7 ms·
SteveB’s Retirement Announcement
- petilon 13y agoIn assessments of Steve Ballmer's tenure (including Ballmer's own assessment as reported on ZDNet) Vista is mentioned as a prominent failure. No one seems to want to mention the bigger failure: Windows 8, whose adoption is below Vista.
- muzz 13y agoTrue, but the market landscape recently was very different those two times. When Vista launched, the personal computing market was basically Microsoft's to lose. Mac OS existed but iOS and Android didn't. Now with those two powering tablets, the personal computing (PC+tablet+phone) is much more competitive: http://www.asymco.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/01/Screen-Shot-2012-01-15-at-1-15-8.45.58-PM.png http://www.asymco.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/01/Screen-Shot...
- buster 13y agoWasn't Vista supposed to be that awesome new-technology operating system with WinFS and whatnot? I think the big failure was that it came out as a Windows XP with a new (worse?) interface and too many problems. Windows 8 is just a continuation of that road, still no new technology under the hood and an even worse interface for desktops (imo).
- johnchristopher 13y agoIt was being hailed as the best software ever to land on our computers by some vocal microsofties on some forums at that time. When it became clear that half the things promised (dbr filesystem, etc.) weren't delivered or were sub-par to promises Vista was then hailed as "foundation for the future... when you build a house you first dig foundations then put walls and a roof". Except when I buy a house, I want a house and not some hole in the ground. IIRC there were four pillars: WinFS, Aero, Avalon and sthg else (audio or DX stack) ?
- jaredsohn 13y agoYou're thinking of Indigo. "(It included) several main pillars: Avalon (Presentation), Aero (User experience), WinFS (Storage), Indigo (Communications and collaboration), and Palladium (Privacy and security). Of these, one pillar (WinFS) would be dropped completely while another (Palladium) would be so stripped down that it's no longer considered a pillar at all." http://winsupersite.com/product-review/road-gold-long-road-windows-vista-part-2-2003 http://winsupersite.com/product-review/road-gold-long-road-w...
- yulaow 13y agoAlso I think at that time the pc-market was not in a situation of crisis as in the recent years. The problem, now, is not only that w8 bring a different ui and so a lot of people are just a bit frightened by it, it is also that the sells of general purpose pcs are worldwide down.
- mbell 13y agoBalmers actual quote was a bit more nuanced than what the media reported, the actual quote is: > I would say probably the thing I regret most is the, what shall I call it, the loopedy-loo that we did that was sort of Longhorn to Vista. Which I interpret to be in reference to issues with Longhorn development rather than issues with the final product (Vista). e.g. the failure of WinFS which Gates also mentioned in a Reddit AmA awhile back as something he wished had made it to market.
- huhtenberg 13y agoLuckily for Microsoft, Windows 8 failure really comes down to the lack of the Start button on a desktop screen. If it were there, everyone would've just skipped the fancy tiled screen, went straight to the desktop and got an improved W7 experience. Windows 8.1 puts the button back, so the adoption rates should climb back up and rather quickly.
- mythz 13y agoThe Start Button isn't back, it's the same lose-context-and-switch-to-Metro B.S. that was in the first version. So instead of activating the hot corner, there's now a prominent button where the Start button was, but it still takes you to a disjointed (touch-friendly) desktop that many wish could be disabled entirely.
- michaelt 13y agoTo be fair, Windows isn't the only desktop environment to throw away old interface designs and adopt new ones that many wish could be disabled. Not saying it's a good (or bad) think in either case (as I don't know) but it's certainly not a unique-to-microsoft thing.
- snowwrestler 13y agoIt's not just that Vista was poorly adopted. It's that Vista took WAY longer than expected to write and release, and then it was terribly flawed anyway. It's still very early in W8's life cycle to call the game. XP was not very popular until SP2.
- CaptainZapp 13y agoUhh, Poor Steve having to save the company because it was at the brink of extinction due to the evil government action of the US and the EU is about as revisionist as it comes. Look, that company violated antitrust laws left and right and Steve Balmer was instrumental in this sordid affair. I'm neither a Microsoft hater (I actually think their OS offerings since XP are pretty solid) but that's just so much revisionist bullshit I couldn't even finish the article. Microsoft was not punished for being big and successful. They where punished (and rightfully so) for repeatedly and purposefully violating the law in a multitude of jusrisdictions.
