8 ms·
What I don't get is all the companies actually setting up shop in San Francisco. If I were a tech startup, I'd actually setup shop in a nice area relative to c
by tracker1 13y ago
What I don't get is all the companies actually setting up shop in San Francisco. If I were a tech startup, I'd actually setup shop in a nice area relative to cost of living, then attempt to draw people out.
If you can get someone already in SF out to say Boise, Denver, or Phoenix they can make 80% of what they made in SF and have a better lifestyle. If you cover the cost of moving that should make it a very attractive offer. Sell their home in SF (if they own), and buy a nicer/roomier place in the new location.
Phoenix in particular has a pretty thriving tech community, and a far better cost of living. The main reason I stay here is the job market is great, and the cost of living is far better, relative to programming pay than most other areas. Of course there is the down side (June, July and August).
- 727374 13y agoMy personal pick is South Lake Tahoe. No state income tax, 3.5 hr drive to SF, commercial airport, and stunningly beautiful. Heck, a lot of SV/SF bigshots already have vacation homes in the area.
- tracker1 13y agoExactly... There are lots of really nice locations all across the country that seem to be far more attractive options to a startup wanting to draw in talent.
- joonix 13y agoHow are you going to convince people to move a rural area where they know nobody just to work for your startup that might not be around in a year? All to save what, $1,000 a year? How are the schools in Tahoe? Vacation homes, exactly. Lifestyle business guys, freelancers, writers, yeah of course. But trying to found the next Google in Tahoe doesn't make sense unless there's already a major "anchor" tech company in place there.
- 727374 13y agoIf you're trying to start the next Google, by all means you should move to Mountain View and put it all on the line. Someone could easily save $20k a year between lower rent (1500/mo vs 2500/mo) and lack of CA state income tax (9k?).
- kbuck 13y agoI live in the bay (but not SF), and the biggest thing that would would give me pause here is that I don't want to live in Boise, Denver, or Phoenix. Some people are fine with living anywhere. Others are looking for good weather, a specific culture, or something else.
- prostoalex 13y agoMy typical response to recruiters pitching their next hot startup "right in the heart of SOMA" is remote work with a combination of travel + corporate housing. That usually brings the conversation to a halt.
- callmeed 13y agoYes–having previously been enamored with the idea of someday founding a startup in SF, I'm more and more enjoying staying right here on the Central Coast of CA. I'm in San Luis Obispo and between here and Santa Barbara we've got good universities, a big digital agency, a small Amazon office, iFixit, RightScale, MindBody, and a lot of other smaller startups. Being driving distance to both LA and SF means I can hit meetups and hackathons at any time. I'm at the beach on almost a daily basis. Our biggest drawback is a weak VC climate and no international airport. Housing isn't exactly cheap either (median home is $567K) but there are plenty of options within 20 min drive. So, we won't be the next SV but it would be cool to see more companies starting and staying here–or more large companies setting up satellite offices here.
- Domenic_S 13y agoShhh... don't let people know about the oasis that is SLO, Oprah already opened that up! http://travel.usatoday.com/destinations/story/2011/04/San-Luis-Obispo-Its-the-happiest-place-in-the-USA-/45900412/1 http://travel.usatoday.com/destinations/story/2011/04/San-Lu... I regret leaving SLO county. I live in the Bay now, but returning is on my to-do list.
- illicium 13y agoIt's also fairly boring if you're not into schmoozing with college students or retirees, and there's no good food compared to the Bay Area/LA.
- callmeed 13y agoI've got a wife and 4 kids so boredom isn't even an option for me.
- tzs 13y agoWhen I was at a startup many years ago, we were so busy that no one had time to take advantage of the various entertainment and cultural offerings of the Bay Area or Silicon Valley during the week. It was only on the weekends that we might have time to take a break and go out to a nice restaurant, or a show, or a club, or whatever. Best someone might do during the week was catch a movie. Given this, what's the point of putting the company there? We could have put the company in Modesto or Stockton, where people could live in much nicer homes during the week (and the company would pay a lot less for office space), and they would save so much in living expenses that even if every weekend they drove to San Francisco and stayed in a nice hotel and ate every meal at a nice restaurant, they would still come out ahead.
