10 ms·
A Close Look at Dark Souls’ Ingenious Difficulty
- hobs 13y agoI wanted to read more, but it was basically a walkthrough of the game... I will have to save this one for later.
- roarroar 13y agoDark Souls is a bigger, less polished version of Demon's Souls. It has a problem with hidden information that can only be discovered through trial-and-error. Demon's Souls was like this too, but the scope was small enough that it didn't cause big problems. Not sure what there is to praise about the character builds. In both games there's an easy and obvious way to get a bulletproof character: plow everything you have into vitality and endurance. The difficulty of Dark Souls (which is harder than Demon's Souls) should be applauded, but it's really quite disorganized, and there seems to be a lot of misplaced praise out there for the trial-and-error, but this part of the game really just sloppiness. It needs better clues - dialogue, books, inscriptions on walls, etc. The soapstone sign system is just pure laziness. Trying to play it off as some genius design choice is degenerate. There's a reason both titles give the wiki URL on the PS3 cases..
- robdor 13y agoI disagree that a high vit + end build is bulletproof. I'm absolutely certain that most anybody could destroy that build easily in PvP. One of the great things about the build system in Dark Souls is a build that is great for PvE may not be a great build for PvP.
- roarroar 13y agoOkay, so it's bulletproof for PvE.
- autarch 13y agoIt's really not though. At least for me, I find that there's a balance between giving and receiving damage in the boss fights. While having higher vitality (more HP) lets you survive longer, unless you can also dish out a lot of damage the fights can become incredibly difficult. Basically, the question is how many times you can hit the boss by taking advantage of their timing versus how many times you screw up trying to take advantage of their timing. If you have more HP you can screw up a few more times but if you're not dealing much damage you end up having to avoid screw ups for a long time in some boss fights. Then there are the fights like the Four Kings where you really want to be doing higher DPS or else things get really messy. Personally, I found the easiest build for PvE to be a sorcery build focused on high DPS. With a high enough intelligence you can deal a lot of ranged damage, which makes avoiding being hit that much easier.
- roarroar 13y agoA Fire Uchigatna+6 or +7 makes Four Kings easy if you have 20 estus flasks and plenty of vitality. Since this weapon doesn't scale with stats you barely have to alter your build to use it. I'm not saying it's the only viable build, nor the only fun one. I'm saying that the builds aren't exactly a work of genius, which is I suppose unavoidable when on your first run there are basically zero clues as to what's to come. For example, how are you supposed to know that Four Kings will need high DPS? A better way to do all this would be to foreshadow every boss in some way. For example, NG being a very cut-down version of the game with simplified, shorter areas and weaker bosses, with NG+ being the real deal deal. This is basically how everyone who really loves the game plays it anyway: bumble around through your first play-through, then on the second and third goes you can start making more conscious choices, since you have some idea of what's to come.
- vacri 13y agoThis is basically how everyone who really loves the game plays it anyway No, it's not - NG+ is much easier than NG, because you start decked with all your previous equipment. People who really love the game do NG runs staying at level 1. I've put in lots of hours, and NG+ is dull because you already have anything and can go anywhere. The challenge is gone.
- Joe-Z 13y agoI fully agree with you on the hidden information problem. So many people seem to kind of praise this though. I, for one, started 3 characters and with every one of them I ran into a problem at around the time when the lightning spear becomes too weak. Pretty much the only option I saw was to craft a weapon, but the crafting system just isn't explained at all. The only way to learn something about the crafting is, as you said, trial & error, which is just frustrating, especially if you have to sacrifice rare resources for that. Basically if you want to play the game without the wiki (which still feels a bit like cheating for me) you either have to put in insane amounts of effort (I mean come on, it's still only a game!), or you're fucked. I really hope Dark Souls 2 is better in offering at least basic explanations of the friggin' game mechanics. </rant>
- octaveguin 13y agoDiablo 2 was arguably terribly designed similarly - character builds required external information to progress to the harder difficulties. Not to mention what I'm sure the designers weren't intending at first - repeat farming over and over of the same content. In the end, this became what made it such a huge hit. The fact that you had to study character builds made a sort of meta game. Minecraft is another example where you have a wiki tabbed while you play. And lets not even get started on dwarf fortress - the awful UI is the game. I believe the metagame is whats at work in all these. A lack of tutorials and good ui feels somehow more authentic and rewarding.