- yulaow 13y ago"funny" fact: they also did not respect the punishment EU gave them, so they were punished again over it. Microsoft has serious problems with let the competitors a chance to compete. edit to add data: http://www.theverge.com/2013/3/6/4069126/eu-fines-microsoft-for-windows-7-sp1-browser-ballot http://www.theverge.com/2013/3/6/4069126/eu-fines-microsoft-...
- revelation 13y agothe general caution about antitrust that then pervaded the Microsoft culture Thats certainly wrong. They at some point just stopped shipping the browser choice utility they had been forced by the EU to ship, and it took a year for anyone to notice: The Windows 7 SP1 retail release was initially missing BrowserChoice.eu functionality, affecting 28 million computers. The error remained unpatched for 14 months, and as a result in March 2013 the European Commission fined Microsoft €561 million.
- Argorak 13y agoIt didn't take a year for anyone to notice, it took a year until the investigation was finished and another fine was announced. Concerning that Microsoft is a test-obsessed company, failing to test properly for an error that could cost you multiple millions is also a huge blunder. This was failing to live up to a legal oblication, not a mere bug.
- elorant 13y agoWhat this article misses is that despite the successes and failures of SteveB, to the outside world Microsoft is largely considered as a company without a vision. I don’t know if they ever had one, but all those talks all these years about tablets and handheld devices and those beautifully crafted videos about how computing will be 20 years from now, all that don’t materialize into products. Take for example Surface (the table not the tablet). They go and produce a sci-fi table with a touch surface which looks amazing but costs an outrageous $10.000 and has no freaking applications. And that coming from a software company which has spend the better part of the last 30 years building APIs. Where’s the vision in that? I use .NET daily as a platform for building web apps. I love it. I consider it a pretty solid platform and the IDE is like the golden standard in the industry. But in the long term I don’t think that they have a clue as to where they’d like to take things. Right now MS seems like the company that waits others to innovate and then follow on their steps. They spend $7B yearly on R&D and you get to wonder what’s the end result.
- soofaloofa 13y agoResearch can (and arguably should) exist outside of a corporate vision.
- michaelcampbell 13y ago> I consider it a pretty solid platform and the IDE is like the golden standard in the industry. well... in the .NET echo chamber ecosystem, sure. I haven't done serious .NET stuff in a decade, but it was 6-7 years behind the (free) java/jvm IDE's then. I understand it has gotten much, much better but people I know that are current with it and actually use other ecosystems too generally prefer the choices and prices of those over VS. (eclipse, intellij, sublime text, textmate, webstorm, and so forth)
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- anuragramdasan 13y ago>> Had it succeeded he probably would have gotten the kind of credit regularly attributed to that other company head named Steve. Some times some statements within an article show such negative attitude that it becomes difficult to take the rest of the article seriously. I don't know why the author has such resentment towards 'that other company head named Steve' and why he feels to need to mention it at all. Also in one paragraph it is mentioned that Steve is a hero. The paragraph immediately following that states that he couldn't get things put together at the same time or execute his plans. How does a CEO become a hero when he is not able to deliver the most important things expected of him? A very confusing article this one.
- protomyth 13y agoI thought the interesting line from the article was: "For employees and ex-employees, our biggest beef with Steve will probably turn out to be that he made a great, if sometimes brutal, place to work a lot less great. And that, particularly in the second half of his CEO tenure, it became a lot more brutal yet cruelly random in how it measured and rewarded employee contributions." It is one of those situations that gets repeated at companies of every size. It was a fun place to work then someone did something and the fun stopped. The weird part is when it happens at places that are profitable. It being "cruelly random" isn't really that uncommon either.
- twoodfin 13y agoAs much as I agree with the criticism of Microsoft's implementation of stack ranking, if the stock had kept growing like it did in the '90's I think you would have seen a lot more happy employees. Nobody cares too much about the review system when the options you got three years ago are making you a millionaire.
