9 ms·
Round-up: ✗ EL panels (not yet) ✗ Smart glass (unless you own a ferrari) ✓ Frozen meals + programmable microwave ✓ Lame robots ✓ 3D movies ✗ Fusion power
by ricardobeat 13y ago
Round-up:
✗ EL panels (not yet)
✗ Smart glass (unless you own a ferrari)
✓ Frozen meals + programmable microwave
✓ Lame robots
✓ 3D movies
✗ Fusion power plants
✗ Radioactive batteries
✓ Solar power
✓ Self-driving cars (in progress)
✗ Moving sidewalks (do airport conveyors count?)
✓ Video calls
✓ Mobile data, sharing, e-books
✓ Global mobile phone network
✗ Moon colonies (double fail since he just takes them for granted)
✓ Fiber-optics
✓ Unmanned mars missions, plans for a colony (mars one etc)
✓ Flat screen TVs
✓ 3D display tech demos
✓ Meat substitutes
✓ Digital teaching aids (kinda)
✓ Boredom and consumerism
- zanny 13y agoOn some of the missing ones: 1. We have at least one fusion plant I know of, the UK Joint Torus, which I know have been operating for decades. It just consumes more power than it generates. But Asimov suggests one or two, which is strikingly accurate. 2. We could probably make radio-decay batteries (maybe not AA size, but car batteries running on Thorium or some such, albeit an extremely expensive containment for something running so hot). We probably just don't do it because the radiation risks are too high. And I'd count airport conveyors as moving sidewalks. Or just the complexity of baggage carrying systemes in those airports, lend that we easily have the technoloy to create weather resistant rotary motor systems as sidewalks, but like Asimovs suggestions of underground housing, cost is the bigger prohibitor than technology. Also, I don't think the degree of boredom he touches on has occured. Consumerism and the wealth concentration in the US has kept people needing to maintain 40 hour work weeks where productivity is magnitudes higher. We produce vastly more, but work as much as ever. Back in the 60s the sentiment was that 21st century Americans might have 10 hour work weeks.
- dllu 13y ago1. The National Ignition Facility [1] recently reported record amounts of energy produced by laser-based fusion, but it is more of a research facility than a power plant. 2. Do the betavoltaics [2] in some early pacemakers and the small reactor on spacecraft and the Mars Science Laboratory count as radioactive batteries? But I am assuming that, since betavoltaic pacemakers and nuclear spacecraft have been around since Asimov's time, they probably don't count. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Ignition_Facility http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Ignition_Facility [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betavoltaics http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betavoltaics
- morpher 13y agoThe wikipedia page doesn't seem to have any information about "record amounts of energy produced" at NIF. The closest thing I've found is a press release[1] that mentions "highest [neutron] yield achieved so far from a layered DT implosion". Neutron production should be proportional to the number of fusion events (and thus also the energy released). But, its odd that they don't claim this specifically. [1] https://lasers.llnl.gov/newsroom/project_status/index.php https://lasers.llnl.gov/newsroom/project_status/index.php
- ricardobeat 13y agoOn 2, NASA does use radioactive decay batteries on the rovers, but it's still 'space tech' :) > where productivity is magnitudes higher Overall, yes. Per worker? Hell no. Half or more of current jobs are pushing paper and doing meaningless bureaucratic work. Related article from last week: www.strikemag.org/bullshit-jobs/
- itafroma 13y ago> > where productivity is magnitudes higher > Overall, yes. Per worker? Hell no. Half or more of current jobs are pushing paper and doing meaningless bureaucratic work. Actually, productivity per worker has grown for most developed countries. The Bureau of Labor Statistics has a wealth of information on the subject: http://www.bls.gov/fls/intl_gdp_capita_gdp_hour.htm http://www.bls.gov/fls/intl_gdp_capita_gdp_hour.htm Of note is chart 6, which shows GDP per hour worked has grown, albeit slowly, for most developed countries; and table 2a, which shows real GDP per employed person has more than doubled since 1960 for the US, and in some developed countries like Japan, increased 6-7x.
