5 ms·
I actually really rather prefer buying my own insurance, and by that I mean I buy only the minimum required by law. Insurance companies design their policies to
by moron4hire 13y ago
I actually really rather prefer buying my own insurance, and by that I mean I buy only the minimum required by law. Insurance companies design their policies to get more out of you then you get out of them, and they've gotten very good at figuring out ways to deny benefits to people.
Just give me the money in my paycheck and let me do with it as I see fit. The money I would spend on insurance I put into a personal savings account. I insure myself.
I spent $1200 total on health care costs in the last 3 years. Now that Obamacare requires I buy insurance or else get hit with a penalty, I'm going to be spending a lot more than that every year.
Why should it be cheaper to have group policies through employers? The entire freaking point of the insurance company is that they are pooling money from a bunch of people over time in the form of premiums to be able to distribute to a minority who need it in emergencies. It's already a paramutual arrangement, why do we have to obfuscate it with employer group policies?
Insurance, at least as it is done in the US, is a scam. It is an oligarchy designed to keep medical services prices high so they can justify outlandish premiums as merely just a small percentage margin.
- Retric 13y agoIt's cheaper because of information disparity. Basicly, individual learns he has condition X tells no one and buys insurance and suddenly the inshurance company is out 200,000+$ or worse (AIDS can easily run 1,000,000+$). However if a company is buying insurance then presumably the insurance company knows more about the risks than the HR person setting up insurance.
- Guvante 13y agoActually the major thing with group insurance is the number of people. It is unlikely that more than 1 or 2 people in a small company will have any major health issues, so if you are signing up 20 people your overall risk is lower (in your example a $10,000 per person cost). Combined with different feelings toward risk, usually health insurance is a win win. The annoying thing about the recent "reforms" is it mandates preventative care be covered, eliminating the ability to get pure "oh crap" coverage.
- TomatoTomato 13y agoNumber of people is actually not as big a factor as it is made out to be. For major medical and certain supplemental health like dental, there is a load for small groups, but it isn't very much. The risk is certainly higher, but one large claim can make a group's loss ratio beyond what can be recovered, so the additional premium has to be spread across the small group category. The biggest factor which is often overlooked is that the insured is "actively at work" which lowers the potential risk, because working people are healthier and the insurance company can add underwriting factors for certain industries. Another thing to note is even if you are allowed to select a voluntary product like dental or health indemnity product, there is little or no choice on the specific riders or benefit amounts which lowers the "anti-selection" for riders. Products that are partially employer-paid like major med and/or a group's participation percentage being high also limits the potential anti-selection. Disclaimer: work in Actuarial
- aestra 13y agoThat makes sense to an extent. It goes out the door with family plans (to me). Is a spouse more likely to be healthier because their partner works? Child because parent?
- acdha 13y ago> The annoying thing about the recent "reforms" is it mandates preventative care be covered, eliminating the ability to get pure "oh crap" coverage. This is only annoying until you realize how many people have incurred significant costs by avoiding preventative care. Why do you think insurance companies are so quick to run campaigns for healthy-living, vaccination, regular physicals, etc.? They'd much prefer to pay a few hundred dollars a year for you on a known schedule than deal with open-ended late-stage problems.
- moron4hire 13y agoThat changes nothing. The aggregate probability should be the same. Even if we assume that the insurance company will modify premiums based on the type of work the company does, they'd do that to the individual as well, as they ask your occupation. The chance that the insurance company could get scammed by a covered person lying to indirectly through their employer is is the same as the insurance company getting scammed by a covered person lying directly to the insurance company. Regardless, this is all covered under pre-existing condition clauses and contract law: i.e. they most definitely WON'T be out the $200k from your hypothetical.
- Retric 13y agoThe aggregate probability of a heathy 25 year old deciding to pay full market price for Heath insurance is lower than a sick 25 year old. However, you also get people who discover there at an increased risk for a disease and decide to get coverage etc. PS: Heath insurance company's are vary rational, if the risks where equivalent they would charge close to the same rates due to market forces. Instead identical group plans even for small groups can be significantly cheaper.