- roarroar 13y agoIt reeks of autism. You know it's bad because it forces you out of the game to look at some web page. It's basically showing total contempt for the aesthetics and fantasy of the game in favor of the endless cataloging and retrieval of pointless information.
- vacri 13y agoThis is just not true. You can play the game fine without the wiki, and I did so on my first playthrough... with a kb+mouse. You just can't min/max without the wiki. And if you want to PvP, then sure, you need to min/max... but if you're PvPing, you're going to be going to a wiki anyway.
- roarroar 13y agoWhat's not true? I didn't say you were forced as some kind of hard requirement to use the wiki - just that the use of the wiki forces you out of the game and that it is clearly designed to be used in conjunction with a wiki. It should be taken as read that it can be played without it. I mean, who wrote the wiki? The requirement for guessing and repeating segments is just so high that it detracts from the experience. This isn't about knowing every little detail for "min-maxing" either - it's about basic organization to make discovery of information systematic rather than being a sheer time sink. So tell me: how do you figure out that for the Demon Firesage - located in a fiery area, covered in fire - the weakness is.. fire? Trying a bunch of stuff, in this case totally counter-intuitive. What reason would you have to think Gwyn can be parried, when no other boss in the game can be? By trying a bunch of stuff and stumbling upon it since, again, it is counter-intuitive. In other words: by having complete and utter contempt for the value of your own time. It completely takes away from the sense of fantasy, as well. The whole point with these open world games is to feel like you have the freedom to make your own choices. But if you know that your best best is to go everywhere and pick up every item you can then it feels like janitorial work, not a grand adventure.
- simias 13y agoI agree, I love both games but it's casual nethack as far as I'm concerned: it's very difficult to enjoy the games without a minimal amount of spoilers. I went blind for my first run in both games, and while I could finish demon's souls with a minimal amount of grinding I hit a wall in DaS because some upgrade paths are simply dead ends. Leveling up resistance, for instance. Certain weapon's upgrade paths. And you have no way of knowing that before you get destroyed in the next dungeon because "hey, occult weapons are useless! Tough luck".
- guizzy 13y agoIndeed. The OP's link praises the way the game branches at the very beginning and teaches you to go up first, but the way up was not nearly as obvious to me as it seems to have been for him. I had to use a walkthrough. Most RPGs, when they take you out of a tutorial, have you facing the way you need to go. It's very unintuitive (and I'd say bad design) to force me to do a 180 right from the start and go the opposite way from where I'm facing. It might just be me being dense, but it took a while before I realized that the skeletons on the way down were not just the game being "difficult" but purposedly unfair at that point.
- sullichin 13y agoWell, one way has incredibly durable skeletons who can kill you in two hits, and another way has the same enemies that you fought in the tutorial... It's not that obtuse.
- guizzy 13y agoOf course once I went up it was obvious that it was where I needed to go, but I needed a tutorial to tell me there even was another way but down. The guy by the bonfire does mention something of the sort, but I thought he was referring to the ruins right next to the bonfire. When you spawn after the tutorial, you spawn facing the slope that goes down.
- zerohm 13y agothere seems to be a lot of misplaced praise out there for the trial-and-error, but this part of the game really just sloppiness. I have to disagree. I thought the "here is the whole map, figure it out" aspect was brutal but brilliant. Dark Souls is the modern equivalent of Zelda for NES. You immediately have access to paths you have no business entering at the start of the game. But that makes it all the more gratifying when you come back later and concquer that path. With ever advancing quest logs, way points, and real time navigation arrows, it's nice to see game designers go with the opposite approach.
- roarroar 13y agoSo what's your argument? You think it's kind of like Zelda? So what? Did you even read what I said? It's problematic in Dark Souls precisely because of how big and complex it is. Demon's Souls is cut out of the same clothe - but it is smaller and simpler, so these things don't become a pressing issue. None of the qualities you list, e.g. having access to deadly areas, are against what I'm saying. It has nothing to do with "guest logs, way points and real time navigation". None of that is necessary to fix the game. I can't play games like Skyward Sword where there's some asshole computer jumping out of your sword dropping the most ball-achingly obvious hints. What's needed are carefully placed clues, of which there are very few. I think it's fair to say that the game is deliberately counter-intuitive in ways that serve only to waste your time.
