13 ms·
Why a medieval peasant got more vacation time than you
- ams6110 13y agoShould be tagged [opinion]. This is not a news piece.
- D9u 13y agoThe fact that our elected representatives have voted themselves so many perks, as well as raises, highlights the double standard which has become prevalent in the USA. Exempt from the Obama care fiasco, retirement eligibility after a ridiculously short period of employment, an enviably short work "year." It makes me wonder why I didn't go into politics...
- rweba 13y agoLawmakers already had health insurance so the Affordable Care Act didn't really affect them in any substantial way. In general the ACA won't have a huge immediate impact for those who already have health insurance.
- D9u 13y agoAnd those without health care insurance can presently walk into any community health center to receive subsidized health care free of charge. Even illegal aliens can get free health care right now, so how will the ACA affect those without health care insurance?
- Shivetya 13y agothe true one percent are the politicians. In regards to the time and life of medieval peasants and the like, I think I will take my work week over theirs.
- davidw 13y ago> It makes me wonder why I didn't go into politics... There's nothing stopping you but yourself, you know. It's not like West Point or something where you have to start right out of high school.
- D9u 13y agoI don't have the resources to cease working in order to campaign for office, and no big backers are supporting my positions, so although it may be only me holding myself back in the eyes of some, there are extenuating circumstances which work to keep me in my place.
- njharman 13y agoWhat opinion is expressed? All I see are tons of facts on working hours, vacations, leisure time. With plenty of supporting links for more information / verify for yourself.
- coldtea 13y agoThere's not opinion in the piece. Just numbers. Perhaps you meant to tag your comment "don't agree".
- ams6110 13y agoIt's published with an "Opinion" heading right at the top. The whole piece is clearly advocating an opinion that more leisure time is a good thing, for one.
- coldtea 13y ago>The whole piece is clearly advocating an opinion that more leisure time is a good thing, for one. There's a disagreement on the issue?
- pg 13y agoStatistics about how much time medieval peasants spent working can be misleading, because a lot of what they spent their time on when they weren't doing fieldwork was still work, e.g. tending their own gardens, making implements and furniture, working on their houses. They had to make most of the things they used themselves. So when "work" was over they didn't go home and watch TV. It's hard to be sure exactly what life was like for preindustrial agricultural workers, but the most convincing evidence that it was very hard was that early mines and factories were easily able to recruit all the workers they needed, despite working conditions we know to have been harsh.
- EthanHeilman 13y ago>the most convincing evidence that it was very hard was that early mines and factories were easily able to recruit all the workers they needed, despite working conditions we know to have been harsh. I don't find that evidence convincing for two reasons: 1. Many peasant farmers relied on a commons for food production which was being legislatively destroyed at that time ( See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enclosure https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enclosure ). Factories got peasants who were being pushed off their land due to industrialization. Those peasants might not have opted to be factory workers if they had been able to live a traditional peasant life. Note that this same process was repeated when Mexico grew it's industrial base in the 1990's under NAFTA using Article 27 to destroy common land to create cheap factory labor( see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_American_Free_Trade_Agreement#Zapatista_Uprising_in_response_to_NAFTA_in_Chiapas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_American_Free_Trade_Agre... ). 2. People going to work in factories may not have be aware of how terrible the conditions were and once they found out they may not have been able to reverse the situation (starvation wages don't make for many options). In much the same way that sex-traffickers promise one job (working as a cleaner) and then once the person is under their power the traffickers force them to work as prostitutes.
- alexeisadeski3 13y agoFactory workers were paid handsomely and competition for such jobs was fierce.
- FD3SA 13y agoThis is simply a result of the balance of power shifting ever further towards employers over the past few decades. What incentives does a short-term value maximizing employer have to give his employees paid vacation? In addition, a perfect storm of automation, globalization and erosion of worker rights has severely reduced the bargaining position of employees worldwide. Furthermore, by keeping the majority of the population fully occupied at all times, participation in the democratic process becomes an incredible burden. Thus, the political arena becomes a playground for those who can afford the luxury of free time. It doesn't take a genius to see whom these factors benefit.
