5 ms·
I am going to get my drum out and bang on it again. Software is a form of literacy - and we measure literacy completely differently. In fact we measure it lik
by lifeisstillgood 13y ago
I am going to get my drum out and bang on it again.
Software is a form of literacy - and we measure literacy completely differently. In fact we measure it like we measure science - you are not a scientist unless other scientists agree you are, and you are not a coder unless other coders say you are.
What Fowler wants to measure is not the top echelons of productivity but the lower bounds - presumably to winnow out the unproductive ones.
But that is not how we conduct ourselves in literacy or science. We educate and train people for a very long time, so that the lower bound of productivity is still going to add value to human society - and the upper bounds are limitless.
What Fowler is asking for is a profession.
- rabino 13y agoThis. A million times this.
- joshyeager 13y agoYour last sentence is exactly right. There are significant benefits to building a profession that is predictable and well-defined. Ensuring a reasonable lower bound reduces the risk of failure significantly. The open questions are 1) whether it's possible to do that, and 2) whether it's possible to do that without inadvertently imposing an upper bound. Common wisdom among software developers is that it is not possible and even if it was it would impose a very tight upper bound. But as far as I know, that common wisdom is just guess work. No one has found a good solution yet, but there's also no proof that there is not one. That's why so many people continue to try.
- gdubs 13y agoI agree with the sentiment of your last paragraph, though in fairness Fowler seemed to end his piece saying that measurement was seductive and likely to make things worse. Still, I can't help cringe at some of the ideas posited -- for one, the idea that more features == a better product. Or that profit is a measure of engineering productivity. As if it's that uncommon for great products to be badly marketed.
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoI think Fowler was just reaching for a stick to beat the metric he was deconstructing - "look Joe writes only 10K lines but makes ten times the profit - that means LoC is not a good metric." However I do think that (free) market success is a reasonable measure of value / worth - backed up by my favourite quote for which I can find no author: "Many books are unfairly forgotten, but none are unfairly remembered."
- gdubs 13y agoMeasuring value (profit) isn't going to be a reliable indicator of how well something was engineered. There's too many badly engineered products that make tons of money, and too many brilliantly engineered products that are commercial flops. So many other elements are involved -- finding the right audience, marketing correctly to them, luck, etc.
- skrebbel 13y agoI agree with what you're saying, but I feel that it's exactly what Fowler is saying too. The article is called "cannot measure productivity", after all. What parts of what he writes do you disagree with?
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoFairy Nuff I suppose he ends with throwing his hands in the air and saying we cannot do it. Well actually we can achieve a measure of literacy, just not perhaps fluency. We know if a child can read and read well. It's possible to take their written work and assess or mark it. We can (and do in code reviews) do the same for code written by adults. The problem he is stating is IMO in two parts - measuring basic competence (is a person of net benefit, can they write competent code, are they literate?) which is possible, and how good are they compared to their peers, which is much more subjective and based on taste as much as anything. So I agree we should not try to measure productivity, I disagree that that's the end of the conversation, mostly because I disagree that productivity is one thing - I see it as more Hygiene/Motivator
- foobarbazqux 13y ago> you are not a scientist unless other scientists agree you are Science requires one thing: making and testing falsifiable hypotheses. A priest is able to determine whether or not you are doing that. If anything, it's philosophers who decide what science is, e.g. Karl Popper.
- swombat 13y agoDoing science does not make you a scientist.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- epenn 13y agoCan you elaborate on why you believe this to be the case? Saying that a scientist is one who does science seems like a truism bordering on being tautological. I'm curious why you disagree.
- swombat 13y agoDoes knowing a bit of physics make you a physicist? Does praying make you a monk? Does mixing a few chemicals make you a chemist? Does having some theories about people's motivations make you a behavioural psychologist? Does balancing a budget make you an accountant? "Scientist" implies a certain amount of knowledge, training, discipline, etc. I'm not implying that every scientist needs to have undergone academic training - there are other ways - but merely doing a scientific experiment is not enough to call yourself a scientist. A scientist is one who "does science" with some knowledge, consistency and perseverance.
- foobarbazqux 13y agoI guess you'd better edit Wikipedia: > In a more restricted sense, a scientist is an individual who uses the scientific method. [...] This article focuses on the more restricted use of the word. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientist https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientist
- __--__ 13y agoyou are not a coder unless other coders say you are Not everybody needs the approval of an external entity. I couldn't care less what other coders think of me. What I ship speaks for itself. What I write speaks for itself. What studies scientists publish speak for themselves. The rest is politics.
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoScientists must pass peer review to publish, and peer review can be very harsh. Double blind helps winnow out political bias. Coders must get jobs to continue coding if they are not independently wealthy. Bias abounds in this case, as other coders with influence must vouch for you, and...in this case your projects can influence their opinion of you. We are social creatures: we don't live as hermits (most of us anyways).
- benched 13y agoIt was still an inflammatory thing to say, given that there's nothing stopping a person who does live as a hermit from learning to write working code. In the days before the Web, I created two good-sized adventure games without ever having interacted with another programmer (save maybe 2 book authors). Nobody vetted me. I just made and released them. The lone wolf programmer has always been a thing.
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoBut if you are working alone as a hermit, why do titles even matter? Titles are just something someone uses to classify you, and in isolation mean nothing (unless you have split personalities; joking, schizophrenia is a serious subject).
- foobarbazqux 13y agoThe psychiatric definition of schizophrenia doesn't have anything to do with split or multiple personalities. That's actually more like dissociative identity disorder. I know this is a widespread misconception, I used to think the same thing.