13 ms·
Does Gravity Travel at the Speed of Light? (1998)
- bfe 13y agoWeisberg and Taylor showed, with 30 years of data, that the orbital decay of the binary pulsar PSR 1913+16 agrees with the gravitational radiation prediction of general relativity to within 0.2%: http://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/0407149 http://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/0407149
- spdegabrielle 13y agoDon't 'TL;DR' this is worth reading.
- einhverfr 13y agoSee, I was going to make a joke like: TL;DR: Relativistic models of gravity rely on retarded positions.
- ssivark 13y agoIt's a fairly short and clear article, so no need for a Tl;DR. Note that this is NOT yet another "revolutionary" announcement, but just contemplative reasoning from a respected expert in gravitational physics.
- peterwwillis 13y agoYeah, well. I don't get it. Could somebody summarize it in terms a 9 year old like myself can understand?
- pdonis 13y agoHow about "Yes, gravity travels at the speed of light"?
- marcosdumay 13y agoI like this better: "All of our theories say that yes, gravity travels at the speed of light, but nobody was ever able to test it on practice."
- aidenn0 13y agoGravity travels at the speed of light, but it pulls you towards where the object is going to be when it left the object, not where it was when it left the object.
- acchow 13y agoThanks for this. Tweaking it slightly: > Gravity travels at the speed of light, but it pulls you towards where the object would be if the object kept moving at constant speed, not where it was when it left the object
- aidenn0 13y agoIt's been 10 years since I took a physics class, but isn't it constant acceleration, not constant speed?
- gtani 13y agoBaez has published some great booklists and a FAQ for self study http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/physics/index.html http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/physics/index.html http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/books.html http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/books.html http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/physics/Administrivia/booklist.html http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/physics/Administrivia/booklist...
- mladenkovacevic 13y agoI wonder if the recent nova event visible with the naked eye can be used to do an experimental measurement... or perhaps it has to be a supernova as the article suggests.
- codezero 13y agoI am guessing it has to be a supernova on account of there being many novae discovered/observed each year.
- pdonis 13y agoYes, any gravitational radiation from a nova would be much weaker than from a supernova. As the article notes, unless the supernova is very close to us, our current detectors can't detect the gravitational waves from a supernova, so they certainly wouldn't be able to pick them up from a nova.
- chiph 13y agoSo, the FTL gravity pulses used in David Weber's Honorverse series (sci-fi space opera) aren't possible. :(
- negativity 13y agoBut maybe a "warp drive" is? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6238297 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6238297 ...so then we still get to achieve an effective result of reaching a destination faster than light. ...and since the gravity warps space, and the warp drive exploits warped space, does that mean that the quantum mechanism behind the warp drive is somehow directly related to gravity? the ring would contain exotic matter called negative vacuum energy, a consequence of quantum mechanics. The presence of this toroidal ring of negative vacuum energy is what's required from the math and physics to be able to use the warp trick. It doesn't explicitly mention "gravity", but wouldn't this "negative vacuum energy" have some kind of important relationship with the behavior of gravity?
- pdonis 13y agowouldn't this "negative vacuum energy" have some kind of important relationship with the behavior of gravity? It seems like it would, yes, but I haven't really seen this discussed in papers on wormholes.
- protomyth 13y agoWell, a hand-wavy explanation could be the gravity interacts with hyperspace[1] allowing the detector to pick it up FTL. 1) it seems his version of hyperspace has a lot of interaction with gravity (e.g. gravity waves like The Deep)
- yawgmoth 13y agoSomething very interesting whenever this question is asked - what is the speed of light? It is "the speed at which data propagates through space time". I think that is a fascinating truth to our universe. There is a very good discussion from r/askscience on this topic: http://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/1kjp6z/does_gravity_travel_at_the_speed_of_light_if_the/ http://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/1kjp6z/does_grav...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- mahranch 13y agoI always liked the analogy from here: http://zidbits.com/2011/04/why-cant-anything-go-faster-than-the-speed-of-light/ http://zidbits.com/2011/04/why-cant-anything-go-faster-than-... The speed of light can be thought of as infinite speed in that context. Since time slows as you get closer and closer to the speed of light, it stops completely at 299,792,458 m/s (hypothetically, if you gave photons a reference frame). Trying to go faster than light could be compared to a car slowing down for a red light. Once at the red light, the car stops. Going faster than light would be like asking the car to go slower than completely stopped. It just doesn't make sense in a philosophical or mathematical sense.
- chockablock 13y agoDate in title should be 2011 (date of latest revision), not 1998. Article includes a citation from after 1998.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- hcarvalhoalves 13y agoThat's mind bending, never thought of gravity that way (being a force like EM, and subject to a propagation speed). In my mind, gravity was just some sort of "vacuum" the mass leaves as it moves, and other bodies get "pulled in" because that's the space where the "energy" (mass) levels are smaller, and the system tends to a stable state. But not something like a wave that propagates, just a side effect of the global system, not tied to speed in any way.
