5 ms·
Graphing calculators are entirely unnecessary for learning high school/college mathematics/physics/etc. (though they might be useful for engineering students wo
by jacobolus 13y ago
Graphing calculators are entirely unnecessary for learning high school/college mathematics/physics/etc. (though they might be useful for engineering students working on-site where access to a full computer is impractical – I don't have such experience with that, so can’t comment).
There is no good pedagogical reason for assigning problems to students which use numbers that can’t be worked out easily on paper or with a regular scientific calculator. Forcing students to expend effort on keeping track of many-digit numbers is in general an unnecessary mental load which distracts from the concepts being taught. Including "how to use your calculator" sections as part of mathematics instruction, and assigning "calculator problems" which include e.g. unreasonably complex symbolic integration problems or unreasonably precise numbers, for the sake of giving students practice with a graphing calculator interface is a waste of teacher and student effort.
Additionally, Because Texas Instruments has so effectively lobbied textbook authors and test writers and school administrations to get their calculators on the list of approved/official devices, many students are prompted to spend an unreasonable amount of money on calculators which they do not need. It’s something like a tax on those students.
TI graphing calculators have awful, obtuse interfaces. Their programming and debugging tools are rudimentary and outdated. Their graphics capabilities are limited, and graphics made with them can’t be used for any other purpose or easily shared. Students would be much better served by lessons/mentoring on the use of regular general-purpose computers and programming languages, whether for mathematics or whatever else. If they need symbolic integration or graphing capabilities for solving some concrete engineering problem, or for exploring, they would be much better served by a tool such as Mathematica or Maple [or heck, Python] than by a TI calculator. Full computers are much better for inputting and interacting with data and mathematical structures.
It's been 9 years since I was in high school. But on principle, I never bought a graphing calculator, and I never found it to be any disadvantage in any course I encountered in high school or college [except, briefly, on the AP Calculus test, where I had to familiarize myself with the TI83's awful UI on a borrowed calculator during the test; it didn’t end up hurting my score]. However, I found programming in Maple, and later Python, to be invaluable in solving all sorts of problems.
- freehunter 13y agoI personally loved using my graphing calculator especially in classes where it was not required. Statistics and accounting, for example, were classes were we were expected to memorize formulas that I found to be difficult to learn. Come test day, though, I had programmed those formulas into a note on my TI 86. The teachers always gave their reasons why they were forcing us to memorize these equations that in the real world we would have written down (or use software to solve for us), but I never bought into it. And they never forced me to erase my calculator's memory before the exam.
- pigscantfly 13y agoMy high school roommate bought a TI calculator keyboard to efficiently type in formulas/notes before exams - probably the best investment he made. I remember programming a basic quadratic equation solver at the end of a math exam sophomore year, because I had extra time and had already checked the test once. I didn't find any mistakes, but I wrote out the code on the back of the test and got an extra credit point :). I'm torn, because although TI calculators are pretty undeniably a sinkhole of innovation and unnecessary to most students, I loved (still love) mine so damn much. I'd rather have them update the system and their prices (which if anything have risen on the same models since I was in high school) than get them out of schools entirely. But maybe that's just nostalgia thinking for me.
- zokier 13y agoOf course memorizing not sensible. That's why we have cheat sheets and/or standardized reference booklets. Practical, and more importantly fair to all students because they all have the same material available.
- Nicholas_C 13y ago>Come test day, though, I had programmed those formulas into a note on my TI 86. So you cheated?
- freehunter 13y agoYes. I comforted myself in saying I had come up with a creative solution for problem solving and that I was justified in rebelling against the teacher who assumed everyone was a finance major. But in essence, yeah. I cheated. And I passed.