- nostromo 13y agoPeople put so much weight on leadership. Microsoft when Balmer took over had one direction to go: down. It's reversion to the mean. Eventually a company is going to roll 7 on the craps table. Unless Cook is extremely lucky and skilled, in 5 or 10 years people will say the same thing about Apple. Days of stagnation and decline will also visit Google and Facebook eventually. I understand our fixation on leadership. It is super important. But as a thought experiment, I wonder if Steve Jobs was running Microsoft 2000-2010 instead of Steve Balmer, would Microsoft be in great condition today? Or were there already internal and external forces at play at that point that were trouble for Microsoft? I guess the ultimate lesson is one you can learn from Bill Gates: quit while you're ahead.
- michaelwww 13y ago> Microsoft when Balmer took over had one direction to go: down Not at all. As mentioned here in the Vanity Fair [1] article, the iPhone could have been a Micosoft product and now brings in more revenue than the entirety of Microsoft. Ballmer said "There's no chance that the iPhone is going to get any significant market share. No chance." If you cut through everything else said, I think this is pretty damning. [1] http://www.vanityfair.com/business/2012/08/microsoft-lost-mojo-steve-ballmer http://www.vanityfair.com/business/2012/08/microsoft-lost-mo...
- hudell 13y agoWell, if apple hadn't been forced to release iOS sdk, it probably wouldn't get any significant market share as he predicted.
- CamperBob2 13y agoThe iOS SDK was always going to be released, but only for the (then-unannounced) iPad. That's how they were able to change their tune so quickly when users demanded more than web apps.
- michaelwww 13y agoHow was it forced? Steve Jobs: Let me just say it: We want native third party applications on the iPhone, and we plan to have an SDK in developers’ hands in February. We are excited about creating a vibrant third party developer community around the iPhone and enabling hundreds of new applications for our users. [1] Oct 18, 2007 [1] https://discussions.apple.com/thread/1183763?start=0&tstart=0 https://discussions.apple.com/thread/1183763?start=0&tstart=...
- bhauer 13y agoOften the people who decry the era of desktop PCs over also still believe it righteous for the US and EU governments to levy fines and targeted regulations on Microsoft. Which is it: are desktop PCs relevant and therefore worthy of strong-handed regulation or are they irrelevant? Surely if they are irrelevant, we can call off the government attack dogs and allow Microsoft to bundle a browser and media player with their desktop operating system already, yes? So thank you, OP, for bringing attention to the regulatory position Microsoft is in versus its competition. I've ranted elsewhere [1] about the market-holistic detriment I believe the anti-trust judgments caused. At the time, I had been of mixed feelings, being an avid Netscape fan. Since then, I've come to regard the anti-trust cases as a tragedy. Ultimately, I think it was not just Microsoft who suffered but also the consumer. I presently find the world of mobile computing far from the ideal that I want, and I feel it arrived in this form thanks in large part to an unnaturally narrow competitive landscape (the irony!) When I retrace the steps of the past 15 years, I see there were fits of movement in a direction of unified computing, but those were lost. Only recently with the NSA leaks and a gradual pendulum swing back to self-control are we seeing some blips of unified computing. Yet now Microsoft concedes that tablets and mobile phones should be first-class computing devices (argh!) and simply follows the proven money-making model of the other titans. I still hold out some hope that they will come around to a unified computing model, among other things [2]. [1] http://tiamat.tsotech.com/microsoft-awakens http://tiamat.tsotech.com/microsoft-awakens and [2] http://tiamat.tsotech.com/microsoft http://tiamat.tsotech.com/microsoft
- rbanffy 13y ago> Which is it: are desktop PCs relevant and therefore worthy of strong-handed regulation or are they irrelevant? The question is irrelevant. While PCs are rapidly losing importance in the general computing and communications market, Microsoft's monopoly extends over most of the desktop computer market. It is, therefore, a monopoly. It may not be as important as it once was, but the PC market is still huge by all measurements (and is mostly less relevant these days because the mobile device segment exploded).
- bhauer 13y ago