3 ms·
> Nobody is abdicating their humanity and the only "dehumanizing" thing I see is the implication that some people are. Your taking a human relationships issue
by wpietri 13y ago
> Nobody is abdicating their humanity and the only "dehumanizing" thing I see is the implication that some people are.
Your taking a human relationships issue and deciding it based on narrow cost-benefit analysis is definitely dehumanizing. And that's exactly what you're doing by comparing attorney salaries against the cost of resentment.
Hint: if you have to say, "hey, it's nothing personal, it's just business" after somebody is badly treated, then dehumanization is exactly what's happening. It's obviously personal to the person you're saying that to. What that phrase says is that you've decided to treat them impersonally.
- jfarmer 13y agoIt's not my responsibility that they take it personally any more than it's my responsibility as the apartment owner, bar, or bouncer that the person being ejected from the line is taking it personally. As Tumblr, I have no relationship with the person in question. Why isn't it their responsibility to ask if they might use my name first? Why isn't it the loud-talker's responsibility to know the rules of the road (or sidewalk, as it were) before they hop in line? A C&D does not have the force of law. If I build a service that piggy backs off another service without their permission, I shouldn't be surprised that their opening remark is a strongly-worded, "We don't know you. We don't have a relationship with you. We don't like that you're doing this. We don't feel the need to explain ourselves to you. Stop it, now." If we want to talk about empathy and human-to-human interaction, the "human" thing for me to do (IMO) would be to apologize for stepping on that other person's toes and ask what I could do to make it work. The obnoxious thing for me to do would be to stop what I'm doing, set up a milk crate, and start shouting about how this other person is trying to censor me. I don't think it's inhuman to do that, but OTOH I shouldn't be surprised when the other person is suddenly less inclined to make nice. In this case, I would not be saying the same thing if Tumblr's first move were something that carried legal force, in the same way that I think it'd be inappropriate if the first thing the bar did was call the police and file a noise violation rather than tell the person to leave.
- Dylan16807 13y ago>Why isn't it their responsibility to ask if they might use my name first? Jesus, listen to yourself, you sound like a freeman on the land.
- jfarmer 13y agoI have no idea what that phrase means. My point was that I don't think someone else needs to ask my permission to use the my name or my company's name first, but likewise I don't think they should be surprised (let alone indignant) when I ask them knock it off, politely or not. This is doubly true if they're being a bit cheeky and they know it. Honestly, if I'm running a site premised on integrating with another service in a particular way without that service's buy-in, I'm going to expect at some point they'll get in touch with me. If I'm doing something I know they won't like, I'm going to expect that contact will come in the form of something between a strongly-worded email and a C&D. We're talking about a C&D here. This is not some life-ending legal apocalypse. He could simply choose not to respond. He could pay an attorney $100 for an hour of his time if he felt that was too big a risk and learn about nominative use. I just don't think this rises to the level of moral outrage everyone else seems to think it does. I'm not defending Tumblr, but I don't think what they did was beyond the pale.
- wpietri 13y agohttp://lmgtfy.com/?q=freeman+on+the+land&l=1 http://lmgtfy.com/?q=freeman+on+the+land&l=1
- wpietri 13y agoOk, I'm not engaging with your hypothetical, so I'm just going to answer the relevant stuff. A) This guy did not "build a service that piggy backs off another". Certainly not more than every other site-monitoring tool, none of which any reasonable site operator objects to. And if they do, there is a technical solution that is pretty simple. B) The tone of that quote is totally dickish. You might not be surprised to get that, but this guy was surprised, and most people would be. As a fan of Tumblr, he made something for other fans of Tumblr. The proper human response to that is either "Thanks!" or "Thanks, but that's a problem because..." Not some sort of freak-out. C) Your whole made-up interaction is pure fiction, unrelated to anything anybody has said. Your initial argument was about trademark enforcement, so I have no idea where any sort of "service piggybacking" is coming from. D) Tumblr were jerks first, so this guy putting up a notice that is mildly jerky is not an unreasonable response. Also, I just don't get why you're pursuing this so heavily. Given the way you were a) told you were wrong by an expert, b) are getting a lot of push-back on your arguments, and c) are getting downvoted, maybe you should take that a a sign to pause for a while. You seem to have done some good stuff, but this vigorous defense of callous corporate intimidation is off-putting. Like Dylan said, you should really listen to yourself.