- ricardobeat 13y agoIf you consider 'productivity' as generating financial wealth, yes, but GDP is not a material measure. Going solely by that, bankers would be the most productive workers on earth, and I'm sure lots of people would disagree.
- mortehu 13y agoLight bouys[1] also use radioisotope generators. 1. http://www.uspowerboating.com/Assets/TrainingDept/Powerboat+files/Education/uss-MoA-Buoy.jpg http://www.uspowerboating.com/Assets/TrainingDept/Powerboat+...
- learc83 13y agoThey used to use radioisotope powered batteries in cardiac pacemakers up until the mid 80s.
- ctdonath 13y agoLike with the prescient Ladies' Home Journal predictions, much of what hasn't happened isn't so much that we couldn't do it, but that we can do it and find it uninteresting or inconvenient after all (like moon colonies: doable, just not much point given the cost involved vs benefits).
- williadc 13y agoIt is irritating to hear claims that something can be done which has never been done. As evidenced by every project I've ever worked on, people have a very poor idea of how much work it takes to accomplish a task. There are very likely hurdles to building moon colonies that you have not considered.
- rpedela 13y agoThere is a big difference between saying something is possible and saying something is easy. I don't think it is easy to build a moon colony. On the other hand, I do not see any scientific or engineering reason why it is not possible. We have already proven we can land on the moon and that we can build space colonies (i.e. ISS). Sure there are hurdles I have not considered, but that just makes it hard not impossible.
- dredmorbius 13y agoGiven that we've not been able to create a self-contained biosphere on Earth, the prospect for long-term environmental support on the Moon seems low. The IIS gets regular resupplies to keep its environmental support systems operational and habitable.
- waterlesscloud 13y agoThere's no requirement that a lunar colony be self-sustaining in order to qualify as a lunar colony.
- 13y ago
- dalek_cannes 13y ago> We produce vastly more, but work as much as ever. Back in the 60s the sentiment was that 21st century Americans might have 10 hour work weeks. Isn't that because we now have a very large semi-parasitical managerial class that we need to support? It's almost a retreat into feudalism. Doubt anybody saw that coming.
- Houshalter 13y agoThat doesn't make a lot of sense. People don't work because they want to support someone else, they work because they want to support themselves.
- dclowd9901 13y agoHe's trying to make the case that there's some great conspiracy to keep people employed in jobs that shouldn't exist. I suppose he'll next tell us that the rich are "job creators."
- solistice 13y agoI'm not sure what you think job creators are. Is it some kind of medal you get when you employ someone? Do you loose it if you fire them? What kind of conditions constitutes employing? Do I get to be a job creator if I give you a dollar for explaining your point? Job providers, I get why those are important. Not everyone wants to be bothered with the business side of living, along with its risks. I can actually see how that division of labour and responsibilities aids both sides of the equation. But if you count self-employment, there's job providers on every rung of the social ladder. The chinese guy selling chua'r on the street is a job provider, just as much as the multimillion entrepreneur employing thousands of people. So it becomes senseless to say that one wealth bracket supplies jobs, and another one doesn't. And then there's "job creation", which seems like a meaningless metric if you don't factor in loss of jobs, current amount of jobs, unemployment, etc. And you seriously want to pin that metric down on a single group? By the way, if the take the logic further, and look at who's implicated in major job destruction (layoffs), it's us. Hackers. I'm going from the Systems optimization definition here, and when you optimize away a part of a system, someone's bound to get fired. Your packaging machine eliminated 5 packaging workers. Your fiber optic cable eliminated 50 post office workers. They're being added, somewhere.