- pachydermic 13y agoObligatory: http://xkcd.com/895/ http://xkcd.com/895/
- hcarvalhoalves 13y agoHaha good one!
- pdonis 13y agoActually, the "gravity" that propagates at the speed of light isn't really a "force"; it's more like changes in a force. A completely static gravity field doesn't have to "propagate" at all, because it never changes; but it can still produce a "force" (i.e., it can still cause objects to freely fall towards the source).
- hcarvalhoalves 13y agoI see the point. Thanks for the comment.
- jack9 13y ago> But if the sun vanished right now, it would take 8 minutes for the earth to stop orbiting and shoot off into space. http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/physics/Relativity/GR/grav_radiation.html http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/physics/Relativity/GR/grav_rad... There's a number of competing models which fit existing data. http://scienceblogs.com/startswithabang/2010/08/25/what-is-the-speed-of-gravity/ http://scienceblogs.com/startswithabang/2010/08/25/what-is-t... See the closing paragraph referencing LISA ~ 2030 A.D. The real way to measure the speed of gravity is to detect and study gravitational waves. By comparing the arrival of a gravitational-wave signal with that of an electromagnetic signal from an astrophysical source, one could compare the speed of gravity to that of light to parts in 10^(17).
- mturmon 13y agoPeople may be interested in experiments to detect these waves. From the Wikipedia page on LIGO: "LIGO, which stands for the Laser Interferometer Gravitational-Wave Observatory, is a large-scale physics experiment aiming to directly detect gravitational waves. [...] At the cost of $365 million (in 2002 USD), it is the largest and most ambitious project ever funded by the NSF. Observations at LIGO began in 2002 and ended in 2010; no unambiguous detections of gravitational waves have been reported. The original detectors were disassembled and are currently being replaced by improved versions known as "advanced LIGO", scheduled to be operational by 2014. [...] Measurable emissions of gravitational waves are expected from binary systems (collisions and coalescences of neutron stars or black holes), supernova of massive stars (which form neutron stars and black holes), accreting neutron stars, rotations of neutron stars with deformed crusts, and the remnants of gravitational radiation created by the birth of the universe." For more: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LIGO http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LIGO http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravitational-wave_detector http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravitational-wave_detector There is a fantastic lecture series by a Yale U. astronomer that touches on this and related topics from a calculus-free perspective: http://oyc.yale.edu/astronomy/astr-160 http://oyc.yale.edu/astronomy/astr-160 Also on youtube and iTunes U.
- TallGuyShort 13y agoI'm surprised the term "waves" (a la electromagnetism) is used instead of "fields" (a la magnetism). Can anyone explain that?
- icegreentea 13y agoWaves (such as EM waves) imply the change in some field, which is what they are trying to detect. After all, we already detect gravitational fields - after all, we are standing on the earth - what they're trying to detect are very specific changes to gravitational fields, thus waves.
- platz 13y agoI was fascinated with LIGO when I learned about it. It seems the best plans for such devices exist in the planned space-bound installations, such as LISA (http://lisa.nasa.gov/ http://lisa.nasa.gov/)
- stephengillie 13y agoIt makes me think of hanging sand in Minecraft -- you disrupt 1 column and cause it to be recalculated and fall, and this causes the columns next to it to be recalculated and fall, dominoing on until all of the hanging sand has fallen. This is the propagation in action. The propagation time is a combination of the 'tick rate' and the 'size of the granules'. In Minecraft, I'm pretty sure the tick rate is around 1/10 of a second, and the granule size is defined as 1 cubic meter. In our universe, the tick rate probably is 1/c, or .00000000333 seconds (please correct my math), and the granule size is similarly infinitesimal.
- aphyr 13y agoSince c is a velocity, 1/c doesn't have units of time; it has units of time/distance. Special and general relativity (at least, as commonly formulated) also assume that space and time are isotropic and continuous, which means there is no "granule", no "smallest increment" in the field equations. That may or may not be true; we're still trying to figure out if spacetime is quantized or not.
- DougWebb 13y agoDoes anyone know what Wolfram would say about the tickrate? I bought the huge book and know that he believes space is quantized, at least, and I assume he believes time is as well, as the rate the universal state machine changes states. But I never read enough to learn what he thinks that rate might be.
