6 ms·
The demise of the DSLR
- nawitus 13y agoI might go mirrorless if and when Canon releases a full-frame mirrorless camera. Sony is apparently releasing one next year.
- abirkill 13y agoI think a lot of pros will add a crop-frame mirrorless camera to their kit when Canon release their speed booster (and a decent EF-M body, which will probably be at the same time). The ability to use existing full-frame lenses at the same focal lengths on a mirrorless camera, and gain a stop of light-gathering ability, will be a big draw.
- justincormack 13y agoNot really, they will still be much bigger due to retrofocus than a dedicated mirrorless lens. Lens redesign is needed really to make the most of it.
- abirkill 13y agoI'm not suggesting that this will be the final evolution, merely a tipping point that I suspect will see Canon's mirrorless offerings take off. Pros are going to be very reluctant to start buying several thousand dollars of lenses in a new and unproven (longevity-wise) lens mount, but may well buy a $1000 camera if an adapter lets it accept all of their existing lenses, keep the same focal length, and also turn their 16-35mm f/2.8 into a 16-35mm f/1.8.
- chrisbolt 13y agoDo you mean the RX1? http://duncandavidson.com/gear/sony/rx1/ http://duncandavidson.com/gear/sony/rx1/ I have one, and it's pretty impressive.
- gigq 13y agoI also have an RX1 and it really is a fantastic camera. I bet the OP was talking about the rumored full frame interchangeable lens camera (possibly a full frame NEX) that Sony is supposed to be announcing soon.
- jseliger 13y agoNo, he's referencing the long-rumored "NEX Full Frame": http://www.sonyalpharumors.com/sr5-full-frame-mirrorless-from-sony-coming-in-almost-exactly-one-year-24-or-30-32-megapixel http://www.sonyalpharumors.com/sr5-full-frame-mirrorless-fro...
- georgemcbay 13y agoI actually just "went" (but not completely) mirrorless when the EOS M got an autofocus speed upgrade and a price cut to clearance levels (I paid $350 for the body and kit lens). I am so glad I bought this camera. I still use my T1i DSLR with "big glass" at places where I need reach (I could get a lens adapter for the EOS M, but if I'm rocking a 100-400mm lens on the camera, the smallness of the mirrorless is insignificant, and I'll generally want an optical viewfinder) or faster autofocus and I plan on buying a 70D real soon to replace the T1i, but the EOS M comes with me everywhere. And the image quality is soooo good for a go-everywhere camera (the sensor is the same size as the one in my DSLR, and even better in a few minor respects since it is basically the T4i sensor)... Image quality is leaps and bounds above the Canon S100 which was my previous attempt at such a take-everywhere solution. Here's a shot I would never have gotten if the EOS M wasn't small enough that I can carry it everywhere (keep in mind this is just handheld using a bridge railing for stabilization, no tripod). I got this on the way to the parking lot after meeting some friends at the last Culture & Cocktails event at the San Diego Art Museum: http://www.gmcbay.com/pic/bpark.jpg http://www.gmcbay.com/pic/bpark.jpg There are a few more examples accessible via directory listing here, all from the EOS M for which I've since bought two more lenses (it still all fits in a very small Lowepro Lowepro Compact ILC Courier 70 bag even with the three lenses): http://www.gmcbay.com/pic/ http://www.gmcbay.com/pic/
- cschmidt 13y agoFor me going from a D700 to an OM-D, the biggest benefit was the much smaller size. And much of that size was in the lenses, not the bodies. The m4/3 lenses are so wonderfully small, after hauling around a 24-70/2.8 for so long. I think you'd be missing much of the benefit.
- bountie 13y agoThat last paragraph is a downer... Unlike film cameras, DSLR cameras you already own are going to be harder to maintain, if at all, and then what happens to all the thousands we spent on dslr glass...
- jacquesm 13y agoThis has been happening with every cycle. Media life-span got shorter and shorter. Just look at things like 16mm, 8mm, VHS and soon on the video front, 45, then 33 rpm vynil, compact cassette, DAT tape and CDs on the audio front. With film it isn't any different and it should be no surprise that digital devices suffer from this too. There has to be some lower limit for medium+device longevity.
- 3pt14159 13y agoIf there was a near-magical device that someone created that let you take pictures with your eyes at any iso, angle, etc that you desired wouldn't you be happy? The money we've put into glass is money towards an end. The end being taking awesome photos. If tomorrow I could do with my phone what I can do with my backpack + three or four lenses + 5D MII I wouldn't even blink. I'd just say "SWEET!" I love my lenses because of the photos they give me. And I totally disagree with this article. For every DSLR person that goes mirrorless there are going to be 10 iPhone photographers that go "pro".
