4 ms·
Upshot is, The Indie revealed another piece of the puzzle in the reach of the surveillance culture that's being built. I suspect this is a direct leak from GCH
by grey-area 13y ago
Upshot is, The Indie revealed another piece of the puzzle in the reach of the surveillance culture that's being built.
I suspect this is a direct leak from GCHQ, trying to get ahead of future stories, and also trying to undermine Snowden's stance as a responsible whistleblower. No-one else is in possession of this information, and the article reads like a puff piece for GCHQ, particularly the ending.
This is incredibly misleading from the Independent - if it was from government sources that should have been clearly stated. If not they should name their source, it's not The Guardian (info destroyed one month ago), Snowden (denied, seems unlikely), Greenwald (Brazil), or Poitras, so where did it come from if not the government? It's really embarrassing for them if they have been duped, and even worse if they are complicit and reproducing press-releases from GCHQ without attribution, and with the implication that they have seen secret documents.
If they have seen secret documents and the UK government provided them, this undermines the argument against whistleblowers like Snowden, if not, who is the source? Without a source being specified, their story is not credible.
- panacea 13y agoTo be fair, the Indie has been completely missing from the conversation so far. Understandable that they want in. Despicable, if they're using 'undisclosed sources' who are the UK spy services though.
- eliasmacpherson 13y agoYes it does read like dirty tricks alright, particularly this which might as well be a statement from Theresa May who stands over the abuse of the terrorism law: >"the Metropolitan Police announced it was launching a terrorism investigation.. Scotland Yard said material examined so far from the computer of Mr Miranda was “highly sensitive”, the disclosure of which “could put lives at risk”. " I see that as an attempt at discrediting Miranda/Greenwald/The Guardian. > The Government also demanded that the paper not publish details of how UK telecoms firms, including BT and Vodafone, were secretly collaborating with GCHQ... But it only published information on the scheme... after the allegations appeared in the German newspaper Süddeutsche Zeitung. More of the same > The Independent understands that The Guardian agreed to the Government’s request not to publish any material contained in the Snowden documents that could damage national security... But there are fears in Government that Mr Greenwald – who still has access to the files – could attempt to release damaging information. More of the same I think the fact there is a base in the middle east is already known from this: http://oglobo.globo.com/infograficos/volume-rastreamento-governo-americano/ http://oglobo.globo.com/infograficos/volume-rastreamento-gov... I think the GCHQ involvement and the BT, Vodafone are the only new information. So it smells pretty bad, especially combined with the misdirection about being in Snowden's files.
- espeed 13y agoI suspect this is a direct leak from GCHQ, trying to get ahead of future stories Among other things, it shifts the focus from domestic surveillance to Middle East surveillance, which presumably less people have an issue with.