- comrade_ogilvy 13y agoIt depends on your business model. If your business model does not include strong growth, you have the option to organically growing your dev team from smart and less experienced people over the course of many years. If your business model includes VERY strong growth, paying top dollar to hire experienced people may be a necessity. Large numbers of experienced people can (more or less) only be found in SF/SV. It might cost 4X as much, but it can offer a potential payoff 10X or 20X or 40X as great. (At least that is what the VCs are looking for.) And many businesses live in between these extremes, where the optimal choice is unclear. Choose wisely.
- thetrb 13y agoYes, but do you really think you would find the people you need that are willing to move to Modesto or Stockton?
- combusean 13y agoI don't know if you're aware of this, but there are jobs in San Francisco that actually do have a reasonable work-life balance.
- badave 13y agoExcept none of those places are Silicon Valley or San Francisco. There are few major hubs of startup activity, the other major one being New York City. The atmosphere and population density of ambitious programmers and like minded designers and business guys play a key role in why those active hubs exist in very few places. VC money and the active community play huge roles here. There are dozens of meetups you can go to and meet people interested in programming or startups. There are hackathons every other weekend and a lot of tech based conferences are pretty much routine. There are happy hours almost every day of the week at various incubators or shared work spaces or even at clubs hosted by a startup. The sheer volume of events and startups and tech based companies here blows Boise, Denver, Phoenix, .... all other cities out of the water. That's why SF is so expensive to live in -- all these tech guys get paid $$$ and landlords feel as though they can just keep raising prices to take over that income. It's similar to how NYC got extremely expensive because of all the financial guys making tons of $$$. If there is cash to be had, it'll raise the cost of everything.
- fennecfoxen 13y ago"If there is cash to be had, it'll raise the cost of everything." If there's cash to be had, it'll rase the cost of... some things. First of all, obviously, of real estate, because there is a finite stock of developed real estate, there is finite land nearby (especially in San Francisco), the short-term supply curve is relatively inelastic (i.e. it takes time to build apartments) and the long-term supply curve isn't that elastic either (because local governments limit construction through the political process). And then that will push up the price of things with real estate as an input (e.g. restaurants and grocery stores) and with labor as an input (also restaurants and grocery stores and other things in the service industry).... But that's about it. Some things will remain cheap. You can buy the same cheap electronics and home furnishings and digital media off Amazon.com as anyone else does.
- JimboOmega 13y agoOne thing that's left out is that young people want to move to certain cities because other young people also live there. The economic/networking benefits are huge, of course. But you can't ignore the "cool" factor. It's not just some ephemeral thing. Being in a "cool" city means vastly more and better dating opportunities. Also social ones - more like minded people - but dating ones in particular. Young people with disposable incomes want to hang out and date others like them, and that's one of the biggest draws of a city like San Francisco.
- acgourley 13y agoWe just fled from SF to Berkeley and haven't looked back.
- integraton 13y agoThe reason people do their startups here is because there are several related, overlapping professional and social scenes spanning 2+ generations. From a less cynical perspective, the fact of the matter is that compared to anywhere I'm aware of, the Bay Area has a much stronger culture of entrepreneurs assisting each other. There's a much stronger culture of what could perhaps be framed as mentorship, with a large population of people who have been in the game for a long time and are still engaged as founders, executives, or investors. It's also probably one of the few places where there's a widespread acceptance that innovation means experimenting with risky business models without being forced to constantly focus on short-term revenue. From a more cynical perspective, in many cases for younger or newer founders, this means it's easier to climb the social ladder and be in the "tech entrepreneur" scene. It feels exciting and the money flowing around between young people (something that doesn't exist everywhere) makes everything seem more real than it is. I also think it's far easier to inflate the value of companies here for a variety of reasons.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- zinssmeister 13y agothis all sounds great for entrepreneurs, but what about the software engineer that just wants to work on cool projects and have a nice home/kids/car and isn't really interested in networking much, having a "mentor" or raising capital to start a company?
- lbrandy 13y ago> work on cool projects Because of the density of "cool projects". If I move to Boise* to work at your cool company, and something happens, and it's not so cool anymore, I'm in Boise. If I'm in SF, I go next door. [1] Sorry Boise. I chose you because the grand-parent used you as an example... feel free to insert your favorite city for rhetorical purposes
- michaelochurch 13y ago
- lmartel 13y agoDrawing people out can be hard, though. A lot of tech companies recruit young engineers and new grads heavily, and many 20-somethings won't be convinced to leave SF. SF might be expensive but it's fun in a way that Boise isn't for (most) young people. If you ask a fresh Stanford or Berkeley grad to move to Boise and take a 20% pay cut (even though it's more pay relative to the cost of living) they're going to hang up on you.