- cschmidt 13y ago> what happens to all the thousands we spent on dslr glass... Well, if you don't wait too long, you can get a lot of it back. I sold my D700 + glass, and made $3300, which I used to buy a lovely OM-D system (12, 20, 25, 45, 75). I use my camera much more now.
- elorant 13y agoSurprisingly enough I’ve end up taking most of my photos with a smartphone. I used to carry around a compact camera but even that felt meaningless after I discovered how sharp photos can a modern smartphone produce. Plus software like Lightroom makes it easy to enhance the quality of your pictures a lot. So since the phone is the one device I carry with me all the time I see no point of having yet another gadget with me. As for my DSLR it's eating dust in some shelve on my library, I rarely ever use it these days. I’d love to get my hands sometime in the future on the 40 megapixel smartphone announced by Nokia.
- slaven 13y agoI take a ton of iPhone photos, but still I just bought another prime for my mirrorless camera (GH2). When taking photos of people it is still night-and-day difference between the two and bringing those photos to Lightroom always makes me smile compared with what Lightroom can do with iPhone photos. And 40 megapixel Nokia won't change that (lacking in lenses + dynamic range) But don't get me wrong - I love that my phone is good enough for photography to have on me all the time.
- kenjackson 13y agoI have a need for a good point and shoot this week and I got a friend to loan me his Lumia 1020 -- the pictures have been amazing for a phone. I haven't used my DSLR in a while -- mostly just using phones due to the convenience. The drop in quality historically is so huge though that I do on occasion consider carrying around the bulky DSLR (but I usually decide not to). But with the 1020, for the first time, I feel like the gap has been made small enough (although still not small) where I've found this past week that I've never seriously wished to have brought my DSLR. I'm still on contract, but I think I'll find it hard to go back to any other phone camera.
- e12e 13y agoBut the 1020 doesn't shoot in RAW, does it?
- 13y ago
- andrewcooke 13y agoi suspect he's correct, but it's strange to see an article on the subject, written by an apparent expert, that doesn't mention depth of field.
- justincormack 13y agoThere seem to be wider aperture small field lenses turning up eg f0.95, although they will have to be pretty big...
- andrewcooke 13y agoif you do the maths, depth of field depends on both the aperture and the sensor size. in other words, f1 on a smaller detector doesn't give the same depth of field as on a larger detector (for an object at the same distance). i wrote about here, but i am not sure it's very clear http://www.acooke.org/cute/DepthofFie1.html http://www.acooke.org/cute/DepthofFie1.html [edit: and so, for medium format, depth of field is more pronounced...]
- justincormack 13y agoSure, thats why people are going for f1 or less vs the usual f2 or so on full frame.
- ubercow13 13y agoBut mirrored vs mirrorless is not directly related to sensor size, there are mirrorless full-frame cameras.
- pampa 13y agoShallow depth of field is of limited use and vastly overrated. I was shooting mostly with medium format TLR camera and there was always a problem getting greater dof, not shallower. Greater dof is actually a big plus for many shooting styles and subjects.
- abirkill 13y ago
- devx 13y agoMirrorless cameras are disrupting DSLR's, and smartphones are disrupting the point and shoots (and possibly mirrorless cameras in the future - 10+ years).
- _sabe_ 13y agoAlot of people seems to think that the bigger camera the better, so soon the only ones buying DSLRs are the amateurs. :D
- potatolicious 13y agoThe numbers suggest otherwise though. Mirrorless cameras have been stealing some sales from DSLRs, but not as much as anyone thought it would (or hoped). DSLR sales are collapsing on the other hand, in a pretty dramatic way. People aren't trading the bulky DSLR in for a svelte mirrorless, they're trading it in for their phones. It turns out that a large portion of the amateur DSLR market is dominated by people who are now perfectly happy leaving their gigantor kit at home. Contrary to what Canonikon et al predicted, the entire low end of the market seems to be collapsing - DSLR, mirrorless, and all.
- malandrew 13y agoI'm looking forward to the serious glass lenses getting smaller because sensors are getting better and smaller at the same time.
- bborud 13y agoI'm looking forward to the invention of a new kind of physics too.
- MRSallee 13y agoCheck out micro 4/3 lenses, they're pretty small compared to typical SLR stuff and even other mirrorless systems. The Olympus 45mm f/1.8 is damn minuscule, yet renowned for image quality. The Panasonic 20mm f/1.7 is just as sharp and even smaller.
- ddunkin 13y agoI've been kind of hoping for this, all that high-end DSLR gear will suddenly become affordable on the used market. With photography, at least to me, you don't need the latest and greatest thing.