- shmageggy 13y agoMy impression is that Wolfram came to such conclusions because he is obsessed with cellular automata and with their mathematical universality in discrete domains. Of course, they are useless in continuous domains, so it would be ruinous to his world-view if the universe were continuous. So it's a bit like ancient metaphysics a la Plato and Co., where the properties of the universe are inferred from first principles (which come from... where, exactly?) rather than from any empirical observation. A review of Wolfram's book: http://vserver1.cscs.lsa.umich.edu/~crshalizi/reviews/wolfram/ http://vserver1.cscs.lsa.umich.edu/~crshalizi/reviews/wolfra...
- rossjudson 13y agoI remember perplexing a high school physics teacher with this one, many years ago. ;) His answer was that he thought it would propagate at the speed of light, but he wasn't sure. I was just being a smart-ass, trying to figure out if something could go faster than the speed of light.
- AlwaysBCoding 13y agoThis is the winning comment from the reddit discussion from /u/RobotRollCall * This is a far more interesting question than it might seem at first glance, and it deserves some attention because it tells us something fundamental and wonderful and just bloody awesome about the universe. But I don't know how to tell the story succinctly. So I'm going to do that thing I do. I am very, very sorry. Please feel free to move on if this strikes you as tiresome. Consider the Earth, and you on it. You're not floating freely, so clearly something's going on. We call that "gravity." We can call it, in the most generic sense, an interaction: you and the Earth are interacting somehow, and that's what's keeping you from floating freely. We can then ask what the speed of that interaction is by putting it in these specific terms: How much time will elapse between your changing your position relative to the ground and your beginning to fall? Yes, it's the Wile E. Coyote problem. Wile E. Coyote runs off a cliff, floats in mid-air long enough to hold up a sign that says "Help," then begins to fall. Clearly that's an exaggeration. But just how much time does elapse, in real life, between stepping off a cliff and beginning to fall? We can approach the problem naively by remembering that all propagating phenomena in the universe are limited by the speed of light. Given that fact, it makes sense to hypothesize that the time between the moment when Wile E. steps off the cliff and when he begins to fall will be equal to or more than the distance between him and the ground divided by the speed of light. It certainly can't be less, right? We can then construct a set of very, very precise experiments with very fine tolerances — probably involving electromagnets and lasers or something — to test this hypothesis. And then we can find that we're totally goddamn wrong. To the absolute limit of our ability to measure it — and our ability to measure it is really good, since we used electromagnets and lasers and other expensive science things — when an object is dropped, it begins falling instantaneously. Not after a very small interval of time, but absolutely instantaneously. As in zero time elapses between dropping and falling. This is fairly earthshaking, really. Because it implies that somehow a "signal" of some kind is getting from the ground to Wile E. faster than the speed of light. Which is supposed to be impossible. I'm going to skip ahead a bit here, because I don't feel like explaining the entire theory of general relativity, and it won't be that useful in answering the question anyway. Suffice to say that no, no time elapses between dropping and falling, but at the same time no, no signal or interaction has to propagate upward from the ground to Wile E. in order to make him start falling. In fact, what's going on is that Wile E. is always falling, due to the curvature of spacetime created by the Earth. Whenever he's standing at the edge of the cliff, on the ground, the ground beneath his feet — paws? — is arresting his fall by, effectively, pushing up against him. The very instant that's removed, he starts falling. So in that sense, gravity has no speed. Because it doesn't actually propagate through space. One way to look at it is to say the gravitational field fills space, so wherever you are, you're already being affected by it all the time. Another way is to say that gravitational essentially is space, so it affects you simply by virtue of existing. The two are essentially equivalent English translations of the equations that actually describe the phenomenon. But okay, that's half the problem. The gravity of a static body fills space, or is space, and as such can't be meaningfully said to have a speed. But what about the gravity of a changing body? Like you said, what if "suddenly a black hole appeared?" Well, the answer of course is that that never happens, ever. Gravitation doesn't suddenly anything; macroscopic things don't just appear out of nowhere, and teleportation is impossible. So we don't have to think about that … and in fact we couldn't get meaningful answers if we tried. But things do move. The moon's moving relative to the surface of the Earth; we can tell, even apart from the fact that we can see it up there, because the moon is the major contributor to the tides, and the tides rise and fall. But what's the relationship between the moon's position in space and the tidal acceleration on the Earth? Are the two somehow always in perfect sync, or is there some lag? If so, how much, and in what direction? That's actually a much harder question to answer than you might think. There was a now-infamous paper some years ago by a fellow named Tom Van Flandern (recently passed, God rest his soul) that asserted that the change in gravitational acceleration in a dynamical system actually propagates many times faster than the speed of light — at least twenty billion times faster than the speed of light — but not instantaneously. This got a lot of attention at the time. If the propagation speed of changes in spacetime geometry were equal to the speed of light, that'd be fine. If it were literally instantaneous, that'd also be fine, more or less, though our theory would need some tweaking. But faster than c but still finite? That was