- throwaway_yy2Di 13y agoWe have at least one fusion plant I know of, the UK Joint Torus, which I know have been operating for decades. It operated ("actually sustained fusion") for a total of four seconds, in 1997. Most of the work involves non-fusion plasmas. http://www.jet.efda.org/wp-content/uploads/jeteuropeansucess.pdf http://www.jet.efda.org/wp-content/uploads/jeteuropeansucess... That was a costly experiment: the resulting radiation -- neutron activation of the structure -- made the reactor inaccessible for 18 months. http://www.iop.org/Jet/fulltext/JETP98037.pdf http://www.iop.org/Jet/fulltext/JETP98037.pdf
- rpedela 13y agoThere are several teams working on a dense plasma focus design for fusion rather than the large and expensive tokamak or laser designs. What I like about dense plasma focus is if it works, little or no neutrons (bad radiation), the apparatus is the size of a garage, extremely cheap for a power plant. As far as I am aware, these guys are the closest to achieving a fusion power plant with dense plasma focus: http://lawrencevilleplasmaphysics.com/ http://lawrencevilleplasmaphysics.com/
- singingfish 13y agounderground building will always be more expensive than the above ground equivalent. Some of the more interesting close to underground alternatives are still very costly in labour (earthships, straw bale), and not thoroughly tested in many climates. Engineered below ground construction will always cost a shit-tonne in concrete and waterproofing (source - just built an engineered 3.5 metre downstairs in a 2m cut on the side of a hill).
- jacquesm 13y agoWhile we don't have underground housing underground malls are not exactly rare. Montreal, Toronto and many other places besides.
- madaxe 13y agoWe have "radio-decay batteries" - RTGs. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioisotope_thermoelectric_generator http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioisotope_thermoelectric_gen... They can be miniaturised, using the photoelectric effect, alphavoltaics or betavoltaics. We do not use them because "Nuclear is bad, m'kay?", and the market just isn't there, so the R&D hasn't happened.
- coldtea 13y ago>We do not use them because "Nuclear is bad, m'kay?" The irony is nice but misplaced. We already have a huge problem disposing the toxic waste of regular batteries. Not to mention what other misuses those could have if accessed by the random lunatic....
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoWouldn't the Hong Kong escalators count as moving side walks?
- gradstudent 13y agoThe 3D movies we have now are not the type Asimov is talking about. He's describing holograms.
- ricardobeat 13y agoHe mentions both kinds: 3D movies (Robot of the Future) as a given, and a 3D rotating cube hologram as a tech demo.
- saraid216 13y ago> ✗ Smart glass (unless you own a ferrari) I used to have corrective glasses that did what he described. I can't remember what the type of lens was called, and Google is being unhelpful. But walking in and out of shade was definitely a bit annoying because it kept repolarizing. > ✗ Moving sidewalks (do airport conveyors count?) I'd say so. Open question: how would we put benches on moving sidewalks? P.S. I am amused you didn't include hovercars.
- pserwylo 13y agoI recently read an interesting New Scientist article in an old (2009) magazine[0] which explains how to use moving sidewalks for mass public transit. Spoiler alert - it has actually been done before! [0] - http://web.archive.org/web/20090809091201/http://www.newscientist.com/article/mg20327200.200-how-the-moving-walkway-nearly-overtook-the-metro.html http://web.archive.org/web/20090809091201/http://www.newscie... (using wayback machine because new site is behind paywal)
- saraid216 13y agoI guess making the sidewalks a circular deal would make the benches problem pretty easy to solve. I was really more hoping for some scheme to expand and collapse the benches.
- beambot 13y agoSmart Glass: Transitions lenses change opacity based on incident UV light levels. They work great, and I love 'em.
- speeder 13y agoHere in Sao Paulo there is a moving sidewalk connecting two major metro stations, it is really cool for most part, but sometimes shit happens, like when one asshole decide to stop at its exit, or when someone fall, or when it breaks.
- olalonde 13y agoThere are also lots of those in Hong Kong and Shenzhen, though most of them are indoors.
