7 ms·
Apartment Blockers: Parking Rules Raise Your Rent
- Fargren 13y agoI feel like I missed something. Why is it that off-street parking must be subterranean? Is it more expensive to make the building a floor of two taller and use the first floors for parking? Is this illegal somehow?
- ams6110 13y agoMight be illegal, if there are height restrictions in the zoning code. Also a lot of cities now add in requirements to have street-level retail so that buildings are not featureless walls or concrete parking ramps at street level.
- spc476 13y agoA friend of mine used to be an architect, and I asked him once if it was possible to build a mile-high building. He said that it was technically possible but economically unfeasible because it would be hard to rent all the space. The base of the building (X number of floors) would have to be huge, and most people want to rent suites (office or living space) with windows, leaving the deep interior bare of renters. Perhaps a ring of stores, with the interior of the first floor or two as a parking garage, which are less desirable anyway?
- x0x0 13y agothe burj khalifa got to 2700 ft http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burj_Khalifa http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burj_Khalifa
- dredmorbius 13y agoMany towers have multiple floors (I've seen as many as 10) of parking. Turning radiuses and building services (elevators, water, sewerage, cooling, electrical) limit the ability to restrict parking to interior cores, though automated parking systems might allow for this. Utilizing interior cores for warehousing/storage might also make some level of sense. I've also seen numerous buildings with large interior multi-floor (often the full building height) atria -- some quite beautiful in fact.
- sjs1234 13y ago"She builds it as tall as the legal height limit for that zone too."
- spc476 13y agoI was wondering the same thing. The office building I work in has the first four floors devoted to a parking garage, with floors 5 to 10 as office space. Why couldn't the same be done for housing?
- thrownaway2424 13y agoBecause it's hideous? People walking around don't want to walk past the blank walls or ventilation grates of parking garages. An attractive urban pedestrian environment needs to have something _different_ and _interesting_ every few dozen feet. That's why streets with many narrow storefronts are the most crowded with pedestrians.
- iyulaev 13y agoThat's why streets with many narrow storefronts are the most crowded with pedestrians. Correlation != causation.
- dredmorbius 13y agoCorrelation + causal explanation gives you a pretty strong link, however. You can also directly compare regions in which monoliths break the flow small/frequent storefronts. The relationship, in my casual observation, holds very strongly. You can disrupt the pattern by providing street-level temporary equivalents, e.g., street fairs / farmer's markets, and the like. And obxkcd: http://xkcd.com/552/ http://xkcd.com/552/ "Correlation doesn't imply causation, but it does waggle its eyebrows suggestively and gesture furtively while mouthing 'look over there'."
- spc476 13y agoHere's the building I work in: https://maps.google.com/?ie=UTF8&ll=26.200547,-80.149577&spn=0.009241,0.012252&t=m&z=17&vpsrc=6&layer=c&cbll=26.200361,-80.149577&panoid=5HmWm0fNWGVR0KLEjGk0kQ&cbp=12,276.97,,0,1.5 https://maps.google.com/?ie=UTF8&ll=26.200547,-80.149577&spn... You can see the garage entrance to the left, and the garage wraps around behind the main entrance (a five story open air atrium) to the right hand side. It doesn't have to be hideous.
- icambron 13y agoThis is basically what sjs said, but you're only allowed to build the building so tall (zoning rules often crazily restrictive about this). So if you put your parking above ground, you'd have to have fewer units.
- bproctor 13y agoYeah, I don't understand this article. My building has a 1 story basement, street level is retail space, the next 6 floors are parking, and above that 24 floors of apartments. You can't easily tell from the outside what is apartments and what is parking without looking close. I also live in Seattle only blocks away from where this guy is talking about.
- schoper 13y agoCars ruin everything about urban life. Look at what happened to SF when the automobile came on the scene in the 30's: http://www.oldsf.org http://www.oldsf.org
- dkersten 13y agoI would love a car-less city where the only vehicles are public transport or commercial delivery vehicles, with cycling being the only allowed personal transport.
- BerislavLopac 13y agoAnd Segway.
- hollerith 13y agoI hear that some city cores in Europe are car-less in this sense.
- jared314 13y agoI think the issue is the people, not the cars. The people of Peachtree City, GA have a large golf cart culture. And, they still have golf cart traffic jams[1], golf cart drunk drivers[2], and severe golf cart accidents [3]. [1] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8RlXz_DQYRI http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8RlXz_DQYRI [2] http://now.msn.com/peachtree-city-georgia-has-golf-cart-dui-problem http://now.msn.com/peachtree-city-georgia-has-golf-cart-dui-... [3] http://www.myfoxatlanta.com/story/22293708/peachtree-city-teen-recovering-golf-cart-crash http://www.myfoxatlanta.com/story/22293708/peachtree-city-te... Edit: Removed 'primarily' assertion because of information from vinceguidry
- vinceguidry 13y agoThey don't 'primarily' use golf carts. They still use mostly cars. I lived there for several months. Golf carts are definitely part of the culture, the city encourages them by building paths, but the vast majority still drive cars.