- combusean 13y agoPhoenix has a thriving tech community? What? I lived in Phoenix and I moved to San Francisco to find work precisely because of Phoenix's dismal tech industry. After my contract ended last year, I had three or four job opportunities in Phoenix that I had to turn down. There is no worse feeling in the world than turning down work when unemployed because those jobs would have been huge steps backwards in my career. One was with a college where I'd be rewriting the same web form in PHP with some rudimentary javascript every day--no growth opportunities. One was with a custom automotive shop that hosted their website on phpBB and had the worst code imaginable as demonstrated to me on a programming test. Another was with a web design firm that listed the most extreme political candidates in the state as its clients. None of these jobs were accessible by transit, incidentally, and would have given me upwards of a 20 mile commute from downtown (the only place in the Phoenix area with a modicum of arts, culture, and entertainment options--and that's about 0.001% of what the Bay Area can offer). IMHO, it's still 2006 in Phoenix's web dev industry, with a bunch of crappy PHP jobs and maybe five Ruby on Rails jobs postings a year. Companies that serve millions of users and are on the absolute cutting edge of technology simply do not exist in that town. I am certain that my job, writing enterprise social media management software in Ruby on Rails does not exist in the state at all. Practically speaking, the access to venture capital, tech journalism, and labor in San Francisco and Silicon Valley is utterly unmatched in the nation. Personally speaking, my quality of life, partially because of a 43% higher paycheck (before bonuses) than I'd ever make in Phoenix is unmatched. My rent might be three times as much, but I've more than made up for it in improvements to my social life, mental health, dating life, and about two dozen other factors. The funny thing about expensive places to live is that they're worth it. Your idea that people have a better lifestyle in Phoenix compared to San Francisco is an absolute Dunning Krueger--there are FAR more factors to one's quality of life than how big their house is. When I talk to Californians about Arizona the only positive thing I heard was that somebody liked Sedona or Spring Training on vacation. The vast majority said Phoenix was too hot and racist and couldn't imagine living there for any reason. I wouldn't move back to Phoenix for a part time job that paid a half million a year.
- Periodic 13y agoI've had jobs at various tech companies. I'm fairly confident I could make a good living in most cities in the US, either through working remotely, contract work, or working for local companies if I can find a good one. However, I just can't get the quality of work in Arizona that I can get here. When I go hunting for a new job here I can talk to dozens of world-class companies making products used across the world. More importantly, these companies are really innovating. They aren't just rebuilding or reapplying the same technologies. That fulfillment in my work is worth dealing with the cost of living, though most of the companies compensate well.
- ganeumann 13y agoOne of my portfolio companies set up shop in Portland, Oregon and managed to convince some of the best developers on the planet (in my opinion) to move there. Not sure if that would work in Boise or not, but it's doable.
- icedog 13y agoAs a developer in SF, I've been telling everyone that Portland is the place to be. You can actually live comfortably and (relatively) safely ride your bike to work. Plus, it's undoubtedly a more beautiful city. Unfortunately, I haven't been too impressed with the job selection in Portland. Though, I may be doing my own startup in a few months; Portland may be my spot for seeking residence and capital.
- steveax 13y agoNaw, it sucks up here in stumptown. Rains all the time. Can't find a decent pint of beer or cup of coffee to save your life. Place is full of hipsters -- have you seen Portlandia? You wouldn't like it. Best stay away.
- kilroy123 13y agoI think this is why Portland's tech scene is really booming. Much lower cost of living, supportive tech scene, and still a cool city to live in. Though the weather isn't nearly as nice...
- icedog 13y agoI lived there for a few months in the summer; the weather was perfect. I hear the rest of the year isn't as enjoyable, but neither is SF.
- mbesto 13y agoCouple of reasons: 1. Early evangelists/Network. You can effectively "buy" 10-15% of your long tail by living/networking there. (assuming you have a compelling product) 2. Capital. Capital is recycled in tech companies in SV just like finance capital is recycled in NYC. These are two areas that many companies find very difficult to do in early-stage.