- InclinedPlane 13y agoEL panels: those exist, you're probably staring at one right now, it's behind your LCD. LED lighting is also fairly common these days. It's certainly possible for exactly what is described to be installed in a house, it's just not particularly desired. Adjustable transmissivity glass is a reality but not yet practical enough for it to be ubiquitous. Radioactive batteries very much do exist, they are called RTGs, and they have given great benefit to spacecraft and other equipment. They power the Curiosity rover, for example. However, they are too impractical and too expensive to be used for ordinary household equipment. This would be true even without the radiation problems of RTGs, which are, of course, significant. We should have moon colonies by now and ironically the Apollo program is probably the most at fault for that. In order to make it happen a lot of political capital was expended, creating a particular political situation which has become a permanent institution within NASA manned spaceflight (specifically, billions of federal dollars flowing into a few very specific congressional districts which has continued through Apollo and Shuttle programs and now SLS/Orion). If NASA had instead concentrated on a slower program which built up long-lived infrastructure and optimized toward lowering launch costs and increasing capabilities then we would easily have cities (or at least towns) in orbit and moonbases, and Mars bases.
- wildgift 13y agoThe cold war ended, and there was no longer a need to prove that we could send something up into space and rain down fiery death upon anyone on the planet. Hence, no more space program.
- InclinedPlane 13y agoThat's not entirely true. Even after the end of the Cold War the manned spaceflight program in the US has received several billion dollars a year in funding. It's more than possible to operate a quite proficient manned exploration and colonization program with funding at that level. The problem is more that NASA and congress have been completely ineffectual at using resources effectively. The ISS was almost entirely built and launched after the end of the Cold War, and it's total cost was at least 50% greater than the entire Apollo program, for example.
- scheff 13y agoI would be willing to consider the International Space Station an equivalent of the Moon colonies, as it serves much the same purpose; research and training, but is more convenient.
- ekianjo 13y agoIt's way easier to build a space station than a Moon Colony. The technical achievement is very different in magnitude.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- mirkules 13y agoFun fact: the ISS would be technically impossible to build on Earth because it would collapse due to its own weight. No gravity makes creating structures much easier both to move and to support.
- beambot 13y agoSmart glass exists (Transitions lenses), as do radioactive batteries (using beta-decay by a company called BetaBatt, and RTGs used by NASA). The former is a commercial success; I've owned and loved the lenses for years. I don't know if the latter is used outside certain sensing, defense, and aerospace applications.
- mirkules 13y agoIt should be noted, however, that he correctly predicts that batteries should be disposed of only by authorized centers undoubtedly due to their hypothetical radioactive nature -- which is clearly wrong -- but I think we can give a quarter of a point there for even thinking about the ramifications of disposable batteries.
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoDisposal isn't much of a concern in deep space or on mars (yet).
- mirkules 13y agoThat's true, and I remember there was some talk in the astronomy community about disposing of nuclear waste in deep space or shooting it at the sun. Although, if we can recycle some or all aspects of batteries (the non-radioactive parts, heh) that would also help with conservation of raw materials.
- jloughry 13y ago'Dropping nuclear waste into the sun' is more expensive than most people think. It's a matter of delta-v. From here you can't just drop something down the Sun's gravity well and expect it to fall in. In terms of energy cost it's more like lifting it all the way up there, more or less.
- hdivider 13y agoDigital teaching aids: yes, definitely. I'd say we're doing pretty well on that front. There's DragonBox, which teaches basic algebra [0]. There's 3D software (Blender etc. or just 3D stuff in a web browser), which, because of its interactivity, makes it much easier to understand complicated 3D shapes (and can help with visualisation when doing group-theoretic calculations). And then there's all the stuff that we take for granted, e.g. highly optimised search algorithms for teaching material and papers, instant unit conversions and even fairly complicated calculations using Google and Wolfram Alpha, and so on. Also, Wikipedia. "Part of the General Electric exhibit today consists of a school of the future in which such present realities as closed-circuit TV and programmed tapes aid the teaching process.." Compared to some of the items above, it looks like technology has gone well into and even a little beyond merely 'aiding' the teaching process. [0]: http://www.dragonboxapp.com http://www.dragonboxapp.com (Very good summary BTW - thanks.) =]
- samstave 13y agoDon't many (most?) satellites use radioactive batteries?
- k__ 13y ago> And experimental fusion-power plant or two will already > exist in 2014 They do.
- jaaron 13y agoThere are arguably a fair number of moving sidewalks in Hong Kong: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Central%E2%80%93Mid-Levels_escalators http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Central%E2%80%93Mid-Levels_esca...