- aznjons 13y agoWell put, the relationship trends more and more asymmetric. Add in rhetoric designed to convince workers to buy into a system that exploits them: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6240495 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6240495 In general, employers have far more leverage over employee's lives than the individual employee has over the corporation's well being even though we sometimes pretend that it is symmetric and that the market is fair. Employers optimize for maximum profit for "the shareholders." Somewhere along the line, morality is tossed out, and shortly afterward even legitimate long-term sustainability is also out (cultivating a strong workforce, valued for their talent rather than purely for their labor). Add in the feedback loop of political apparatuses being appropriated for profit (lobbying) and the political arena is just another exploitable lever for amassing more resources by those with the resources to do so.
- venomsnake 13y agoWhich creates a fertile ground for Marxism 2.0 . The moment the screws tighten even more and instead of middle class you get technical/service class for the elite you will have a lot of unhappy people to deal with. And as history has shown time and time again when you have a lot of poor and unhappy people new ideologies could spread like fire. Another thing that concentration of wealth brings is that when the chant becomes "eat the rich/powerful" there are very few rich people left to mount a solid defense - the Arab Spring, the Fall of the Berlin wall all showed that. (I mix political/military/economic power because I think in electroweak style theory they are all the same - the ability to mess up with other people's lives)
- netcan 13y agoThis comparison is probably nonsensical. Still, I think the part of the zeitgeist it's coming from is interesting. No matter how rich we get as a society, very little of that wealth seems to be expressed as more leisure time. This is true comparing different decades (We got richer, still work lots) and its true comparing professions/socio economic classes (highly paid engineers & lawyers work just as much as call centre employees). It is IMO, a failure. Its also very hard for an individual near the median to break out of it without being somewhat of an extremist.
- alexeisadeski3 13y agoIt is a personal decision though, right? Some choose more leisure and others don't. Go talk to some ski "bums" or surf "bums" to see what I mean
- guelo 13y ago"Ski bum" is not an option for people that want to have economic security and maybe buy a mortgage and raise a family.
- alexeisadeski3 13y agoEconomic security and a mortgage are mutually exclusive for most people. And raising a family is unrelated to both.
- ronaldx 13y ago> Economic security and a mortgage are mutually exclusive for most people. Oh wow no. For "most people", a mortgage represents the only means of escape from throwing all your money into a rental trap. Having access to a mortgage represents a giant step up in economic security.
- Fingel 13y agoA <noun> bum is simply someone who has realized they love something in life more than money, and is immune to the FUD of "economic security" - it's not hard to get by with a little intelligence and resourcefulness. These same people (from my experience) tend to be the best parents simply because they can switch from spending their leisure time from <noun> to child.
- discreteevent 13y agoOne thing to remember in all these discussions about working hours is that its one thing to work for yourself and another to work for someone else. I've done both. When you work for yourself you don't take much time off until things are going well, and its not a problem. I think the problem arises when people who own the business genuinely can't understand why everybody else doesn't want to put in the same hours that they do. It's about ownership. Doesn't mean that employees can't be very productive for 8 hours and then go home and do their own thing. e.g. take their kids to sport or music, contribute to voluntary organisations, work on a side project. Each to his own.
- tokenadult 13y agoThis article statement, "His life was shadowed by fear of famine, disease and bursts of warfare. His diet and personal hygiene left much to be desired" explains why I don't want to go back to the life of my peasant ancestors. The author's background, "Lynn Parramore is a senior editor at AlterNet, co-founder of Recessionwire, and founding editor of New Deal 2.0 and IgoUgo.com. She is the author of "Reading the Sphinx: Ancient Egypt in Nineteenth-Century Literary Culture" and has taught cultural theory at NYU" suggests to me why I won't take this opinion piece kindly submitted here as a guide to current economic policy. Actually, today's economy in the United States offers unparalleled opportunities for each worker to make the worker's preferred trade-off among cash income and leisure time, especially if the worker is part of a family household of persons who agree to make different trade-offs from one another.
- engrenage 13y agoWhat's in your background that means we should care about your comment?
