3 ms·
Use two-factor authentication for Persona with your own domain
- johnpmayer 13y agoThis looks really cool, but I'd prefer a personal tier option that I can host myself - this is auth after all.
- StavrosK 13y agoIndeed, I am thinking of open-sourcing the project so people can host it themselves if they like, while maybe retaining some extra functionality in the hosted version. It does mean that the benefit of easy installation will be negated for self-hosted installations, though.
- mcherm 13y ago> It does mean that the benefit of easy installation will be negated for self-hosted installations, though. ...and that's OK. You can offer self-hosted for the paranoid (or those who are not paranoid but merely reasonable and wish to engage in straightforward and legal activity like communicating with government whistle blowers), and offer the hosted version for those who value the ease of use. As a consumer, the fact that you offer both would increase my confidence in the hosted version.
- StavrosK 13y agoYep, that's the rationale behind the open-sourced version. I'd like to see some adoption before going to the trouble of open-sourcing it, though.
- drivebyacct2 13y agoYou might discuss the privacy implications of being this party in the Persona flow. There is some (very small, not important to me, but to some) information that you could glean.
- StavrosK 13y agodrivebyacct2, your comment is dead, although interesting. I will change the site to mention privacy implications, but what this service can learn about your logins is basically "you asked to be logged in to an unknown site at some known date". Persona itself is designed so that your identity provider doesn't know very much about where you log in.
- drivebyacct2 13y agoSorry, I'm aware it's dead. I didn't think there was much information exposed, but I thought it might have included where you logged into (that might depend on http/https?). Anyhow, maybe it's because it's Sunday but it's very disappointing to see this getting so few comments. Especially when it seems like just a few months ago the "Look at our amazing innovative password-less email login flow is!" that got so much attention, when this is the much more mature and future-friendly version of that idea. Cool work, I'd never considered outsourcing auth stuff before, but this is something I'd consider using and paying for.
- andrewflnr 13y agoRegarding the comment count drivebyacct2 mentioned, I consider it a good sign when a story has a high upvote/comment ratio. 32/6 (soon to be 7) is pretty good.
- StavrosK 13y agoReplying to drivebyacct2, nope, the protocol doesn't expose where you log in (that was one of their explicit goals). It's also one of the reasons I like Persona so much and decided to make this. I'm very glad you like it, I am always looking for feedback and would love to see Persona/Persowna gain more users. Please don't hesitate to email me about anything (email is in profile).
- Amadou 13y agothe protocol doesn't expose where you log in To be fair, in practicality it does expose where you log in because that website has to communicate with the persona server. The website could use a proxy or something to try to obfuscate which website it is doing an authentication for, but if there is any significant volume it would surely leak out unless they did it through Tor (and were not the only site doing persona authentication through Tor either). What the persona protocol explicitly does not leak is each login event, checking in with the persona server only happens once during account setup.
- ateev 13y agoYes. It would be greatly helpful if you open source it.
- mfincham 13y agoI am not sure I understand a hosted "authentication protocol implementation as a service" product. When's the code being released, and what's it written in? :)
- StavrosK 13y agoThere are no specific plans, currently. It's Python and Django, though.
- drdaeman 13y agoOne of the reasons I dislike Persona and believe it's a step in a wrong direction, is that after so many problems we had with various authentication/identity systems it make you lease your own identity from some third party you're forced to trust. Some say that I can set up my own Persona server, but my problem is that I think one can't really own a domain, only temporarily lease it from a registrar, so it's still the same. In contrast, one can posess a keypair without the necessity of any third parties (and third parties still may confirm the identity).
- StavrosK 13y agoHow is that any different from the current system, where your email address is your identity, and Gmail probably owns it?
- atmosx 13y agoIt's not that what he's saying actually, that all current easy-to-use systems (from Gmail to disqus) are based somehow on third parties. Your solution is the same, so the privacy breach (theoretically) is there. The good is that I don't have to type passwords and you probably should promote this persona feature a little bit more than the privacy thing, which presumes that we trust a third party while most of us do not. Good luck anyway, I might try to setup your persona for my website if persona takes off.
- StavrosK 13y agoSure, that's what I'm saying too, though. Persona isn't a step backwards, because, at worst, it's equal (and a bit better, privacy-wise) than what we have now. Otherwise, you can set up your own provider and not need to trust anyone else (except the domain provider, I guess, sure).
- workhere-io 13y agoI understand your concerns, but I think the positive aspects of Persona far outweigh the negative ones. E.g., with Persona it's much easier for users to sign up for a new service because no annoying email validation step is required. The developers of a website benefit from not having to store passwords (they only need to store the email of a user).