or so people will realise they made a mistake voting for LNP but it'll be too late. Filtering will not only be used to filter adult content, it'll be used to block whatever content Abbott and church/parent groups of Australia want banned. It'll also block legitimate content as the test run of a filter a little while ago actually showed. This is just the beginning. A filter is nothing compared to what Abbott will be capable of doing in his position of power. He is hell-bent on proving a point by rescuing the economy by taking dirty lobbyist money in exchange for a few lax laws and blocked sites here and there.
- octotoad 13y agoThat was quick. Looks like they've backflipped on it already.
- nwh 13y agohttp://www.abc.net.au/news/2013-09-05/no-internet-filter-says-turnbull/4939156 http://www.abc.net.au/news/2013-09-05/no-internet-filter-say... They've now backed out on it. No mandatory filter. The report was "poorly worded".
- austerity 13y agoAs a human being I am angered by these rapid advancements of Internet censorship in the developed world. As someone in the business of circumventing said censorship I am excited to have the solvent westerners as my clients in additional to generally poor third-world folk we are currently serving.