- Rickasaurus 13y agoHaving played both Demon and Dark souls, I think Demon souls was only better in that it flushed out the Maiden and the monumentals in a way which was deliberate and set the tone of the game. Dark Souls could have used something along these lines, but in every other respect it's the better game. From the improved enemy AI, to balance in the weapons and crafting, to the variety of locations and enemies, and don't forget the subtle lore in the item descriptions and placement of unique enemies and items. Dark Souls is just plain better. That said, they both rank as my favorite games of the last ten years. Edit: Also, if this has convinced you to pick this game up for the PC (it's often on sale on Steam for under $10), don't forget to get DSFix for the graphics and DSMFix fix for mouse and keyboard support. It wasn't a very good port, but the community has made it great. DSFix: http://blog.metaclassofnil.com/?tag=dsfix http://blog.metaclassofnil.com/?tag=dsfix DSMFix: http://pages.cs.wisc.edu/~petska/ http://pages.cs.wisc.edu/~petska/
- devindotcom 13y agoI just got it on sale for $7.50. I had a pirated version I played a few hours in (wanted to see how the port was; as you say, it's pretty bad) that circumvented GFWL, storing my save in a local 4-meg file rather than on some server somewhere. And I can't restore him! I'M VERY SCARED TO START AGAIN. But I might just do so with the fix.
- epsylon 13y agoEven when playing in online mode, the savegames are still on your computer. (Somewhere in the C:\Users\yourlogin\ mess...)
- devindotcom 13y agoOh, really? I didn't see them appear. I'll try again - thanks for the info.
- roarroar 13y ago>Dark Souls is just plain better. Nope. It has a worse frame rate, just for a start. All the qualities you list are laudable, but they don't even come close to addressing "every other respect". For example, Dark Souls requires you to pick up way more items than Demon's Souls. More items is good - but not if it turns into a tiresome exercise in collection.
- anigbrowl 13y agoI don't think the writer's point is well made by his gushing style (and this is also a page that could badly benefit from some nicer fonts and pictures to break up the wall of text). However I am a huge fan of Demon's Souls and will probably get around to Dark Souls eventually too. It's the closest thing that I've come across so far to an immersive version of Nethack.
- mekpro 13y agoI found that most of the fun in this game can be easily destroyed by FAQs and Youtube. I myself get very frustrated by Sen Fortress's Bonfire that i can't resist the urge to get an answer from wiki. After read this, I find myself regretted because i had missed the crucial experience of this game. Explore or dead ! I wish I could forget everything about this game so that I can innocently play it from the start again.
- quanticle 13y agoThis is why I play randomized rougelikes, like Nethack, or more recently, Torchlight. You can't make spoilers for a game that randomizes its levels.
- cheald 13y agoIf you like roguelikes, check out Binding of Isaac. I can't figure out why it's so compelling, but boy howdy, is it ever.
- tomlu 13y agoThe author neglected to mention my favourite trap in Sen's fortress. There's an elevator you can get on that if you don't get off in time will bring you headfirst into a bunch of spikes. The genius part is the elevator floor is covered in blood, a hint you would certainly notice if you take your time and proceed cautiously. This is the sort of thing that makes every death feel deserved, which is pivotal to the souls series.
- zerohm 13y agoThere are lots of little clever details like this. You might have also noticed that in Ornstein and Smough's chamber there are two elevators: a large one (for Smough) and a small one (for Ornstein).
- roarroar 13y agoYou're being very selective. What is the hint that Demon Firesage is weak to fire? What is the hint that Gwyn is parryable - unlike every other boss in the game? etc
- zainny 13y agoWhat really annoys me about Dark Souls is the shitty PC port. They're still selling tons of copies of the game for PC because of all the silly hype around it, and yet the game is virtually unplayable - even with all the mouse fixes, mods, etc. Why is it acceptable for game developers to completely abandon their customer base and continue to sell a broken product? I picked up the game during a Steam sale, spent a good few hours trying to make it playable with a variety of mods, fixes, etc. and then just gave up completely. And for those few hours I did play it, nothing about it stood out to me as being incredible or ingenious.
- cheald 13y agoDSFix and an Xbox controller makes it perfectly playable, IMO. What problems did you run into?
