6 ms·
>>She's a woman. She's a CEO. She's guaranteed to have a target on her back. I don't think her being a woman is terribly relevant here. All CEOs regardless of
by enraged_camel 13y ago
>>She's a woman. She's a CEO. She's guaranteed to have a target on her back.
I don't think her being a woman is terribly relevant here. All CEOs regardless of gender, race, nationality, etc. have enemies. That's what it takes to rise to the top in corporate politics. People smile in your face and stab you in the back at the earliest opportunity.
One could make the case that she has more enemies due to being a successful woman in technology, but I think that would pale in comparison to the number of enemies she has due to her job title alone.
- btilly 13y agoRead the article again. Notice how many of the ways in which she was being criticized were things you could only really say about a woman? Having enemies comes with the job. Your enemies will attack you as they can. Being a woman gives them culturally acceptable ways to attack you that they can't use against men.
- RyanZAG 13y agoNot necessarily disagreeing, but if a male CEO was posing in a fashion magazine, he would get just as much criticism.
- minikites 13y agoMissing the point: a male CEO wouldn't pose in a fashion magazine because that's not how we treat men. http://www.buzzfeed.com/jpmoore/men-ups-manly-men-in-classic-pin-up-poses http://www.buzzfeed.com/jpmoore/men-ups-manly-men-in-classic... See how peculiar it looks?
- arjie 13y agoI'm curious. Googling reveals that these posts are fairly common. The funny thing is that there aren't any photos of women in stereotypically male poses. Is that because there aren't any such poses or because no one feels a need to try it out? I'd like to see if those look as ridiculous.
- asdfdsa1234 13y agoMayer chose to pose in a fashion magazine. She wasn't "treated" any way in this case.
- lambda 13y agoReally? Like Donald Trump on the cover of GQ? How much criticism did he get for that?
- sp332 13y agoI think you're underestimating the amount of criticism she got. It's been pretty crazy.
- slurry 13y agoa. What's wrong with a fashion magazine? Vogue adds a metric ton more value to civil discourse than most business magazines combined. b. Given the borderline-soft-porn treatment Elon Musk gets around here, I think we should collectively hold off on criticizing anyone for going overboard on such matters.
- rjknight 13y agoWell, yes, but her opponents are also dismissed as "macho loudmouth[s]", which is something you can only really say about a man. That's not to say that all of the criticism of Mayer is fair or justified. I imagine that very little of it is. But I suspect that she's being criticised much more for having ideas, and the will to pursue them, than she is for being female (say, an 80/20 split). But it's a lot easier for people who don't care about the intricacies of Yahoo's product strategy to talk about her gender than it is to talk about her ideas for Yahoo's products.
- zhemao 13y agoI don't think people criticize male CEOs as much for "having ideas and the will to pursue them." You can't say there isn't a gender-based double standard for CEOs obsessed with product to the degree that they sometimes offend their employees. Steve Jobs was known to berate and verbally abuse his employees, but people excused it because he was a "genius" and a "visionary". Meanwhile, the worst Mayer has done is ask work-from-home employees to return to the office and people call her a "princess".
- cantankerous 13y agoI think the language is indicative of an entrenched male culture at the top trying to cope with a strong female leader from the outside. It's kind of the worst of both worlds. Sure, being a woman isn't the only thing, Mayer is also in tech. Top management probably finds that weird, too. However, calling her things like "a princess" or "stuck up" is incredibly patronizing and sexist. Everybody knows those words pretty much don't apply to grown men in a situation like this. That's to say, given the set of circumstances the semantics of these labels are specific to her gender. I can't help but think people take issue with her gender, and then criticize her on the product front specifically so do they don't look sexist....which is why you see all this criticism that lacks proper justification about her strategy at Yahoo.
- lambda 13y agoI think it's incredibly relevant. Many of the criticisms she's received seem quite gender biased. Let's see. One of the big ones is "she had a baby." Well, that's something that only a female CEO could do. And she took two weeks of maternity leave for it; no more than many CEOs take for vacation. That entire criticism seems to be "she's a woman", and wouldn't be applied to a male CEO who took a similar length family vacation. Time claims that she has a "princess problem". Would any male CEO be described the same way? And they go on to say "She is one of only 21 female CEOs in the Fortune 500. Doesn’t she owe it to us to tell us how she got there?" Um, why would she owe anyone anything just because she's a female CEO? The problem isn't that she's made enemies in the business sense. The problem is that lots of writers and columnists seem to focus more on her gender, and apply criticisms simply because she's female.
- enraged_camel 13y ago>>The problem isn't that she's made enemies in the business sense. The problem is that lots of writers and columnists seem to focus more on her gender, and apply criticisms simply because she's female. When I said "enemies" I was focusing on people within Yahoo!. Who cares about what writers and columnists say? They will write anything to get readers.
- cantankerous 13y agoThis article is about what a specific writer says along with a few different talking heads. I think it's totally relevant.
- bostonpete 13y agoI haven't followed the Yahoo saga too closely, but I thought the baby related criticism was related to her revoking people ability to work remotely while simultaneously building a nursery right next to her office so she could be near her own child. I don't recall any criticism of her 2 weeks of maternity leave.
- slurry 13y ago
- sp332 13y agoThat's true, but somehow Meyer having enemies is newsworthy whereas for any other CEO it's not really remarked.
- karnajani 13y agois there any reason to believe that Yahoo had not already shared information with government agencies?