- VLM 13y agoOther than adding the fear of famine, I'm not sure how different that is from today. Fear of disease? Check. Both realistic (as in, the huge fraction with no/minimal health insurance or any dental at all). And unrealistic, like fearmongering politicians (as in, send lots of money to X or we'll all die of some made up thing) Bouts of warfare, check. Both actual for kids in .mil, and imaginary daydreams of terrorism. Inferior diet? Check. The personal hygiene thing, I donno about. I'm not so foul but seems like many people are allergic to soap and water, and others who think smelling like an ashtray is a perfume.
- btilly 13y agoSorry, but if you think that we have equivalent fear of disease then and now, you don't know what life was like then. How many people did you personally know who died of disease as a kid? I knew one. (Cancer.) But this was a period where people would have 8 kids in the hope that 2-3 of them would survive to adulthood. And disease was the big killer.
- cryofan 13y agoDiversity is strength...for Capital. But diversity is weakness for Labor. The more diverse a nation, state, city, neighborhood, workplace etc, the less united is Labor. Diversity engenders factions. Factions weaken unity. A less unified Labor is easily preyed upon by Capital. What sort of diversity creates factions? 1. Size: the larger the nation, state, city, workplace etc, the more factions. 2. Distance. 3. Race. 4. Culture. 5. Nationality 6. Language. The fact that factions and diversity weaken the position of the majority has been well known to Capital for centuries. In fact the so-called 'founding fathers' (aka Capital) deliberately discarded the Articles of Confederation and replaced them with the Constitution because the structure of the government created by the constitution would cause factions in the electorate, weakening the position of Labor and strengthening the position of Capital. See, e.g., the federalist papers that were written by the Father of the Constitution, Madison (worth 100 mill after he got his inheritance) and see also his notes on the constitutional convention. I have given you the theory. Let us examine the evidence: for western nations, let us compare two extremes: one, very large and diverse, the other, small and relatively homogeneous. The USA versus...denmark, sweden, iceland, austria et al. Where is it that the people enjoy more time off? Where is it that the people have more control of their governments? Now, recently denmark, sweden, austria, et al are "enjoying" more diversity via mass immigration. How is that increased diversity impacting the quality of the lifestyle enjoyed by the citizens therein? You know the answer. Now you have the theory and the data. But you will not understand what I am saying because this is not what you have been taught since youth. Hmm...another of the puzzles of mankind upon which to ruminate....
- valtron 13y agoWe get weekends off -- so that's around ~100 days at least.
- igravious 13y agoWell then, let's petition for a 3 day weekend. That'll give us the 150 of our medieval brethren. I propose we couch it in terms of equality legislation: Fridays for the Muslims, Saturdays for the Jews and Sundays for the Christians. This serves all Western monotheistic (Abrahamic) religions equally. In order to balance things out though we will need to raise hourly wages across the board by 20% because we'll be only working 4 out of every 5 hours that we do now if I've got my math right. Thursday will be the new Friday. TGIF will become TGIT.
- justinhj 13y agoTo be inclusive should add a day for atheists and misc religions too. Monday works for me
- sokoloff 13y ago25% would be needed to get to equal wages. (4 * 1.25 = 5) The 20% is the amount by which your income would be reduced if you were paid 4/5ths as much as today.
- thyrsus 13y agoSo that's why North Carolina Republicans just outlawed "Shariah law".
- bobdvb 13y agoYet again glad to be in Europe...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- exratione 13y agoThose commenting here who haven't done so already should go read A Distant Mirror: The Calamitous 14th Century. It's a great primer on what life was actually like back then, and what is and isn't known about the details. http://www.amazon.com/Distant-Mirror-Calamitous-14th-Century/dp/0345349571 http://www.amazon.com/Distant-Mirror-Calamitous-14th-Century... The discussion on enclosures and factories seems like a red herring, as that whole mess took off too late in the timeline to be considered Medieval. At the point at which enclosures were happening in a widespread way in (for example) the UK, the economy was transitioned into a state of fairly steady growth in wealth and life expectancy over the long term that would, via compound gains, form the foundation of the Industrial Revolution.
