18 ms·
Are people honestly still proud to be American when things like this come to light? Why would you want to continue to live in a country that seems to make thin
by grecy 13y ago
Are people honestly still proud to be American when things like this come to light?
Why would you want to continue to live in a country that seems to make things like this routine? (honest question, I don't understand)
- jlgreco 13y ago> Why would you want to continue to live in a country that seems to make things like this routine? Honest answer to the honest question: I want to live in this country[1] because I consider it my home. The government? That is the part I don't care for. I feel absolutely no loyalty to it. When another victor inevitably starts writing history books, those books will not be kind to the modern American government. [1] Where "country" is both a chunk of geography, a loose-knit culture (perhaps best described as a culture of loose-knit cultures), and the place where most of the individual people I like also live.
- ekianjo 13y ago> I feel absolutely no loyalty to it. Yet you are enforced to be loyal to it. Try not paying your taxes, for example, and they will deprive you of your freedom.
- jlgreco 13y agoI am loyal to it like somebody is loyal to a mugger. If I don't give them money, people with guns will take it. I would say this is better described as "obedience" than "loyalty". Should I move to another country and pay a different government my tax money instead? Arguably. It is not clear to me which government I should instead be forced to pay, and my options are very limited as I am ill-equipped to live in most other countries. Five Eyes rules out the most obvious answers.
- ekianjo 13y ago> Should I move to another country and pay a different government my tax money instead? Arguably. I'd say any government which does not have a standing army killing innocent people overseas is a better choice. At least your taxes would then not be used to produce bombs and guns. I agree with you that no country is perfect and you can find flaws in every of them, but still. There are some levels of differences.
- anologwintermut 13y agoTaxes pay for roads, schools, police, sewers, water, courts, etc. They are things you consume by living in this country and thing that most people would like to have around. They also pay for the military, the CIA, and evidently things like supporting the gassing of Iran. But they are not enforced loyalty. Moreover, you can get out of paying US taxes. You just have to leave the country, renounce your citizenship, and pay an exit tax (after all, it would be rather absurd to allow someone to profit off the US legal system and business environment and then leave before paying the bill)
- ekianjo 13y ago> But they are not enforced loyalty. I think you are playing with words. The government expects you to pay your taxes. It is counting on your money. On your loyalty to feed them constantly, until you die (and even after, actually). Since people don't wait until guys with guns and uniforms come to their door to pay their taxes, I would say everyone is pretty loyal to the State and do not wait for threats to comply. If that's not loyalty, then I don't know how you call it. And many citizens do think taxes (no matter the amount) are a GOOD thing, and will defend the Right of the State to steal your money in a significant manner. Isn't that loyalty ?
- dfc 13y agoAll countries enforce loyalty. If I moved to Canada I would be forced to be loyal to the Canadian government. To make matters worse I would also have to swear or affirm an oath of loyalty to some lady and her heirs and successors across the ocean. Are there any countries that do not take punitive actions when citizens decide they do not feel like paying their taxes?
- ekianjo 13y ago> Are there any countries that do not take punitive actions when citizens decide they do not feel like paying their taxes? Probably not, or very few at least, since there is no pure libertarian country example in the world so far. Even though, you may decide where you pay your taxes - depending on how much you agree with the policies of the country where you pay them. You can't keep feeding the Dragon and then complain the day it burns another village with its inhabitants. Don't feed the Dragon in the first place.
- dfc 13y agoYou can be a "pure libertarian" and recognize market failures for things like national defense or the need for a system of codification and protection of property rights.
- ekianjo 13y ago> market failures for things like national defense Care to elaborate?
- dfc 13y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Market_failure https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Market_failure
- lukifer 13y agoMarkets are a technology; like all technologies, it's important to use the right tool for the job, and to be aware of the surrounding contexts that influence its uses in the real world.