- RougeFemme 13y agoActually, the insurance company would probably do some checking and, finding the proof that you were diagnosed before taking out the policy, would invalidate your policy based on your "fraudulently" filling out the application - and pay out nothing.
- mikeash 13y agoThe example still works even if the guy is diagnosed after taking out the policy. Bob takes out a policy because it seems like a good idea, and subsequently is diagnosed with Expensive Heart Disease. He holds onto his policy with dear life, prioritizing the premium payments over things like dinner if he has to. Joe takes out a policy because it, too, seems like a good idea. Nothing happens to him, and six months later he has a change of heart when he thinks about how many shots of tequila he could be buying with the premiums instead, so he cancels his policy. Thus sick people become ever more concentrated in the pool of individual insurance customers.
- mikeash 13y agoYour story of spending $1200 on health care in three years could very well have been one of being completely bankrupted because you suffered a serious but not life-threatening injury. Unless you're a millionaire, you cannot self-insure when it comes to health care. It's not hard at all to rack up a couple of million dollars in hospital bills if you get unlucky, and you'd probably never be able to pay that back. Of course, the hospital would still treat you, and the rest of us end up paying for your care through slightly higher insurance premiums. In short, you're implicitly mooching off society, and apparently proud of it. You managed to get away without actually triggering it, so far, but you were pushing a lot of financial risk onto other people. (Ignore this if you are, in fact, a millionaire.) You wonder why individual plans are so much more expensive than group plans. It's because of people like you! Group plans include every employee, healthy or not, while millions of healthy individuals forego buying individual coverage because they think they don't need it. This gives the individual market a much riskier pool of customers. I agree with the basic idea that the US health insurance market is completely messed up, but you're really doing it wrong, here.
- moron4hire 13y agoIn any risk assessment, you have to balance impact with likelihood. Yes, it could have happened, but the likelihood is so rare that it's not worth the premium. Once again, that's the entire point of the insurance company. They balance impact and likelihood. Even if I had the insurance to cover me, you're still going to get slightly higher insurance premiums. You're actually more likely to receive a higher delta because I was covered than I wasn't, as the hospital will recoup its losses across all insurance providers, while the insurance company will recoup across only their own constituents. The health insurance system is an oligopoly that allows insurance companies and health care providers to collude to set artificially high prices. Drug companies, hospitals, surgeons, medical schools--they all get their payday and the insurance company gets to make a "small" percentage margin on top of it. Which just so conveniently means that they're some of the most profitable companies in the world. Just look at the bottom dollar. If they weren't making out like bandits, they wouldn't be making out like bandits. It's specifically because of ubiquitous health insurance that health services prices are so high. If more people covered themselves, the price of services wouldn't be high, insurance payouts wouldn't be so high, and thus insurance premiums wouldn't be so high. I'm actually doing you a favor by sticking to my principles. EDIT: and regardless of all of that, nobody has the right to mandate what others do with their lives. I could have chosen to be a burger flipper for the rest of my life and your argument would of social impact would still hold, even be worse because society would be out my higher tax revenue.
- RougeFemme 13y agoIn the original post though, the company is paying 100% of the premiums - and would presumably do the same for the disability insurancee. So you would pay nothing out of pocket. You could view it as 2500/x not going into your check - but it's probably 2500/x that would have gone elsewhere.
- mcherm 13y ago> Why should it be cheaper to have group policies through employers? The entire freaking point of the insurance company is that they are pooling money from a bunch of people over time in the form of premiums to be able to distribute to a minority who need it in emergencies. Good question. The answer is that the insurance companies know that people are self-selecting if they buy insurance on their own, while (to a good approximation) they do not select jobs on the basis of the insurance that they will get from it. So insurance offered through an employer comes from a pool of typical people with a certain age and wealth distribution, while insurance sold directly to consumers comes from a pool of people who think that they need that particular kind of insurance. Needless to say, the risk is MUCH higher with the individual policies, and it is priced accordingly.
- davidw 13y agoI'll see your anecdote and raise it one: when I was around 20, and in very, very good shape from lots of cycling, out of nowhere (no crash, no impacts, nothing I can think of), I had a collapsed lung, which I think came to around $20,000 in hospital/surgery bills. Luckily, I was insured at the time: I had not yet started my programming career, and had nothing like that amount of money available.
