6 ms·
US ranked 46th in world Health Care efficiency
- grandalf 13y agoThis is about as meaningful as ranking the US healthcare system in terms of the average height of doctors.
- grecy 13y agoOne of the major topics that comes up when discussing taxpayer funded universal healthcare is the fear of "Government inefficiency", which (we're lead to believe) will eventually result in increased Health Care costs. These numbers and rankings show the United States spends drastically more than countries with universal healthcare, showing that the profit for the private healthcare industry is larger than any "Government inefficiencies". The rankings show if the United States adopted a taxpayer funded Universal Healthcare model similar to those of Developed countries, the end-of-the-day costs for healthcare would go down, and everyone would actually have more money, not less.
- protomyth 13y agoNo, the rankings really don't show that. What they show is a rating based on "life expectancy (weighted 60%), relative per capita cost of health care (30%); and absolute per capita cost of health care (10%). Countries were scored on each criterion and the scores were weighted and summed to obtain their efficiency scores. Relative cost is health cost per capita as a percentage of GDP per capita. Absolute cost is total health expenditure, which covers preventive and curative health services, family planning, nutrition activities and emergency aid." I should also point out life expectancy is a "crock" because some of these countries do no include live births that are under a certain number of weeks. Look at the comparison of Germany vs. France vs. US.
- rdtsc 13y ago> This is about as meaningful as ranking the US healthcare system in terms of the average height of doctors. Can you share some details why? I don't think it is that obvious what you mean. I see "life expectancy", "health care costs as a % of GDP/capita" and "health-care cost per capita" and some efficiency index that I can't immediately tell how it was computed. It seems "interesting" on the surface though.
- InclinedPlane 13y agoLife expectancy is not solely determined by medical care though, there are many confounding factors which are, if anything, far more important than medical care. Ranging from genetic to cultural to socio-economic. Edit: Also, health related statics can be tricky things to measure correctly, even though it may seem simple. It can depend on how countries define live births, for example, which varies greatly from country to country. Moreover, it's not necessarily a good proxy for "health". If someone breaks their arm, for example, and is unable to get it set by a doctor then they could live the entire rest of their life with a disabling injury, perhaps with a great deal of pain, even though they may end up living just as long as anyone else. Similarly, someone may spend the last decade of their life in a very pitiable state, suffering from dementia or alzheimer's and being mistreated often though receiving enough care to live a long life while someone in another country may receive a far better level of care in their old age but die earlier because they had better access to unhealthy foods throughout their life. Or, someone may live longer through heroic means of end-of-life care (intubation, forced feedings, resuscitation, artificial respiration, etc.) which extends their nominal life though may not extend the time period of their life where they are actually properly living. Even more importantly, this is just a shitty infographic, there is no sourcing, no description of the methodology and standards of data gathering and analysis. And yet this comes from an alleged news organization. The quality of this "report" is below the standard that would be accepted in elementary school.
- refurb 13y agoI know the US healthcare system has problems, but really? Worse than Cuba or Libya? You're going to get some weird results if you use life expectancy without filtering out the impact of variables that have nothing at all to do with healthcare (i.e. automobile accidents, incidence of premature births, etc).
- joe_the_user 13y agoReally. You don't remember that Michael Moore movie, do you? Well, the US hasn't actually done anything to solve the problems since then. Cuba is a vastly less wealthy country than the US. I notice in the chart it has a higher life expectancy. Poverty usually isn't a way to increase life expectancy. One must presume they're doing something right.
- glenra 13y ago> Poverty usually isn't a way to increase life expectancy. One must presume they're doing something right. Poverty actually can be a way to increase "life expectancy", depending on how it's calculated. If a baby is about to be born horribly ill and/or premature, a poor country is likely to let it die quickly and be counted as stillborn; a rich country will apply heroic measures to keep it alive for long enough that it counts as a childhood death instead. (in the US it does anyway - the US records infant deaths differently than Europe and this also has a big effect on calculated life expectancy) Cuba also can't afford a lot of cars or roads to drive them on, so fewer people die in auto accidents. (If you adjust for fatal accidents, US life expectancy apparently climbs to at or near the top of the chart)
- grecy 13y agoCuba Have you not seen Sicko [1] by Michael Moore? Cuba has a fantastic universal health care system. A friend from Canada lived and worked there for 3 years, he had some amazing things to say about it, and how much the Canadian system could learn from it. Libya A poster on Reddit who lives there mentioned that before all the crap going down now, Libya too had a fantastic Universal Health Care system. The Redditor in question mentioned it's comparable to the stories you hear from Scandinavian countries, Australia, NZ, etc. etc. (i.e. horrible car crash, totally free. Years of Cancer treatment, totally free, etc.) [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sicko http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sicko
- bjr- 13y agoWe're not last!?!
- grandalf 13y agoIt's highly misleading. It might be more useful to see an analysis of the marginal change in outcomes per spend, where spend is measured in terms of the average wage hour in a particular country. The US certainly skews toward reduced efficiency for the purpose of better outcomes for some edge cases. The average fully insured American gets worse healthcare than the president, precisely because the risk/reward calculus of preventative care, emergency care, diagnostics, etc., is viewed to be different for the president compared to the average citizen. Put differently, ensuring the president's good health is done at the cost of a bit of efficiency. So efficiency is related to class, with the highest class people being able to "afford" lower healthcare efficiency as a kind of luxury. Correspondingly, in countries with much lower per capita income, it's possible to deliver healthcare that is remarkably good (say, roughly equal to early 1990s US standards) for a fraction of the price of modern care. Diseases of affluence get lots of health care spending, and many (like heart disease) offer low yield for each additional dollar. There are a few areas (some cancers) in which you'd very much prefer to be treated with 2013 medicine rather than 1992 medicine. To opine on this issue entails a significant value judgement about the relative importance of various diseases... effectively picking winners and losers, with every dollar saved in the name of efficiency offering a benefit to one person and causing harm to another...
- grecy 13y ago> say, roughly equal to early 1990s US standards If you think any Developed country in the world has healthcare equal to early 1990s US standards, you're very confused. If you're talking about Developing or undeveloped countries, why would you want to compare the richest country in the world to developing or undeveloped countries? I would have expected you to aim higher than the bottom of the heap.
- grandalf 13y agoI'm talking about developing countries... which I think should be praised for figuring out how to maximize efficiency and value to serve very poor populations at low cost. I was around in the 1990s (in the US) and at the time I thought the healthcare system did a pretty good job. A decade or two later and for most diseases, little has changed about the treatments/practices. So for 95% of healthcare issues, 1990s medicine is just as good as 2013 medicine. The fallacy upon which much of the cost bloat is built is the idea that all costs should be increasing b/c quality is increasing in some key areas (like cancer treatment). Ironically, the areas in the US that offer the biggest area for improvement are things like basic systems and process improvements... things like being sure someone helps the 70 year old patient walk the hall twice a day to retain mobility during a hospital stay (even if the reason for the hospital stay is something like a bad cold, a fall, or dehydration from vomiting). Most of the things that can offer significant outcome improvements are very low tech.
- igravious 13y agoOff-topic (but oh-my-god) from same site. http://www.bloomberg.com/visual-data/best-and-worst/most-cash-in-the-world-companies http://www.bloomberg.com/visual-data/best-and-worst/most-cas... 1: Industrial and Commercial Bank of China $518.5B
- flaktrak 13y agoI am surprised the US is even that high!