3 ms·
So this post was about how Wolfram has a big ego? That's it? Nothing wrong with a big ego, is there? Self-promotion is still okay in the world? We're still fr
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
So this post was about how Wolfram has a big ego?
That's it?
Nothing wrong with a big ego, is there? Self-promotion is still okay in the world? We're still free to toot our own horn? Write our own resumes, pitch our own products, spin our own political ideas, sell our own worldviews?
And what, exactly, does Godel have to do with any of that? I take it the idea is that Godel was the real genius?
If we're going to be measuring who's really smart, maybe we'd want to wait a few hundred years.
I admire people with big egos and positive attitudes. We could use more of them in the world. I don't buy into their self-image, but I admire it. Positive mental attitude -- the idea that you're capable of making something really big -- is what's going to keep you hacking on that startup long after others would have quit. Arrogance, on the other hand, is a different matter. But this post had nothing to say about arrogance.
Just wondering how it got so many upvotes. I guess Wolfram must have a natural ability to tick people off?
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- michael_dorfman 17y agoThere's a line between "big ego" and "delusion", and it appears that Wolfram has crossed it. Innovation requires big ego and positive attitude, but it also requires some contact with reality, and the ability to appreciate with humility the achievements of others.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoinnovation, in your opinion requires those things. I'll use musicians as an example because they're most fresh in my mind. Good grief, take a look at some of the people we all acknowledge as being innovators: Motzart, who said he wrote great music like cows pee -- it was just his thing. Beethoven, who used to play performances that would make people cry -- and then would yell at the crowd for being such naves. Berlioz -- "At least I have the modesty to admit that lack of modesty is one of my failings." Delusion is one of those things, especially with really smart people, that's easy to assume and hard to prove. Humility and all of that are wonderful social skills, but they are by no means a prerequisite for being a paradigm-changing person or leaving great innovations to society. The lack of them just makes one unpleasant, and I never said Wolfram was a pleasant person to be around. And the kicker is -- their degree of popularity or acceptance by their peers in their own time was no indication of the contribution they eventually made. Their popularity and acceptance waxed and waned just like everyone else's: based on a bunch of social factors.
- jimbokun 17y ago"Humility and all of that are wonderful social skills, but they are by no means a prerequisite for being a paradigm-changing person or leaving great innovations to society." Social skills are paramount for all but solitary achievements. And great innovations are rarely paradigm-changing innovations. An interesting contrast is Steve Jobs. Jobs is legendarily arrogant. But I would be surprised to see an outright self-protestation of his brilliance or greatness. Of Apple and Apple products, yes, but not Jobs praising Jobs. Instead, his great skill is flattering, motivating and persuading others. I do not think you can dispute that this has led to much paradigm-changing innovation. Perhaps the problem is not that Wolfram is arrogant, but that he is so clumsily and self-apparently so. Wolfram has accomplished much, but it is possible he could achieve much more with a modicum of social skills.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoI don't know Wolfram, and I doubt you do, so I can assume that perhaps he is clumsily arrogant. Makes sense to me. I'm also not a math genius, and I doubt most of the folks on HN are either. I also lack the perspective of viewing Wolfram's works from a couple of hundred years out. Given all of that, why would I want to hold Wolfram in any more disdain than the guy at the local softball game who thinks he was the best baseball player since Hank Aaron? If anything, such people are fun to be around -- at least until you've heard all of their stories. They certainly don't deserve mockery. If you've got a problem with how somebody treats you because they are arrogant, that's one thing. But if you're just out there tearing somebody else down because they're an easy target -- they're clumsily arrogant -- get a grip and start treating total strangers better. I thought about mentioning Jobs. Goodness knows there are a lot of technology types that think they are God's gift to mankind as well. We just don't hear about them so much. I think it's disturbing that we are all turning into hate-mongers: we define ourselves by who we mock and hate. Wolfram is cool to hate, so let's all pile on him. Bill Gates is the epitome of evil, so let's have at him too. It goes on and on. These are human beings, precious other people. Would you want to be treated this way in a public forum by some writer looking to score points from his social group? It's clanning at it's worst -- made out to be light and funny. Kind of like picking on the slow kid at school. Wolfram isn't any good at self-promoting! What a self-deluded idiot. I guess that's what struck me about the article. I don't know one way or the other, but I know I'd rather talk about Wolfram's ideas than the man himself.
- HSO 17y agoThe problem is not "big ego", the problem is missing attribution and acknowledgment. You cannot walk around claiming you invented the wheel even if you came up more or less independently with the idea. More practically, you cannot with good conscience take someone else's data, put it in your DB, do a little sanity check, and then make everyone attribute the source to WA!