- arethuza 13y agoIt looks like we are ~20 years from an actual experimental fusion power plant (DEMO) although the ITER reactor currently being built in France (with the EU being the largest funder) should produce 500MW of thermal energy for nearly 500 seconds. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ITER http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ITER http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DEMO http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DEMO
- DennisP 13y agoITER's not the only game in town: http://www.climatecolab.org/web/guest/plans/-/plans/contestId/10/planId/1304006 http://www.climatecolab.org/web/guest/plans/-/plans/contestI...
- bnegreve 13y ago> ✗ Fusion power plants I disagree! Azimov didn't say that we will be using fusion power, he said that an "experimental fusion-power plant or two will already exist". Which is pretty much what ITER[1] is. So to me, this is one of the most accurate predictions. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ITER http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ITER
- maxerickson 13y agoIt isn't really a power plant until they turn it on. And so far, the difference between a fusion reactor and a fusion power plant has been a significant one.
- solistice 13y agox EL panels No, but they're to expensive for usage on every wall. Personally, I think they'll be pushed towards fringe applications by a technology Asmimov didn't predict. High efficiency LEDs. x Smart glass Yes, but again a cost question. There's this [http://money.cnn.com/video/technology/2012/01/10/t-ts-samsung-clear-tv.fortune/ http://money.cnn.com/video/technology/2012/01/10/t-ts-samsun...], by Samsung. I don't see why you couldn't replace your windows with such screens if you had the spare dough. Also, there's privacy glass, which is cheaper, but still sets you back 500USD/m². x Fusion power plants. Those might be a couple of years off. x Radioactive batteries. Exist, but not in the scale and power density Asimov predicts. There are nuclear batteries for pacemakers [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betacel http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betacel]. x Moving sidewalks Yep, only at chokepoints and long stretches of unidirectional people movement indoors. x Moon colonies. They're on the other side, hiding. Trust me on this one. A lot of these points are arguable. I'm easily excitable, so I consider technological feasibility/existence as a check, but your view on it may be more somber (It has to be exactly as he predicted). I'm just amazed he got that much of it right. On a side note, why couldn't the non-asimov prediction with blimp filled skies come true? They're like sky whales...and I really should get some sleep.
- officemonkey 13y agoThere are several lighter than air gasses. Helium is rare, Neon is rarer, and Hydrogen is explosive and has really bad press. Methane is explosive as well. Ammonia, Hydrogen flouride, and Diborane are either reactive or toxic. Helium, Hydrogen and hot air are the most popular options, but none of them are as safe or cheap as plain old planes.
- solistice 13y agoI know that technically blimps make little sense except in fringe applications. But they're majestic, and I like that.
- takluyver 13y agoThe article distinguishes between what would be technically possible in 2014 and what would be in everyday use, so I think Asimov is being judged against roughly those criteria. Moving sidewalks: I don't think the airport walkways count. Conveyor belts and escalators were both around long before 1964. The prediction is about where they'd be used.
- dghughes 13y agoLawrence-Livermore NIF set a record recently https://www.llnl.gov/news/newsreleases/2013/Aug/NR-13-08-04.html?utm_source=buffer&utm_campaign=Buffer&utm_content=buffer889f9&utm_medium=twitter#.Uh3nIorMbFr https://www.llnl.gov/news/newsreleases/2013/Aug/NR-13-08-04....
- tankbot 13y agoDo these inventions just have to be complete or in widespread use? Smart glass is done and has been for a long time. See Transitions Lenses or Speedglas welding masks. I realize it's cost-prohibitive to scale, but there's also SAGE windows, which use liquid crystal to block light. I'm not sure what qualifies as an EL panel, but LED panels have gotten crazy bright and cheap and are being used more and more. I count the conveyors in airports as 'moving sidewalks'. :) I agree Moon colonization was a fail, but to be fair we could colonize the moon, but why would we want to?
- squozzer 13y agoCorrection -- radioactive batteries -- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioisotope_thermoelectric_generator http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioisotope_thermoelectric_gen...
- squozzer 13y agoOops. Nevermind.