- simias 13y agoThe consensus seems to be that the game is hardly playable without a controller (by the way, steam has a big warning about that on the game's page in the store). Some people make do with the mousefix mod (the default mouse targeting behaviour is beyond silly). It's quite a bad port indeed, but it's a good game so I guess it's better than nothing... If you do a lot of gaming on PC buying a controller can be a pretty good investment anyway, it makes sense for a lot of games.
- frd2 13y agoPlayed the whole game with just the keyboard. It is perfectly doable - just requires a little bit of time to get used to. Since then it's my favourite game of the last 5 years, a real gem... what I didn't like was the lack of proper information on the screen what buttons do what ( in the inventory and so on ).
- jamesaguilar 13y agoI don't know why people expect to be able to play this with a keyboard. It's designed for a certain input paradigm. Play it with the same or face the impedance mismatch. Nobody complains that wii bowling is unplayable with a GameCube controller.
- n1ghtmare_ 13y agoHonestly, this is in my top 5 all time favorite games. It's brilliant. By the time I finished it, it wasn't difficult anymore, you just have to master it. Can't wait for Dark Souls 2.
- ilitirit 13y agoClassic Reddit "review" of the game's predecessor: Demon’s Souls is a game that will make you into a man. A scrawny fourteen-year-old, after two hours with this game, will be grooming his muttonchops and ready to ship off on the next boat to fight the Kaiser. If you are already a man, it will make you into some sort of bizarre double-man. What’s that you say? You’re a woman? You don’t want to be a man? Too bad. Too bad. That’s the Demon’s Souls way. You’ve probably heard that Demon’s Souls is hard. Pshh. Lots of games are hard. Some are even harder than this one. The difficulty is not the point. What sets Demon's Souls apart is the way that it doesn't just kill you, but also stomps on your genitals when you’re down. And it will make you realize that that’s what you needed all along. It’s a lot like life. Sometimes in life you win, and sometimes the giant armored skeleton stabs your face off because the flying mantis monster you didn’t even see shot you in the back with a spike at just the wrong time. And when that happens in life, do you respawn at the same spot and carry on like nothing happened? NO, asshole. You go back to the beginning of the level, leaving all your hard-earned souls out there on the pavement, and you fight your way back. And you learn a lesson from the whole thing, because you should have been wearing your Thief’s Ring, now shouldn’t you? That’s life. The trend in hard games these days is to unlock “Easy” mode for you once you’ve died enough times. Do you think Demon’s Souls does that? Do you think Demon’s Souls is so much as aware of the concept of “Easy” mode? NO IT IS NOT. If Demon’s Souls even knew we were talking about “Easy” mode, it would come over here and kick the shit out of all of us. And we would deserve it. I’ll tell you what happens in Demon’s Souls when you die. You come back as a ghost with your health capped at half. And when you keep on dying, the alignment of the world turns black and the enemies get harder. That’s right, when you fail in this game, it gets harder. Why? Because fuck you is why. Have I told you about the online elements? At any time when you’re in Body form, another player from anywhere else in the world can invade your game and murder you to regain his own body, or just to keep you on your toes. This happens when you’re in the middle of fighting armies of unthinkable monsters that are probably already three-quarters of the way towards killing you. And no, you cannot opt out of this feature! This is what you signed up for when you agreed to be a man. When this happened to me -- when a guy strolled into my game like it was Taco Bell and exploded my torso, costing me my body and all my progress in the level -- was I mad? No, because I was too busy being in awe at how fucking hardcore the experience was. Now, don’t let this dissuade you. Demon’s Souls is a pitiless master, but let it never be said that it is not fair. The game rewards handsomely those who stand up to it, and the greater the challenge, the greater the glory. What the hell are you waiting for? www.reddit.com/r/gaming/comments/acz2t/let_me_tell_you_about_demons_souls/
- jackmaney 13y agoA while ago, I foolishly decided to spend $40 to get Dark Souls: Prepare to Die edition on Steam. The controls were so atrocious--both in the default choice of key bindings and in the control execution that made me feel as though my character was wading through Vaseline--that I found it completely unplayable.
- alex_c 13y agoAh, yes... the PC version should come with a giant red warning that says "DO NOT ATTEMPT TO PLAY THIS WITHOUT A CONTROLLER". There's still a learning curve even with a controller, but once past that the controls have a beautiful simplicity and responsiveness that I've seen in very few other games.
- jackmaney 13y agoWhat's the point of playing a PC game with a controller? If I wanted to play a game with inferior controls, I would just use a console.