- 13y ago
- dbg31415 13y agoArticles like this annoy because the underlying tone is, "Well, you shouldn't have a car." But I don't know anyone over 30 who doesn't have one. The bus system doesn't go everywhere. How would I get to Mt. Rainier, or get around Bainbridge, or for that matter over to work? I've taken the bus and I've driven from Seattle to Redmond; the bus takes twice as long for me to get from home to where I'm going. Rent goes up. If you don't like paying high rent, move to Texas.
- ericabiz 13y agoSounds like you live in Seattle. When I visited there recently, I used car2go instead of renting a car. It's a car sharing service like Zipcar, but unlike Zipcar, you can drop a car off anywhere in their network instead of having to return the car to where you picked it up. Very cool. I use them here in Austin, too, where I live (and they started.) > If you don't like paying high rent, move to Texas. Sadly, not so much true these days, although here in Austin you can make 100% of your mortgage back via Airbnb or having roommates.
- aaronbrethorst 13y agoIt sounds like they live 30 minutes away from Seattle by ferry (Bainbridge Island). Car2go doesn't 'work' there. The answer, of course, is move to the Seattle urban core. (And car2go actually launched in Germany about 2 years before Austin: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Car2Go http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Car2Go)
- thrownaway2424 13y agoThe point is to not force people to build the parking by having minimum parking laws. If some building wants to have lots of underground parking, fine, and if another building wants to have units that are $20k cheaper because they lack parking, that's also fine.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- 13y ago
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- kalleboo 13y agoIn my city, the daily commute traffic breaks down like this: * Car 40% * Bicycle 36% * Bus 16% * Walking 8% I'm nearing 30 and none of my friends who live in the city own a car. Many subscribe to zipcar-type services for when they need to make trips. They're also all childless - all my friends with kids moved out of the city. IMO, cars and cities are a bad mix. They make cities far more unfriendly, they increase sprawl, and cause a spiral of adding more cars, increasing sprawl further, etc.
- chiph 13y agoNot sure why they don't investigate automated parking systems. Their parking density is much higher than lots or decks. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LOR25PjV0wI http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LOR25PjV0wI
- dredmorbius 13y agoCost and retrofit requirements, mostly.
- abirkill 13y agoThere is at least one residential building in Vancouver, BC that has implemented an automated system, but according to this article, the cost per space is almost double that of a conventional space: http://www.vancourier.com/news/vancouver-robo-garage-lowers-security-fears-1.385058 http://www.vancourier.com/news/vancouver-robo-garage-lowers-... Also, having spoken to someone who lives in that building, it seems to be disliked by a lot of residents, due to the long waiting times at peak periods. That's not particularly surprising given there are only two transfer stations. I guess these systems may work better in retail locations where there is a steady flow of traffic coming and going through the day, rather than at residential or office locations where there are very high peaks in demand. To build enough transfer stations to satisfy the peaks would presumably both be very expensive, and reduce the space savings that were made.
- IvyMike 13y agoI don't mind most driving, so self-driving cars are kinda "meh" to me. But then I think about the ability to pull up to a building and tell my car "go park yourself" and it becomes awesome. All sorts of great efficiencies pop out, too: a lot filled with self-driving cars could pack them tightly, and when a car needs to be removed, all the other cars move out of the way. Offices, closed businesses, schools, etc, with parking spaces could all become ad-hoc lots at night. (I'd make city ordinances requiring this for building approval). Your car can park in a remote area somewhere, and when you want to leave, your car comes and finds you. Imagine taking a post-dinner stroll towards my car, and at some point you meet up.
- lifeformed 13y agoI wonder what society will be like once self-drivings cars are ubiquitous. There'd be so much reclaimed real-estate from giant parking lots.
- ams6110 13y agoWhy, will they not need to be parked anywhere?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- awda 13y agoYou need less cars to serve the needs of the currently-in-motion population than for everyone to own their own car. The idea is, a smaller percentage of cars are parked at any given time, and can meet demand with fewer cars. Fewer cars, less parking required.
- jhonovich 13y agoYou will not need as many total cars as they can be shared and most people do not use them most of the time anyway. Think health clubs and Internet service provided by telcos. They can be oversubscribed by designed because providers know that not everyone will use simultaneously.
- awda 13y agoMaybe First Hill is special, but parking in Seattle proper and Capitol Hill (both near First Hill) is extremely crowded and finding a spot can be hard. The mythical building plot described in the article sounds wonderful relative to my experience: "Overnight, when your tenants’ cars will most likely be at home, the office buildings’ garages are usually empty. And, of course, there are hundreds of curb spaces within six blocks of your building, though neighbors’ vehement territoriality about “their” spaces would make it impolitic to mention those in an appeal to the city for a parking waiver. Odds are that your tenants could secure whatever parking they wanted for much less than $250 a month per spot." The cheapest parking I could get on Cap Hill was $150/mo, and it was in one of these subterranean garages. Speaking of garages, any reason you can't build the garage on levels 1-2 and put apartments on 3-5?
