3 ms·
In any risk assessment, you have to balance impact with likelihood. Yes, it could have happened, but the likelihood is so rare that it's not worth the premium.
by moron4hire 13y ago
In any risk assessment, you have to balance impact with likelihood. Yes, it could have happened, but the likelihood is so rare that it's not worth the premium.
Once again, that's the entire point of the insurance company. They balance impact and likelihood.
Even if I had the insurance to cover me, you're still going to get slightly higher insurance premiums. You're actually more likely to receive a higher delta because I was covered than I wasn't, as the hospital will recoup its losses across all insurance providers, while the insurance company will recoup across only their own constituents.
The health insurance system is an oligopoly that allows insurance companies and health care providers to collude to set artificially high prices. Drug companies, hospitals, surgeons, medical schools--they all get their payday and the insurance company gets to make a "small" percentage margin on top of it. Which just so conveniently means that they're some of the most profitable companies in the world. Just look at the bottom dollar. If they weren't making out like bandits, they wouldn't be making out like bandits.
It's specifically because of ubiquitous health insurance that health services prices are so high. If more people covered themselves, the price of services wouldn't be high, insurance payouts wouldn't be so high, and thus insurance premiums wouldn't be so high. I'm actually doing you a favor by sticking to my principles.
EDIT: and regardless of all of that, nobody has the right to mandate what others do with their lives. I could have chosen to be a burger flipper for the rest of my life and your argument would of social impact would still hold, even be worse because society would be out my higher tax revenue.
- mikeash 13y agoYes, I'd be paying for your care either way. The difference is, the way you're doing it now, you contribute nothing while I still pay for your care. If I get a million-dollar hospital bill, you don't pay more, but the reverse is true. If insurance weren't ubiquitous, service would be cheaper, sure. And people would die or be bankrupted by treatable medical conditions like crazy. This is why insurance is so common. People don't like that kind of thing. Given the system that we're in, you're doing me no favors at all by refraining from obtaining health insurance as a healthy person. You've decided that the risk of bankruptcy is acceptable while externalizing a lot of that risk.
- moron4hire 13y agoYour notions of my responsibilities for how and when to protect your financial security are of no concern to me. I will make my own contributions to society as I see fit.
- sfall 13y agoThe problem is that when you don't have insurance your inaction can drive up costs for everyone else (higher prices at the hospital).
- tadfisher 13y ago> I will make my own contributions to society as I see fit. Which is why you will now pay a tax penalty if you don't pay for health insurance coverage. What contributions you make to society is part of a contract, not a unilateral choice.
- mikeash 13y agoThat's fine, a highly common and very human attitude. Just don't pretend like you're being somehow noble, or that the rest of us are somehow screwing you over when we try to make you stop pushing risks onto us without contributing.
- moron4hire 13y agoIf I had never gone to college and decided to just work as a burger flipper the rest of my life and spend all my money on cigarettes and sky-diving (see, I can make up low-likelihood hypotheticals, too), then I'd be contributing even less. Are we going to start mandating that people actualize their full economic potential, as well?
- mikeash 13y agoNo, I'm good with incentivizing that the old-fashioned way, by giving people who fail to do that crappier stuff than those who succeed.
- 13y ago
- hearty778 13y agoYou're wrong. http://www.google.com/finance?q=NYSE%3AUNH&fstype=ii&ei=8Z0bUvj7HcSRiAL8cw http://www.google.com/finance?q=NYSE%3AUNH&fstype=ii&ei=8Z0b...
- moron4hire 13y agoI'm not really sure what you're getting at, as this is just one company. Companies are also pretty good at cooking their books, too, and I haven't seen too much in the last 5 years to make me trust that the SEC is doing their job.
- hearty778 13y agoI like how you downvoted me for factual information. Please look up their competitors, as well as their tinier ones. The margins in the sector are similar across the board. The financial statements are audited by third party accountants. Studies from healthcare researchers use those margins. I didn't know I was responding to a conspiracy theorist, which I hope you're not.
- moron4hire 13y agoI didn't downvote you.
- 3825 13y agoI am not trying to support your parent comment. However, the current trend in healthcare cost is unsustainable. My roommate (stupidly, in hindsight) went to get an ER after being scratched by a small cat in our parking lot. The total bill was over $8k for about an hour of care and two shots. This is unacceptable. There must be some sort of accountability in the system. Unless, there is a secret pact between the hospital and the insurance company to show a larger bill to make the patient think he is getting his money's worth in which case I have nothing to say. If we can't control the price, can I write a will saying my estate will actively refuse care for anything that costs more than 5k out of pocket per day and 15k annually? In the event I do need care that costs beyond that point, please give me a quick and (hopefully) painless death instead.
- enraged_camel 13y ago>>In any risk assessment, you have to balance impact with likelihood. Yes, it could have happened, but the likelihood is so rare that it's not worth the premium. What makes healthcare dramatically different is that, as a layperson, you cannot accurately assess the likelihood variable. You may have some very rough ideas - for example, a professional snowboarder is more likely to get a sports-related injury - but stuff that tends to be extremely expensive is also stuff that can happen to anyone at any time. This differs from, say, car insurance, where a lot of the factors such as the value of your car, the frequency of driving, your driving habits, etc. are known. As such, you can optimize it much more effectively.