- lhl 13y agoAny article on quality of life in agrarian societies should also be contrasted to what life was like in pre-agrarian (hunter gatherer) societies. Jared Diamond wrote the most well known/accessible essay entitled [The Worst Mistake in the History of the Human Race](http://www.ditext.com/diamond/mistake.html http://www.ditext.com/diamond/mistake.html): > "Are twentieth century hunter-gatherers really worse off than farmers? Scattered throughout the world, several dozen groups of so-called primitive people, like the Kalahari bushmen, continue to support themselves that way. It turns out that these people have plenty of leisure time, sleep a good deal, and work less hard than their farming neighbors. For instance, the average time devoted each week to obtaining food is only 12 to 19 hours for one group of Bushmen, 14 hours or less for the Hadza nomads of Tanzania. One Bushman, when asked why he hadn't emulated neighboring tribes by adopting agriculture, replied, "Why should we, when there are so many mongongo nuts in the world?" Of course, that's sort of besides the point... Before the mid-70's productivity and median compensation were correlated, however for the past 40 years this has diverged. Since 1973, median hourly compensation grew 10.7% while productivity has increased by 80.4%[1] Keyne's prediction in 1930 on the leisure society in the US would have been correct if the public had continued to share in society's gains. Instead these gains have been increasingly captured by the top centile. The share of income by the top 1% has increased over 120% since 1979 [2]. While the top 20% has also nominally increased (~30%) all the other quintiles have had a negative share as a result. Now, knowing this, is there anything that can be done to reverse these trends? It seems that we've been locking in socio-economic mobility [3] and our entire government has entered "regulatory capture." [4][5] [1] http://www.epi.org/publication/ib330-productivity-vs-compensation/ http://www.epi.org/publication/ib330-productivity-vs-compens... [2] http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2011/02/income-inequality-in-america-chart-graph http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2011/02/income-inequalit... [3] http://www.ibtimes.com/us-social-mobility-casualty-income-inequality-922041 http://www.ibtimes.com/us-social-mobility-casualty-income-in... [4] http://i.imgur.com/PVpFY.png http://i.imgur.com/PVpFY.png [5] http://www.the-american-interest.com/article-bd.cfm?piece=1047 http://www.the-american-interest.com/article-bd.cfm?piece=10...
- dunmalg 13y ago>One Bushman, when asked why he hadn't emulated neighboring tribes by adopting agriculture, replied, "Why should we, when there are so many mongongo nuts in the world?" This sentence illustrates one of my main gripes with JD's "sunshine and happiness" view of hunter-gatherer societies. Hunter-gatherer lifestyle is fantastic for that small fraction of folks who live where there are plenty of mongongo nuts (so to speak). He sort of handwaves the majority, who are eking a bare subsistence out of the land, or worse, alternately subsisting and starving.
- smsm42 13y agoYou could easily afford same vacation time - work only half a year, consume at the level of medieval peasant (no TV, no internet, no modern medicine, no car, no fancy foods or clothes, one clothes change a decade, no electricity, no running water, no sanitation/WC) - and you'll have plenty of money left to live the dream second half of the year. I'm sure if you forgo the modern civilization, you can get through pretty cheap. In fact, if you qualify for welfare, you could probably give up working altogether and still live better than medieval peasant (they had no free healthcare, free housing, no foodstamps and no free cell phones). So if you wanted, you could live much better that medieval peasant with 100% "vacation" time. Most people, however, want to live even better, so they work to make this "better" happen. Modern civilization doesn't fall from the sky, you know - people make it.
- makomk 13y agoOf course, with no running water and sanitation, one clothes change in a decade, no car, and no internet connection or electricity you might be hard pushed to find and hold a job for even half a year in the modern era.
- smsm42 13y agoWhy, I'm sure there are some jobs in agriculture always available, and nobody cares how you smell when you're in the fields. There are probably other options too. But there's always 100% vacation options, many people are using it right now.