- seanmcdirmid 13y ago> The cheapest parking I could get on Cap Hill was $150/mo, and it was in one of these subterranean garages. I always guffaw when I see American prices, which are so much lower than the rest of the world. The cheapest spot I could get near my apartment in Beijing is around $400/month, and its not available. Switzerland was even worse. But when I was at UW, it was only $50/month (back in the late 90s). Why is the USA so cheap?
- awda 13y agoEasy answer? Low population density, lots of space, relative to Europe (totally unfamiliar with Beijing). UW (U district) is a bit cheaper than capital hill (when I lived in U district, 1 parking spot came w/ rent, an additional spot was $50/mo).
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoWhen I was living there, I never heard of free parking in the U district. You always paid for your slot in the garage even if you only had one car. Many apartment buildings lacked any parking at all. It is true that the US has lots of space, but the cost of driving (and parking) is still ridiculously low compared to other countries with similar characteristics (Canada/Australia)...and people still complain about it being too expensive (god, $4/gallon gas, outrage!).
- lancewiggs 13y agoI would think that contractors need to dig a deep hole to ensure the foundations of the building are secure - get into the bedrock, especially in earthquake zones. Whether the car parks are below or above ground is moot. That said - The High Cost of Free Parking (1) and The Walkable City (2) are both excellent reads on the matter of parking and car parks. The second is the more readable. (1) http://www.amazon.com/High-Cost-Parking-Updated-Edition/dp/193236496X http://www.amazon.com/High-Cost-Parking-Updated-Edition/dp/1... (2) http://www.amazon.com/Walkable-City-Downtown-Save-America/dp/0374285810 http://www.amazon.com/Walkable-City-Downtown-Save-America/dp...
- Anechoic 13y agoI would think that contractors need to dig a deep hole to ensure the foundations of the building are secure - get into the bedrock, especially in earthquake zones Not necessarily, spread footings or piles can work if designed properly and the soil can support it.
- Eliezer 13y agoWhy is it so hugely expensive to dig holes? You would think this'd be the kind of work that would be easy to automate.
- joseph_cooney 13y agoI'm guessing there is an element of 'you don't know what you're going to find until you start digging' aspect to it.
- revelation 13y agoIn Germany and other WW2 theatres, you will commonly find unexploded ordnance. All work will come to a halt as it has to be removed by experts.
- moocowduckquack 13y agoDepends where you are digging them. If you are removing a lot of material in a built-up area it costs a lot to get it off-site.
- tghw 13y agoThe primary reason they dig those holes is because tall buildings need solid foundations. It's not as if they can just build the building at ground level if only it weren't for those darn cars. Foundation depths vary based on too many factors, but a ballpark number for a midsize apartment building is probably in the 15-30% range. So if you have 16 floors, you could reasonably expect to have 2-4 stories below grade. What else would you put there? Even if you only needed 2 stories of foundation depth, digging an additional 2 for parking is relatively cheap compared to the first two, since the equipment is already out there.
- Retric 13y agoYou don't need a full basement for foundations, large pilings are far cheaper. They can easily support 30 story buildings without a basement in an earthquake just fine. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deep_foundation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deep_foundation
- tghw 13y agoTrue, but most apartment buildings will want at least one basement layer for mechanical and storage.
- rdl 13y agoI live in a condo building with maybe 35-40 1br and 2br units on 3 floors, plus first floor 35 or so units of parking. It doesn't seem unworkable, and a parking spot in the building is worth at least 100-200/mo to me. I am not sure how the economics work here but not in the example.
- moocowduckquack 13y agoInstall a couple of lifts on the side of the building and put all the parking on the roof.
- mikeash 13y agoThat certainly sounds cheap!
- corresation 13y agoThis is an awful lot of conjecture, yet remarkably little substance. The core claim of this purported injustice is that "Digging these holes is astronomically expensive", with absolutely nothing to qualify it (beyond a link to an Onion article). The single proof was that LA allowed builders to re-purpose existing buildings (e.g. turning that old sugar factory into condos) without satisfying current parking requirements, which has absolutely nothing to do with the cost on a new build. Large buildings need a substructure proportional with their height, especially in an earthquake zone like SF area. Even where non-parking substructure is built, it usually still requires a complete excavation to ensure that the materials are appropriate for keeping a skyscraper from falling over. However more expensive parking is than without, unless an accounting construction expert wanders in, I draw very little value from someone looking out of their window and drawing perhaps unsupported conclusions. And then even if you assume that parking is more expensive, most buildings charge for parking. Does this cover the extra costs, if any? I don't know, and neither does the author. Just a perceived injustice and yet another claim of subsidizing car drivers.