- raldi 13y agoThere are a lot of great engineers who live in SF, are unwilling to live anywhere else, and don't want a long commute. The only way to get them to work for you is to have an office in the city.
- runT1ME 13y agoIgnoring the lifestyle argument (SF/City life vs. Boise, Denver), there's a practical aspect too. I would take the right offer in SF and relocate there because if the company went under, or I didn't like it, or it somehow didn't end up working out, I am confident I could find something else comparable. I can't say the same thing about any of the cheaper places you mentioned.
- ebiester 13y agoI have two requirements: 1. I can walk to everything I need within a half mile radius from home, including most entertainment. 2. I can get married to my (also male) partner. There are quite a few places in Europe that are open to me, but surprisingly few American cities. And that's why many of us are in SF -- we dislike driving and like liberals. :)
- Guvante 13y agoThere are trade offs to everything. You can't be a half mile from everything when everyone has 1/4 acre lots. No disagreements on the later.
- felipe 13y agoActually #2 is a false assumption: Keep in mind that California approved prop 8 and just recently the courts rejected it after a long and tough fight. In addition, my wife was a teacher and advocate for at-risk minority kids in SF, and I can tell you this whole thing about SF being "minority friendly" is a bunch of BS. Affluent new residents (such as high-tech employees) are very passive-aggressive about "accepting" minorities, but behind closed-doors they are actually very conservative. And the city policies are there to prove my point. I am not trying to discourage you. I'm just trying to alert you to take the whole "SF vibe" with a grain of salt, as my wife and I have witnessed that first hand.
- overgryphon 13y agoIt is better to have a higher salary in a higher cost of living area than a correspondingly lower salary in a lower cost of living area. The price of many many things are constant regardless of where you live, especially with online shopping. These items are all cheaper relatively if you live in San Francisco and make $100k than if you lived elsewhere and made $80k.
- aliston 13y agoFood/nightlife and housing are the biggest expenses for me and most of my friends in the 20-30 y.o. age group, and where I live (Austin), 80k goes a lot farther with regard to those expenses than 100k in Austin.
- caniszczyk 13y agosshhh stop telling people about Austin
- pkaler 13y ago> What I don't get is all the companies actually setting up shop in San Francisco. If I were a tech startup, I'd actually setup shop in a nice area relative to cost of living, then attempt to draw people out. I live in Vancouver. I can wake up in the morning take the Canada Line -> YVR -> SFO -> BART -> your SF office by 10AM. I bet there are a bunch of other cities like that. Portland would be a good bet, too. But intellectual density matters. It matters especially at inflection points like launches, fund raising, etc. Serendipity matters, too. You're going to end up meeting that next hire, customer, journalist, etc the next time you are in a coffee shop.
- alphakappa 13y ago> I live in Vancouver. I can wake up in the morning take the Canada Line -> YVR -> SFO -> BART -> your SF office by 10AM. In theory, yes. In practice, no (unless you are part of a minority that can afford to fly across borders multiple times a week)
- CanSpice 13y agoVancouver's housing prices are just as stupid as San Francisco's, though.
- robbyking 13y agoI think there are too many people like me: I've been developing professionally since 2000, and I would never work outside of the city, no matter how much better the cost-of-living to income ratio is. San Francisco is my home, and I love it.
- jaggederest 13y agoSF has a lot of qualities you definitely can't find in Boise, Denver, or Phoenix. Places, sadly, are not simply interchangeable - if what you value is amazing food and a good night life, NY, LA, and SF (along with a few other cities) are tough to beat.
- jacoblyles 13y agoCan a city with a 12am last train and a 1:30am last call really claim to have a "good night life"?
- jaggederest 13y agoI defy you to find me one place in Boise that you'd consider 'good night life'. I know of at least 3-4 places in SF that are great, and of course, NYC is in a league of its own.
- calbear81 13y agoYes, when everything is reasonably walkable or a short Uber or Lyft ride away. Last call at the bars is at 1:30AM, but the party rages on in private residences.
- danilocampos 13y agoMoving to Boise doesn't give me a better lifestyle. It gives me more disposable income and tons of reasons to want to hang myself. To wit: - Driving and car ownership - Lack of convenience, quality and variety in food choices - Fewer options for personal fellowship and professional networking - Cannabis prohibition - Loss of weather I love - Dull landscape ...to name a few People live in San Francisco 'cause it's wonderful and they can. Only a gun could "lure" me from here.
