5 ms·
Here's a commentator at Mini-Microsoft explaining why it probably became more toxic over time, and it looks like these changes happened before the author arrive
by hga 13y ago
Here's a commentator at Mini-Microsoft explaining why it probably became more toxic over time, and it looks like these changes happened before the author arrived:
http://minimsft.blogspot.com/2013/08/steve-ballmer-is-going-to-frickin.html?showComment=1377372530878#c2642513338204621608 http://minimsft.blogspot.com/2013/08/steve-ballmer-is-going-...
Anonymous said...
My memory is really good - [ current head of HR ] is the one who did away with the "life-time performance average" which let people take huge risks and made Microsoft great.
THAT, was huge BillG wisdom. You could look at your score over time and do some really simple math to see what kinds of risks you could take. And then suddenly, a 15-year running average of 4.0 turned into "your current manager doesn't like you, and he's required to fire one of his 10 no matter what, so you're fired".
She also did away with the standing rule that you could take any written standing offer - NO MATTER WHAT (unless you were actually fired for cause) - which was Bill's way of ensuring that great engineers couldn't be tossed out by one horrible ass-kissing manager ... which is pretty much all of them today.
The day that it became possible for a single crappy manager to fire someone for saying "I disagree", or "That's Wrong". Microsoft died.
And when's the last time you saw that lovely deck of laminated cards that started with "a passion for technology" ... and a really logical employee development plan? yea, right, somewhere around 1995.
[ People who need to leave. ]
- vonmoltke 13y agoI think the problems started when they hit their monopoly phase and Windows became a cash cow. It probably looked at that point like they had "won" and all they had to do was keep the upgrade chain going. Don't need to innovate; that would rock the boat and risk the cow.
- Florin_Andrei 13y agoThat's an awfully early point in time. Lady Diana was definitely alive back then.
- hkmurakami 13y agoIt's taken oldtime winners like Xerox and Kodak decades to wither away and die too.
- Jare 13y agoStrictly speaking, a monopoly / cash cow phase creates a context in which bad practices will not kill your company and are not removed by natural selection. It allows these bad practices to survive and thrive, but it does not create the practices themselves. I think the distinction is important, because removing the cash cow will not fix the problems, but instead let these problems run the company into the ground. RIM is probably a perfect example of this process, and Microsoft is not, which gives credibility to the idea that, for all its failings, Microsoft has in fact been able to embrace a number of innovations and new markets (Xbox, Azure, enterprise...).
- joe_the_user 13y agoInterestingly, some classic monopolies, like the old AT&T and Xerox, innovated tremendously but would fail to capitalize on those innovations (Bell Labs & Unix, Xerox and the Mouse/Menu/etc GUI).
- nostrademons 13y agoI think this is the more common failure mode - a lot of innovative work happens at big companies, but those innovations never make it to market because commercializing a product requires a large investment in, well, finding customers, and the innovators at big companies are not empowered to do this. There is still a ton of innovative research work coming out of Microsoft, Intel, and even IBM, but typically instead of being commercialized and profited from, it languishes until the company shuts down the research lab and the scientists involved get jobs elsewhere.
- hga 13y agoThe original AT&T was an official government monopoly so the very existence of Bell Labs was in part a tax it payed to avoid problems. As I recall it also wasn't allowed to do things like sell UNIX(TM) for serious money prior to the United States v. AT&T 1982 consent decree ... which I notice is the same year UNIX System III was released. Xerox, though ... well, a good book on that is Fumbling the Future: http://www.amazon.com/Fumbling-Future-Invented-Personal-Computer/dp/1583482660/ http://www.amazon.com/Fumbling-Future-Invented-Personal-Comp... ... which is still in print after it's 1988 debut. That isn't even an example of disruptive innovations almost never happening in established companies, Xerox just wasn't doing that sort of thing to begin with. Well, they bought Scientific Data Systems at the top in 1969 and fumbled that by the middle of the '70s....
- jmspring 13y agoPer the article - fostering a system that allows for taking big risks and possibly failing, but showing a track record over time of succeeding is much more beneficial to a company than yearly or half yearly cycles producing a number that has to fit a curve starting with comparing you against the peers in your group. Projects, life circumstances, and many other factors can have a one time effect. Also, yes, Windows and Office are cash cows. MSFT is a company of 90k+ people, they aren't all working on the cash cows. There are individuals trying to create new products, enter new markets, etc. It is a complicated ecosystem. I'm pretty sure it was new HR and HR policies along with Bill relinquishing control that spurred a change in dynamics.
- maw 13y agoShe also did away with the standing rule that you could take any written standing offer - NO MATTER WHAT (unless you were actually fired for cause) - which was Bill's way of ensuring that great engineers couldn't be tossed out by one horrible ass-kissing manager ... which is pretty much all of them today. I've read this about ten times and still don't understand it. Do you know what it is supposed to mean?
- hga 13y agoWhat that means is that if your manager is terminating you with extreme prejudice (but "without cause", e.g. not for stealing from the company), he's not allowed to be a gatekeeper and prevent you from joining another team. E.g. one that knows you are great and your manager is of the "horrible ass-kissing" variety. Let me supply another comment, which shows how terribly bad some very high levels of managers have become: http://minimsft.blogspot.com/2013/08/steve-ballmer-is-going-to-frickin.html?showComment=1377380382013#c3322100820840904710 http://minimsft.blogspot.com/2013/08/steve-ballmer-is-going-... Anonymous said... O.k. here are my 3 favorite Microsoft "principle consultant" experiences: 1. I had this really brilliant L-62 dev who couldn't believe just how STUPID the "chief architects" (L-65 and up, really were). So, one day, one of them walked into our office and took great offense because we'd changed his slides ... Without even blinking, he said "you can change the text all you want, but you can't change my pictures, because that's all people look at." As he was trying to explain to the guy that the "pictures" came from the actual "data" ... I suddenly realized that this moron didn't actually know where charts came from, and I excused myself and waited in the hallway for the really great partner consultant who thought I had a really bad attitude problem, to come flying out, desperately in need of a drink. It took 10 minutes. I took him out for a cup of coffee so no one saw him shaking, throwing things, and revisiting his whole opinion of Microsoft. Seriously, that one wins - but not by much 2). And the same great dev marched off one day to to tell the lead architect that the product he was planning to use, just didn't work that way ... And that one's just plain funny. The "Architect" (who I wouldn't hire to build a computer for a 5-year-old, looked really annoyed, pulled out a glossy marketing folder, pointed and said 'of course it does - IT SAYS SO, RIGHT HERE." Right. Bill Gates would have just shot these people and put their heads on stakes around the castle. [ 3rd example is a bit more intricate but just as bad. ]