2 ms·
Not at top schools where most of a class may well deserve an A or B. Outside of a period in the '60s (the draft) MIT never suffered from serious grade inflatio
by hga 13y ago
Not at top schools where most of a class may well deserve an A or B.
Outside of a period in the '60s (the draft) MIT never suffered from serious grade inflation (I've looked at the numbers), and the general rule is that if you've picked a suitable major you'll make As and Bs unless you're having personal problems.
It would be stark raving mad to grade its students on the curve ... and I've heard of serious pathology in schools that mechanically do, e.g. premeds sabotaging their peers taking organic chemistry (one tale had one deactivating many of his peers' alarm clocks). You just don't want to set up the wrong incentives, and I can attest that at least in the '80s MIT students were generally happy to help each other.
On the other hand there are state schools that by law have to accept every applicant who meets a random external threshold ... they don't have much choice but to flunk out large fractions of their freshman. But after the courses that do that, and often do that for a major, they shouldn't obsess on the curve.
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoMIT accepts only very smart people, to apply differentiation at that level wouldn't work very well: the motivation and aspiration has already been satisfied by the MIT selection process! But even a good hard-to-get-into department (computer science) at a good state school (UW) has a fairly diverse-ability student body, so curves are quite useful in creating some top to aspire to. Even here, since the students got into the department and the bell curve is fairly fat in the middle (hard to fail), it doesn't create for such a toxic environment as being at the top is nice but definitely not necessary (even if you want to go to grad school). The trouble starts where being at the top is necessary (pre-med).
- hga 13y agoIt also matters a bit more in the sciences, where an undergraduate degree is just a ticket to get a Ph.D. unless you want a career as a lab tech. Also, this is in the context of Princeton, one of the best of the Ivies, I'm told the most academically rigorous. I suppose ... ah, here's the key: the Ivies have to admit way too many "legacies", children of alums. Enough that it makes a massive difference in their student bodies compared to MIT, where being the child of an alum doesn't hurt, but is no help at all if MIT judges you can't do the required calculus and calculus based physics. So maybe it does make sense to grade on a curve ... still, MIT grades on mastery, and I know if I found myself in this situation: The undergraduate student body president, Connor Diemand-Yauman, a senior from Chesterland, Ohio, said: “I had complaints from students who said that their professors handed back exams and told them, ‘I wanted to give 10 of you A’s, but because of the policy, I could only give five A’s.’ When students hear that, an alarm goes off.” [ Followed by the dean of the undergraduate college admitting they've got a fixed quota system. ] (http://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/31/education/31princeton.html http://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/31/education/31princeton.html) I'd find another school to transfer to, or at the minimum work out an arrangement for a great grad school recommendation from the guilty faculty (would not be hard since I can/could do research).
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoI agree that the curve should really be at the discretion of the instructor, not administrators, who is best fit to apply it reasonably. One of my colleagues was actually told the opposite in a class he taught recently: that he was failing or not giving A's to enough students in the classes he was teaching! It definitely goes both ways, but instructors are reasonably fit to decide how to do their curves.
- hga 13y agoThe latter happens more than a little at MIT, and I've witnessed a department head tell a professor you've very possibly heard of that he'd never be allowed to teach a particular course again. That was after making him read every student evaluation, were were uniformly negative except for a single special case, which wasn't exactly positive.
- hkmurakami 13y ago>The undergraduate student body president, Connor Diemand-Yauman, a senior from Chesterland, Ohio, said: “I had complaints from students who said that their professors handed back exams and told them, ‘I wanted to give 10 of you A’s, but because of the policy, I could only give five A’s.’ When students hear that, an alarm goes off.” This exact thing happened to my friend in our 2nd year intro circuits course. The prof (awesome guy) wanted to give him an A but couldn't because of the quota and told him this in person. Said friend, as fate would have it, is thriving at MSFT and is currently a Senior Program Manager there.