- ams6110 13y ago$20,000 is a chunk of money, but nothing an ordinary person can't get out from under. Most people spend more than that on a car.
- Swannie 13y agoHello to the person living in a bubble. Most people don't spend more than that on a car. The average price of a used car (what most people buy) is $14,375 [1]. The average savings rate in the USA is below 5% [2]. With a median household income of approx $50k [3], then we assume that approx. $2.5k is the average amount an average USA household can afford each year. With average savings of around $6k [3], that's over 5 1/2 years to "get out from under", not including loss of earning, no savings cushion, and not including interest payments. [1] http://www.forbes.com/sites/jimgorzelany/2013/02/14/used-car-prices-stay-high-heres-where-to-find-the-best-deals/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/jimgorzelany/2013/02/14/used-car... [2] http://money.stackexchange.com/questions/23113/how-many-weeks-of-living-expenses-does-the-average-american-have-savings-for http://money.stackexchange.com/questions/23113/how-many-week... [3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Household_income_in_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Household_income_in_the_United_...
- aestra 13y agoARE YOU SERIOUS!?!?!! Try living somewhere outside of the upper middle class. There is almost nobody I know who can get out of that kind of unexpected debt. "Most people" budget for a car, and don't buy a new one at 20. How about those people who take the bus? http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/06/04/medical-bills-cause-most-bankruptcies/ http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/06/04/medical-bills-cause... Nearly two out of three bankruptcies stem from medical bills, and even people with health insurance face financial disaster if they experience a serious illness, a new study shows. Among families who were bankrupted by illness, those with private insurance reported average medical bills of $17,749 compared to those who were uninsured, who faced an average of $26,971 in medical costs. Those who had health insurance but lost it in the course of their illness reported average medical bills of $22,568.
- moron4hire 13y agoIs it my fault that insurance premiums would increase by my non-participation in the insurance company's ponzi scheme, or is it the scared masses fault that medical services are so high because they relentlessly pursue getting everyone to join in for their own security? Here's the problem with the arguments of "all for one and one for all": Most people are not going to have hundreds of thousands of dollars in medical bills (millions is ridiculous. I have never heard of such a thing, and regardless, the prices are over reported to make the argument that high premiums are necessary). All most people are going to need is yearly checkups, a cost they could easily take on themselves if they pay out of pocket. But instead they put it on their insurance, like it's some kind of free money. Every time someone goes to a general practitioner for a basic rhinovirus and only pays their $10 co-pay, they're making the rest of us (yes, me included, because you generous folk figured out a way to force me to buy minimum insurance) pay for the rest of the over-inflated price of their unnecessary visit. Take a cough suppressant, drink lots of water, and stay home, you'll be better in 3 days. You don't need a doctor to tell you that. I haven't needed a doctor to tell me that since I was a teenager. Stop going to work when you're sick. But the average person is meant to lose out on their premium, otherwise the system wouldn't work. But rather than treating it as the sunk cost that it is, money they're most likely to never get back, the average person goes the doctor for every sniffle and ache.
- ceejayoz 13y ago> Stop going to work when you're sick. That's a pretty privileged statement to make.
- aestra 13y ago>Take a cough suppressant The medical evidence for taking cough suppressants is poor. http://dx.doi.org/10.1002%2F14651858.CD001831.pub3 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002%2F14651858.CD001831.pub3 http://dx.doi.org/10.1136%2Fbmj.324.7333.329 http://dx.doi.org/10.1136%2Fbmj.324.7333.329
- mcculley 13y ago> Just give me the money in my paycheck and let me do with it as I see fit. Unfortunately, the way the system is set up, the money an employer spends on health insurance cannot be used effectively in the health care market. It is not a free market. For my single employees, I pay $406.53 per month for health insurance on a very comprehensive plan. If I were to just put that in their paycheck and tell them to fend for themselves, first they would have to pay income tax on that money and second they would not be able to buy health care services at the rates negotiated by the insurance companies. This doesn't even factor in the situations where an employer and the coworkers have to decide how much to help an employee with his medical bills when something happens.