- Buzaga 13y agoand what a great civilization! Anyway... I think this analysis is shortsighted, for a start, you can't forgo the modern civilization because you can't have a home and you can't leave it, and if you're in it, there's a cost... And it's understood that the right to have somewhere to live is essential but you can't leave the city and get to a piece of land, land is not produced anymore and it belongs to the rich, you can't buy it, you can't raise cattle or chicken and you can't plant, so, you'll die. And then everything else comes after this. Also, lets be honest, the level of education you need to even start pondering this you can't get either, because by then you'd already have had to have eaten and lived somewhere, and maybe you have bills and you can be arrested.. Not such a viable option. Then it's also probably a big fallacy that people can really live off of welfare policy goods, I don't know how it is in the USA, but here in Brazil I'm pretty sure what you get is barely enough for you not to live like a wild animal in middle of 'modern civilization'
- lsc 13y agoWhat I find interesting is how unusual it is for a higher-paid person now to negotiate part-time work. I mean, I've done so at several points in my life, but it's not particularly easy. it's certainly possible, but you need to establish yourself as important to the business (for me, in the past, this has meant working full time for a while.) then do the negotiation, if you want to go half-time. But usually? cutting down below 30 hours a week kills your benefits. Sometimes below 35. Even if you reasonably could afford to pay for health insurance, well, pre-existing conditions keep many of us from buying individual coverage (and individual coverage isn't nearly as tax advantaged as employer-paid coverage, and individual coverage isn't as secure as group coverage; it's much easier for an insurance company to later find a "pre-existing condition" that you didn't note.) But that's the big question. The affordable care act is going to make it so that you can get health insurance on your own, even with pre-existing conditions, (though, I think, employer-paid insurance will still be tax-advantaged) - I wonder how this will effect the number of upper middle class people interested in working part-time. Speaking of, if anyone wants a reasonable sysadmin contractor half time to 3/4 time, I'm available. I'm looking for around $100/hr, but am open to flat rate or other billing mechanisms. I've got a fairly high revenue business (rather more than you'd pay me even full-time) and as such would be happy to go corp to corp. Will work for expansion capital.
- tsotha 13y ago>But that's the big question. The affordable care act is going to make it so that you can get health insurance on your own, even with pre-existing conditions, (though, I think, employer-paid insurance will still be tax-advantaged) - I wonder how this will effect the number of upper middle class people interested in working part-time I would be very surprised if there isn't a rush to the exits from people in their mid 50s if it looks like health care will be affordable. I know I'll be able to retire a full decade earlier if I can get health care for a few hundred bucks a month. As to people working part time... I can see why people would want to (hell, I'd like to do that myself), but I don't think it's going to happen to any great extent. Employers don't like it because there are a lot of per-employee expenses (as opposed to per-hour). Two half-time employees cost more than one full time employee.
- gbog 13y ago"His diet and personal hygiene left much to be desired." Does it means these poor people that happen to be our ancestors had a faint body odor surrounding them? Can we stop with this crasiness? We are animals, animals have "body odor", and it have been considered a good thing for a long time. Every time I hear about personal hygiene I remember this American girl who was learning Chinese with me in a university in south China. She was there on the behalf a sort of NGO and her goal was to "teach Chinese personal hygiene". She was talking about "spreading the use of perfume and deodorant" and such things. So now we have no more colonization, but we still have missionaries, and hygiene missionaries. And they still do harm. (Because yes, abuse of perfumes and deodorant IS harmful in many respects) So, to come back OT, it is ok to wonder if middle-age peasants had more free time, and if their life was pleasant (I guess it was not), but please let our own crasiness out of the discussion. We are the anti body age, anti-body hair, anti-body odor, shaved-porn-age (which is anti-sex), etc. We have our crasiness too. It is very optimistic to believe we are less crasy than the Middle-Age. And God knows Middle-Age was crasy...
- ef4 13y agoOnly someone living in the relative safety of a hygienic society would assume the point of that statement is smell. Medieval peasants died from their lack of hygiene.
- gbog 13y agoI know that. But, without context, if you hear about someone that his "personal hygiene left much to be desired", it just means "he stinks", right? Then when you write about Middle-Age peasants who died for some lack of understanding of contagion mechanism, you do not write "personal hygiene left much to be desired", unless you want to be ironic, sarcastic, or whatever figure de style you are trying to add.