- HelloMcFly 13y agoI also thought Boise was a bad example. From my perspective, the natural alternative to San Francisco is Seattle: decent public transit, awesome food, has a tech culture, friendly cannabis policies, amazing landscape, and (most importantly to me) a much more affordable cost of living. When I was making the choice to relocate to the west coast, I started out 100% set on getting to the Bay Area. But as I visited the cities, looked at the job opportunities (disclosure: I am not a programmer by trade, but have worked in the tech industry), and evaluated my living choices, San Francisco just didn't make any sense for me. Of course I don't mean to suggest that's the only alternative. Rather, I agree with the OP that it seems like there's an argument to be made for basing your start-up outside of San Francisco, and there are at least decent alternatives.
- geoka9 13y ago> the natural alternative to San Francisco is Seattle Only it rains 8 months out of 12 in Seattle :(
- HelloMcFly 13y agoNo city is 100% perfect. I've found that the rain in Seattle is one of those things most brought up by people that have never lived here. It's a daily light rain, and not constant. The annual rainfall in Atlanta is higher than the annual rainfall in Seattle. It is dark in the winter months though, and for some that will be a big bummer. But it's an easy trade for me if that means I can easily afford to live in the city.
- mathattack 13y agoIn the medium and long term, employee cost is less important than missing out on the absolutely best employees and mentors. The work of great employees scale, and the great employees willing to join startups tend to flock towards cities like San Francisco. Yes you can pull it off in Boise, but it's harder. And when you factor in loss of access to mentors, VCs, and suppliers and leading edge customers, you wind up being penny-wise and pound-foolish.
- jacoblyles 13y agoSF is the place to be because of the glorification of the young engineer. If you're hiring people around 25 y.o., SF is the place to be to win the talent war. But engineers with kids can't live there. If you're hiring engineers around 35 y.o., SF is the wrong place to be. We're still in the facebook era with regards to how most founders think about hiring talent. So SF it is. Many of the other places you mention are much more family friendly, and still pretty cool for young people.
- miah_ 13y agoIf I leave a job in SF, I can have a new job within days. I am not sure the same can be said about other regions. Yes, its ridiculously expensive here, but I know I will have a job. I'm originally from Michigan, and have lived in Houston, Boston, and Ft. Lauderdale. I can safely say that the "cheaper" places were a huge PITA to find a good job in. Especially if I didn't want to deal with office politics, puritanical dress codes, or other stupid bullshit. And fwiw, I've worked with Startups, Hospitals, Banks, Researchers, and Factories. There are definitely bonuses to living in a cheap & small town. But unless you are able to work remotely you will likely have to "settle" for a job.
- angersock 13y agoIf you couldn't find work in Houston, I'm pretty sure you weren't trying very hard.
- joonix 13y agoIn banking this was attempted and achieved mixed results. UBS for example tried to get people to move to Stamford but they've migrated from that strategy because they couldn't recruit top talent out of schools. Young people don't prioritize saving money, they want to have fun. Goldman Sachs' #2 campus is in Salt Lake City. They pay less and save on costs but I suspect the real ambitious employees don't take that assignment. You are going to have trouble climbing the ranks if you're posted out in Salt Lake City. It does attract the people who don't care so much for corporate climbing and prefer quality of life.
- martinshen 13y agoStartup people flock to San Francisco and the Bay Area in general because of accelerated learning. You get accelerated learning because everyone is here. Need some paid CAC, viral growth, fundraising, scaling or pretty much anything startup expertise? Those people are all here. It's similar to picking between State vs. Private institutions for school. You will certainly get more bang for your buck in at the State school but you will miss out on the pools of brilliant minds at MIT. (There are similar echo chamber trade offs) Raising funds aside, you gotta ask yourself... is the additional runway gained from moving to a cheaper location worth the potential gains in learning? Is my startup about the hours I put in or about how smart those hours are? I think that you acquire entrepreneur knowledge quicker in SF than pretty much anywhere in the world. I feel like I've gained decades of experience in only 2 years here.
- calbear81 13y agoLower cost of living ≠ Better Living You'll have more money left in your pocket after living expenses but then you won't get the culture, the nightlife and the food.