- truxs 13y agoDSLR were always designed for a niche market. The huge drop in prices allowed plenty of people to get one even if they needed a point and shoot, just because they could look more 'professional' (aka those only using automatic mode). But there are just too many cases where DSLR are superior because of its manual mode (shutter speed, adaptability, wide-angle, ...)
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- bnegreve 13y agoI am not sure that's the point. There are plenty of mirror-less cameras with a manual mode. In fact that's the opposite, the article foresees that in a couple of years, even professionals will use mirror-less cameras. EDIT clarity.
- corresation 13y agolook more 'professional' (aka those only using automatic mode) A DSLR usually means a larger, bigger sensor, better accessories, and better/selectable lenses. Using manual modes is a trivial, side value of SLRs (actually not even sure why it is mentioned given that every "P&S" I've had in the past decade has had full manual control as well), but in no way is a requirement to yield value from them. As a sidenote, one of the burdens of carrying a decent camera -- for those moments that only happen once -- is that someone often makes a snarky quip about being a professional.
- chickenboot 13y agoI'm personally a m4/3 convert - I exchanged my D700 and some great lenses for a full Olympus OM-D kit, and aside from a few quirks, I couldn't be happier. However I am not ashamed to say that the D700 and the glass I had was more camera than I needed; I would wager I'm not the only person who covets (and spends perhaps too much on) new and better gadgets though... I made the switch after a holiday with a new baby - trying to carry a serious DSLR and nice lenses around with a baby just didn't work. The whole m4/3 camera and lens kit feels to me like it weighs about as much as one of the serious lenses I used to have! A real fear is that, despite how happy I am (and clearly the author of this article is too), I don't think they're selling enough across the board (if you don't already, I'd suggest any avid photographer read Thom Hogan's stuff, and he talks about this often - e.g. here: [1]). [1] http://www.sansmirror.com/newsviews/the-m43-users-are-nervous.html http://www.sansmirror.com/newsviews/the-m43-users-are-nervou...
- jseliger 13y agoI never had a full-frame camera, but I did have a Rebel that I traded for an OM-D. Now I understand the hype.
- Stratoscope 13y agoAnother Micro Four Thirds convert here: got an Olympus E-P5 and several great lenses a month or two ago and have been having a blast with them. I got the 17mm f/1.8 that comes in the kit along with the VF-4 viewfinder. (Thank you Olympus for putting a good lens in the kit!) Also picked up the Olympus 60mm f/2.8 macro, 45mm f/1.8 portrait lens, the Panasonic 45-175mm, and the Samyang/Rokinon/Bower 7.5mm fisheye. They are all very fine lenses, but the macro and the fisheye have to be my favorites for pure fun factor. (Tip: the same fisheye lens is sold under all three names. Amazon carries all three and the prices bounce up and down wildly in the $250-$350 range. So put them all in your cart and check it once in a while to see when one of them is down close to $250.) The quality of these lenses combined with their small size and light weight makes the system a real winner for me. I've never actually owned a DSLR. I used to shoot with a Nikon FE film SLR with some nice lenses, but switched to compact cameras when I went digital. The Canon S95 I used for the last couple of years takes great pictures. But I wanted to be able to get fisheye photos (for panorama stitching) and better macro shots, and the m4/3 has really delivered. Thom Hogan is right that Olympus and Panasonic are having trouble selling enough of these cameras and lenses, and it probably is because people aren't moving from DSLRs to m4/3 but instead just using their smartphone cameras. For most of the photos people take most of the time, that's more than good enough. But I also agree with his conclusion: no one should be scared away from m4/3 because of these uncertainties. You can get great cameras and great lenses right now and use them for many years. These were taken with the Olympus and various lenses (except for the stained glass photo that I took many years ago). Some are just snapshots, but a few I'm really pleased with. All are straight out of the camera except for cropping, and defishing in the photo of the two dogs: http://www.flickr.com/photos/geary/ http://www.flickr.com/photos/geary/
- waivej 13y agoMy mirrorless shots tend to nail exposure and composition more often than DSLR. I've been waiting almost 14 years for the compact cameras to finally get comparable sensors and interchangeable lenses.
- foolrush 13y agoCannot think of a larger, albeit seductive, load of codswallop. Techno Utopianism ideologies appear predicated on the belief that technological advances can always implicitly trump physical design constraints. The well trodden technological aesthetic differences of larger sensors, and / or spherical or anamorphic lens elements immediately spring to mind. The article appears lacking a significant bit of insight into the mathematics behind optics and creative image capture. If anything, the lesser capable world of smartphones etc. have provided the agency to give people a means to pique their interest in photography and expand their tools. Suggesting a demise would seem to be anchored against evidence to the contrary[1]. [1] http://www.robgalbraith.com/content_pageecb5.html?cid=7-11667-12092 http://www.robgalbraith.com/content_pageecb5.html?cid=7-1166...