- rdl 13y agoI think history will probably say the US became potentially powerful due to geography (resources and relative safety in the 1800s), as well as technological innovation and relative stability and freedom for a couple hundred years. But then, that WW2 and the Cold War led to becoming an empire, and that once the empire lost a (fairly real, if pointless) external enemy, it started casting about for enemies, and found two: external "terrorists" and any kind of uncertainty or decentralization (i.e. domestic freedom). I'd prefer an American empire to a global caliphate, but that's not really the a likely decision. What is likely is a hegemonic US empire vs. some kind of decentralized system with autonomy and freedom at different levels (individuals retaining a lot, local governments and companies having some, provinces some, nation-states other, regions other, and global some). That would be a pretty clear choice, and I don't think you can say opposing a US empire is opposing the US overall.
- hydralist 13y ago</freedom>?
- mikegagnon 13y ago> Are people honestly still proud to be American when things like this come to light? Humans have an amazing capacity to hold contradictory views. > Why would you want to continue to live in a country that seems to make things like this routine? (honest question, I don't understand) If you disown your government, you relinquish any hope of fixing it through democracy.
- short_circut 13y agoI frequently ask myself that same question. I wish I had an answer for you. I could attempt to answer it but the NSA would probably put me on a no fly list or something as a limited form of extrajudicial punishment. Or maybe I am paranoid. But then again given all the things I have learned about what the US has done how can I not be?
- keerthiko 13y agoEverytime I'm reminded a country like this just spurned me an honestly-applied-for work visa, it brings the taste of sour grapes back up my throat, now that I'm leaving in a few months. It's unfortunate that as others mentioned, many of the individual people I like call this country home. I hope someday to be able to convince them to up their roots and come hang out with me in Canada or Sweden or some cooler place.
- crazygringo 13y agoYou can feel proud to be part of the American people, the American nation, and proud of certain long-standing American values. At you can, at the same time, be completely critical of certain aspects of US domestic and foreign policy -- and even certain aspects of US culture.
- dfc 13y agoI find this to be a strange sentiment and it certainly makes for strange bed fellows. The "love it or leave it" line was also a common refrain from the John Birch crowd and other reactionary groups during the 60s. I think the US is a better place because of people like Mary Harris Jones and Joe Hill or Dr. King and Rep. Lewis. If they (and countless others) had adopted your philosophy things would be much worse for people living in the US who lacked the financial mobility to emigrate to another country.[1] If you think the US is on the wrong path now imagine how much worse the situation would be if the only people left were individuals who supported all of the policies and programs you find so heinous. Can you imagine how much worse life would be for some people in South Africa if Nelson Mandela said "screw it, I am out of here"? [1] I did not want to belabor the point anymore but suffice it to say I think there is a serious "class/privilege problem" with this philosophy.
- rooshdi 13y agoNever got it either. Always reeked of a power trip.
- PavlovsCat 13y ago"Nationalism is power-hunger tempered by self-deception." -- George Owell ( http://www.netcharles.com/orwell/essays/notes-on-nationalism.htm http://www.netcharles.com/orwell/essays/notes-on-nationalism... )
- adventured 13y agoFirst, I would ask what your home country is, so that we can dig into its history. Second, if you had extrapolated out your premise, you'd quickly come to the conclusion that almost nobody could continue to live in their countries. See: Germany, Britain, Italy, Russia, France, Spain, Japan, China, and on it goes. There isn't a single major country on earth without a sordid history. Whether we're talking various European states that massively supported the slave trade or used military expeditions to conquer territory, or the Communist era in Russia or the Fascism era under Putin, or the tens of millions Mao murdered through famine and gulags, well, you get the point. Third, America has 300 million people. What do you think they're all going to do exactly, immigrate to Canada? If they did that, Canada would become America. It's about the culture of the people: the American people elected this mess, and continue to allow it to happen / support it. Overall your questions don't really make any sense. Your intent seems to be nothing more than to drive guilt and passive aggressively bash the US. What's the point of that on HN?
- whiddershins 13y agoWhat country is so great that they can say their government never engages is things like this, even though they have the capacity to?
- saraid216 13y ago> Why would you want to continue to live in a country that seems to make things like this routine? Because I know it best. If I'm going to contribute to fixing a system, it's going to be this one.