5 ms·
Solar is renewable, self sustaining The sun is, but what about the raw materials needed to make the panels?
by sliverstorm 13y ago
Solar is renewable, self sustaining
The sun is, but what about the raw materials needed to make the panels?
- VladRussian2 13y ago>The sun is, but what about the raw materials needed to make the panels? like silicon?
- sliverstorm 13y agoSolar energy technologies, for example, will require half the current world supply of tellurium and 25% of the supply of indium, the report says. http://www.euractiv.com/sustainability/rare-earth-shortage-hamper-clean-news-508967 http://www.euractiv.com/sustainability/rare-earth-shortage-h...
- dredmorbius 13y agoSolar panels do have some low-reserve raw-materials requirements. CSP (concentrated solar thermal power) rather less so, though it has higher costs and isn't as easily deployed widely (PV can be installed pretty much on any existing structure, CSP generally requires its own dedication installations). Though really, all this says is that even under a renewables scheme, we're not going to be able to provide power at the level some have come to expect for the population we've now got (7 billion) or are projected to have (10 billion). The bigger problem from my PoV is that the existing financial and economic systems discount the sustainability capabilities of even a partial capacity provided by renewables to the point that little if any of it gets built -- the biggest hazard I and some others (Gail Tverberg is a pretty notable leading voice, Richard Heinberg another) see is that the financial and economic systems collapse well before energy or other limits fully impose themselves. And yes, others note that renewables as presently envisioned draw heavily on nonrenewables for fabrication and construction: https://www.readability.com/articles/oqtyksza https://www.readability.com/articles/oqtyksza http://www.countercurrents.org/adair301110.htm http://www.countercurrents.org/adair301110.htm The fact that providing energy needs under a renewables basis is going to be really hard doesn't make nonrenewables any better -- they're only going to work until they don't and we fall off a cliff. What's your suggestion.
- sliverstorm 13y agoThe fact that providing energy needs under a renewables basis is going to be really hard doesn't make nonrenewables any better -- they're only going to work until they don't and we fall off a cliff. What's your suggestion. My suggestion is to pick our energy sources carefully. Solar panels mean a dependence on China, which is hardly a departure from our current foreign dependence. Maybe there is no energy source that doesn't put us completely at the mercy of another nation, but who knows if that's the case? No one, because renewables are marketed as inherently endless. I'm not a civil engineer, so I don't know all the details and I can't tell you what the best system is. I defer to the actual experts on that. But I can tell you that the endlessness of renewables may be technically true, but often not at all in practice. That's all I'm getting at.
- dredmorbius 13y agoSolar panels mean a dependence on China If you're referring to rare-earth production, my understanding is that this is more a matter of where mining operations are considered viable and acceptable (largely on a basis of environmental impacts). The elements themselves are relatively abundant in the Earth's crust, they're simply not concentrated as other minerals have traditionally been (though we've done a rather good job of ensuring that concentrated ores no longer exist). Materials dependence is also different from fuels dependence. In the latter case, short-term interruptions can have massive disruption effects on whole economies. Look at what possible military action in Syria is doing to current oil prices, let alone the disruptions of the 1974 and 1979 oil embargoes. Were material flows interrupted, what would be disrupted would be additional energy systems development, but existing systems would continue to function fine (modulo maintenance and retirement). the endlessness of renewables may be technically true, but often not at all in practice. There's a fair bit of truth to that. Many renewables technologies are dependent on specific and limited materials, or on complex technology stacks: PVs also require an extensive chip-fabrication infrastructure. Once it's established and producing it's pretty efficient, but having to build it from scratch would be a challenge. You're touching on issues that many who are looking at future paths (generally: "collapse", "transition", or some combination / variant of these and other options) with cold, clear vision see. My point is that whatever challenges renewables offer, they're out only hope, so if it turns out that they do have profound limitations, we'd best start getting used to that idea. If this means going back to animal power and firewood -- well, we have a rough idea of what sort of population can be supported on that technological stack. And I don't paint renewables as necessarily being sufficient for present-day (or even technologically advanced) lifestyles, though I suspect they might be able to offer that.
- lectrick 13y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stirling_engine http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stirling_engine There's more ways to harness solar energy than photovoltaics.
- api 13y agoPanels are not irreversibly diluted or consumed. They just "fall apart" at the molecular level and have to be recycled.
- dredmorbius 13y agoRecycling has its limits. I've mostly looked at this with regards to lithium (critical in Tesla's EVs, though other rare earths are also limiting, perhaps moreso). With present known reserves (including recent finds in South America -- Bolivia as I recall), there's not enough lithium to build batteries for an EV for the entire world's population. I believe the number I came up was about 1 in 10. And that's for one generation of vehicles. Turns out that you can recycle batteries. But the process recovers only 90% of the lithium. After about 7 generations, you've lost over half your original stock. With sufficient energy, you can extract virtually anything from seawater (even stuff like uranium). But that "with sufficient energy" prerequisite is pretty much specifically the challenge we're looking at.
- api 13y ago"With sufficient energy, you can extract virtually anything from seawater (even stuff like uranium). But that "with sufficient energy" prerequisite is pretty much specifically the challenge we're looking at." Not so much. There is plenty of energy... I mean tons... with one caveat: it's not always on. But there's no reason that extraction of minerals from sea water couldn't be a daytime-only thing.