- wmf 13y agoNEX has the same size sensor as mainstream DSLRs yet the camera is much smaller and lighter. It will be interesting to see what the NEX-FF format looks like.
- pedrocr 13y agoRumor is that the NEX FF will not be much larger than a current NEX-7. The Sony RX1 is also a good example of how small you can make a fullframe mirroless camera.
- reeses 13y agoIn addition, the VG-900 shows that the e-mount will accommodate a 35mm sensor. Mind you, the e-mount lenses are almost universally crap, but I've had good luck using my NEX-7 as a digital back for my M glass.
- pedrocr 13y agoWhat is strange in the rumors is that the full-frame NEX is supposed to include antishake as well. Anti-shake and fullframe was supposed to be the combination that couldn't work on the NEX bayonete size. E-glass has been pretty crappy so far. They're now launching a few good ones. I'm excited about the alpha mirrorless opportunities though. Maybe we'll finally be able to have a SLR-like body that's agnostic to mount.
- jemeshsu 13y agoCurrent mirrorless cameras still can not compete with DSLR for sports and safari photography. Other than that I don't see the need to carry such heavy equipment. Currently using Lumix m4/3 but is tempted by Fujifilm X100s.
- pedrocr 13y ago>Current mirrorless cameras still can not compete with DSLR for sports and safari photography. You'll be surprised how quickly that changes. A 900$ Sony Alpha 77 shoots at 12fps, and a 6.000$ Nikon D4 does 10fps. The Nikon has a much more expensive autofocus system and yet that system is disabled anytime you take a shot by the mirror lifting while the Sony has it enabled throughout. Mirrorless is a natural evolution for sports and safari because of this. On-sensor autofocus has already been cracked so we should be seeing amazing mirrorless cameras for sports coming out in the next Alpha refresh.
- abirkill 13y agoI'm not so sure on-sensor autofocus has been cracked for use in wildlife and sports photography just yet -- it's pretty good for slow-moving subjects, but I've not seen an on-sensor autofocus system that can make a 400mm f/2.8 lens keep a jockey's eyes in focus. It's only a matter of time though. As soon as it is though, I also expect that mirrorless cameras will rapidly infiltrate the pro sports and wildlife market. Burst mode will become as irrelevant as loading film -- sports photographers will simply record full-resolution RAW video and pick out the frame that they want in post.
- pedrocr 13y agoYou're probably thinking of contrast based autofocus, no? The reason I say it's been cracked is that there are now sensors with integrated phase-detection on the sensor itself, so you don't need to split the optical path into a separate sensor. Canon has even announced a sensor where every pixel phase detects. That's even more impressive as you're not limited to a few autofocus points. The other reason that mirrorless has it easier for autofocus is that the sensors can be always on, unlike a traditional SLR where the mirror is up for the exposure and the autofocus is literally in the dark. Sony's SLT system already solves this by splitting the optical path continuously. Removing the mirror entirely is just the next step. That together with the more precise but slower contrast detection should make autofocus systems much better.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoOne point the author misses is that phones have cameras now that eclipsing the 'budget' point and shoot models (often the profit centers for camera makers), and the 'pro-sumer' M4/3ds cameras are eating away at the DSLR high end. Not a fun time to be a camera company. (well profit wise, lots of pressure to innovate and try new things like a camera that "Oh hey! Its a phone too!")
- pedrocr 13y ago>Not a fun time to be a camera company. It's not a fun time to be acting like an incumbent. Canon and Nikon are too stuck to their old systems to innovate. Sony, Olympus, Samsung, Fuji and Panasonic will eat their lunch, and if they don't watch out Sony will eat their high-end as well. The Alpha 99 is a serious contender already.
- bborud 13y agoWhat keeps Canon and Nikon in business is that the ecosystem is more worth than the camera itself. If you buy a Nikon or a Canon there is a high probability that if someone makes some cool gear, it will work with these cameras. The camera is the least important component since it is nigh on impossible to find a terrible SLR. And you if you are serious about photography, you will end up spending more money on lenses than on cameras.
- pedrocr 13y agoThat's what's amazing with mirrorless. Before it used to be pretty impossible to do an EOS to alpha adapter (for example). Once you remove the mirror that becomes much easier because of all the extra space. So even the argument that you should value being able to get something exotic that only Canon/Nikon carry will fade (their tilt-shifts are the only really good example I know of).