- yaddayadda 13y agoHygiene is much more about 'health' than it is about body odor. Several examples: - brushing one's teeth (minimizing decay and tooth loss) - properly washing one's hands (minimizing the spread of disease) - having toilet facilities (http://www.satoilet.co.za/projects/ http://www.satoilet.co.za/projects/) http://www.wordnik.com/words/hygiene http://www.wordnik.com/words/hygiene
- alexeisadeski3 13y agoThe average American adult works 24.99 hours per week. Just sayin... http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2013-05-13/how-average-american-adult-spends-24-hours-each-day http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2013-05-13/how-average-america...
- maxinem 13y agoIn Guns Germs & Steel by Jared Diamond, I don't recall the exact quote but it is stated that the advent of agriculture with its seasonal work gave those in command a labor pool to use for fighting armies during the low-agriculture work seasons.
- michael_michael 13y agoThe BLS study linked in the article is from 1996. Anyone have a more current source on average vacation time for US workers?
- andyidsinga 13y agothat article suffers from the same fallacy as the ol 'back on your heads' joke: -- a guy dies and goes to hell. upon arrival, the devil allows him to pick one of three rooms where he will then spend eternity. in room one, people are being devoured by horrible beasts. in room two, people are being burned alive ( thats harsh). in room three, everyone is up to their waist in the smelliest, most putrid, disgusting shit he ever encountered -- but they're chit-chatting away, drinking coffee and having donuts. after a brief reflection, the guy chooses the room with waist deep shit, coffee and donuts. a few minutes late the devil comes back and yells "alright scumbags, everyone back on your heads". -- ...in medieval times you got one of the three rooms with the occasional coffee and donut break. nowadays, in our briefer vacations we can be ON A BOAT mf'er - don't you ever forget! :):):)
- socialist_coder 13y agoI was thinking about this the other day- why don't some start ups implement a 4 day workweek? That would be a huge incentive for me to join. Yes, it's less productive, but with 33% more weekend think about how happier the employees would be. I would love to try this with my startup once we get into the profitable stage.
- andy_boot 13y agodont treehouse do that? http://ryancarson.com/post/21708810513/4-day-week http://ryancarson.com/post/21708810513/4-day-week
- wybo 13y agoWhat surprises me here is that virtually all comments are about whether peasants really had many holidays. And not about the current situation (+ the macho 'my hours are longer than yours' trap that most of the California Software world seems to be in...) that drains much of the possibility of having a life besides work. One idea that crossed my mind when I still worked in the Vallley, was that the situation might be reversed by a 'Union' that only concerns itself with working hours. Leaving salaries up to everyone for themselves to negotiate as currently. This would: 1) Allow people a coming-out in terms of favoring work-life balance. Which many people confessed to me in private, but did not dare say in front of their boss/team (has nothing to do with a lack of love for the job/project/company, even love itself you can't enjoy 10 hours a day 50 weeks a year, or that would be the length of billionaires honey-moons. Also what is wrong with loving your life and family/friends in addition to the job, and needing some time for that?). 2) Create a bargaining position and a public face for it. 3) Dispel myths of long-term productivity gains through longer hours. Especially in a creative industry like Software Engineering long hours reduce productivity (there are studies of this + the many self-evaluations on HN over the years of people being able to code consistently and productively 4 to 7 hours per day max). Just an idea that crossed a mind.
- Vivtek 13y agoThe frustrating thing to me is that this article simply shows that a medieval peasant got more vacation time than I do - but doesn't say anything at all about why, even though it's in the title.
- ommunist 13y agoThe thing is that medieval concept of time was not linear. So we cannot really compare how medieval peasants perceived their leisure time with perception of the modern worker. It is like comparing cabbages with golf balls. They are both round, right? I also strongly disagree with the author where it comes to fulfilment. In many cases work is more fulfiling than leisure. What would be really worthy to compare is average length and intensity of copulation, family sizes. But scientific approach has no methods for such s comparison. Yet.