- bborud 13y agoPerhaps. But just look at the Petzval lens that just got funded on kickstarter. They will make it for Nikon and Canon. At least initially. Imagine the extra risk and extra cost of researching, designing, manufacturing, stocking and selling that lens for half a dozen different camera systems. If you were making a lens, would you prefer to make one or two versions or 6-7 versions?
- superbeefy 13y agoI think there is always going to be a place for DSLRs. Now, thats probably not going to be a market as large as it is now. However, DSLRs are not going away. A large majority of consumers who buy entry level DLRs never really move away for the kit lens or maybe one or two cheap lenses. These consumers will more than likely move to the new EVIL systems. At the prosumer level you'll see it'll be like a coin flip between people who want a more compact system and don't need all the features that DSLR provides, and others who do. However, at the professional level I don't see a demise of DSLR. There are certain types of work where, at least with current technologies, it doesn't make any sense. Sports photography you need high burst rates with fast accurate AF. Also large optics, this is more of a feeling, but I would rather be holding a large DSLR body attached to a 500mm super telephoto lens than the equivalent on smaller camera systems, this feeling also applies to large external flash units. Things just feel more sturdy in a larger camera system. Other issue I would have with moving to a mirrorless system is weather sealing, lack of ports like PC Sync and mic input, and flash sync speeds not as fast.
- eftpotrm 13y agoFrom a few months with an Olympus E-PL3 (last generation, I know) and a pair of lenses - yes, but not yet. For the bulk of what I do, the Olympus has real advantages over my Nikon D7000. It's much easier to carry round and so gets photos by simple virtue of presence. The ability to shoot waist-level on the screen is a major win, as is the ability to actually see sensor response live. No more guessing dynamic range and chimping, it's automatic. It's not there yet though, and neither are other mirrorless I've handled - * Many fewer direct controls. Simple things like changing ISO or switching AF off are just fiddly. * I've tried shooting moving subjects - it's just not as good as an SLR, you can't pick up and hold a subject anywhere near as quickly and easily. * System scale. None have a flashgun as good as my Nikon SB800 that I've found. My ultrawide SLR lens is double the price. Only Fuji (well, so far) seems to have really got quality fast glass in any quantity. Nine have significant third-party support currently. We're at a cross-over. In a few years the scene will look very different and mirrorless will be the way of the future, but none of them are ready to take over from SLRs properly yet, I'd suggest.
- pedrocr 13y agoThe Sony alpha line is moving agressively in that direction, and that includes all the nice glass and other bits of a system going back to the very first autofocus SLR (Minolta's). The lineup today no longer has SLRs they are all SLTs, with a fixed semi translucent mirror just for the phase-detected focusing system. The optical viewfinder was replaced by a screen fed from the sensor. The (very well confirmed) rumors are that they will be doing away with the mirror completely, and going full mirrorless. Without the mirror there the extra space should allow for all kinds of fun adapters to other systems. Their existing mirrorless sytem (NEX) is also moving fast. They are about to announce a SLR-shaped camera and the rumor is they will be moving NEX to full-frame and adding in-body antishake at the same time. When it comes to high-end mirrorless Sony is the one to watch.
- eftpotrm 13y agoWilling to be persuaded otherwise, but the major win of mirrorless for me is scale. A mount can lose its mirrors but the flange distance is still based around a mirror box so there's no win there. NEX is nice in some ways but I'm not convinced the site difference with a standard kit zoom mounted between an NEX and a Nikon D3200 is worth a system switch.
- 616c 13y agoI am surprised this comment is needed on HN, but a tool is a great tool in the hands of a professional, and a shitty one in the hands of an amateur. Jokes aside, as a kid once very interested in photography and took courses, I was shocked one night to watch TV and see one of those garbage entertainment gossip shows in passing mention how one Sports Illustrated Smiwsuit photographer's camera choice would shock you: he was using point-and-shoots (not all the time, but a good portion of the time). Surprise, surpise, I search and I find him: Terry. Richardson. http://www.aphotoeditor.com/2009/09/25/terry-richardson-talks-about-the-snapshot-and-connecting-with-people/ http://www.aphotoeditor.com/2009/09/25/terry-richardson-talk... A DSLR, like a programming language, is good in some contexts and not in others, and timing vs equipment needed does make a difference like he says, but the death of DSLR? Were we not discussing the slow death of PHP in the PHP thread a few hours ago? Haha. Good tools die, bad tools die, but they will remain tools with supporters and detractors.
- gallerytungsten 13y agoAn interesting article, but the author missed one main DSLR advantage: full manual control. For a number of shooting situations, this control is essential to obtaining the desired results.