really hard to explain. It turned out not to be a problem though. Because Van Flandern just made a mistake in his paper. See, the relationship between motion and gravitation is not as straightforward as it might seem. In fact — and I'm glossing over this now, because the maths are damn complicated — whenever a gravitating object moves inertially, the gravitational acceleration vector at a point removed actually points at where the object actually is at a given instant, as opposed to where the object's light is seen to be coming from at that instant. So in that sense, we're back to gravitation being instantaneous again! But is it really? No. Because you see, if the inertially moving object were to come to a stop instantaneously, the acceleration vector would continue to point toward its future position for a time, as if it were still moving inertially, even though the object is actually somewhere else. The sum of effects that serve to cancel out aberration when everything moves inertially would break down, and the acceleration field would point toward empty space for however long it takes for the change in geometry to propagate through space at the speed of light from the gravitating object to the point in question. Except things don't stop moving instantaneously. Things accelerate, and acceleration requires energy, and when you factor that in, the equations balance out again. (If you feel up to the challenging of following a lot of advanced mathematics, here's the best paper I know on the subject.) - http://arxiv.org/pdf/gr-qc/9909087v2.pdf http://arxiv.org/pdf/gr-qc/9909087v2.pdf So what does that mean? It means that the "speed of gravity" is the speed of light … technically. Changes in the geometry of spacetime actually propagate at the speed of light, but the apparent effects of gravitation end up being instantaneous in all real-world dynamical systems, because things don't start or stop moving or gain or lose mass instantaneously for no reason. Once you factor in everything you need to in order to model a real system behaving in a realistic manner, you find that all the aberrations you might expect because of a finite speed of light end up canceling out, so gravity acts like it's instantaneous, even though the underlying phenomenon is most definitely not. The universe is pretty damn cool, if you ask me.
- ars 13y agoHere's another way to understand it. The difficultly: Despite the propagation delay, gravity always points to where the object should be, instead of where it was when the gravity was "emitted". The explanation: Just like the object itself is moving, the gravitational field (or electric/magnetic field) is ALSO moving! It moves at exactly the same speed, and in the same direction as the object which created it. It's "disconnected" from the source - so if the source suddenly changes direction the field it emitted doesn't know about it, and continues to point to where it expected the object to be. More technical: Why wormholes are impossible, and why you can not create a single magnetic monopoles: What about conservation of momentum? If an object is pulled to where the other object is expected to be, not where it is, then momentum exchange between the two of them would seem to not add up! But it works because you can never create a gravitational or electric field from nothing. You can only move them around, so the momentum always catches up. What about a magnetic field? You can create those from nothing - ah, but you can only create magnetic dipoles, with opposing fields, so again it works. But, you can never create a magnetic monopole because you would suddenly have a magnetic "charge" where none existed before and the momentum would not add up. What you can do is create two monopoles, of opposite poles. (So this implies a conservation of magnetic pole, just like conservation of electric charge - assuming monopoles exist.) What about wormholes? They have the same momentum problem - an object suddenly appears where none was before and it pulls on other objects. You could then move it away before it gets pulled in turn by those objects, and that would violate conservation of momentum. So you can't do that. And, faster than light objects would have the exact same problem - they could move out of the area before they properly shared the momentum. So I suspect they can't exist either. (Unless there is some complicated math I didn't think of which "fixes" it.)
- Ygg2 13y agoWait, haven't they proven that you can make magnetic monopoles and that wormholes are still a possibility?
- gliese1337 13y agoIt is a prediction of some physical theories that magnetic monopoles could exist from the origin of the universe (and it kinda seems like they should, 'cause other than the existence of one kind of charge and the other, there's no good reason to see either half of electromagnetism as more fundamental than the other- both kinds of field can generate the other, and how much of each one you think you have depends on your inertial frame since they're relativistic transformations of each other), but no one has shown that you can make them, pulling the poles of a magnet apart like you can pull electrons away from protons.
- yeureka 13y agoI always wondered about this. If changes in gravity propagated faster than light, could you build a transmitter by modulating a gravity field by colliding matter with anti-matter?
- jswhitten 13y agoHow would that modulate a gravity field? If you're thinking that the matter and antimatter have gravity and that gravity disappears when they annihilate because their mass is gone, that's not the case. All energy and momentum produces gravity, not just mass.
- stcredzero 13y agoYou could only modulate gravity as fast as you could move energy close to you or far away from you. An implausibly powerful gamma ray flashlight flicking on and off would let you do this. Get the beam powerful enough, and it will have a gravitational field.
- gliese1337 13y agoGet the beam powerful enough and it will have meaurable gravitational field. All beams of any intensity technically do contribute some, albeit infinitesimal, component to the gravitational field. It's a fun exercise to calculate just how strong a laser beam you'd need to have to make a black hole entirely out of photons.
- stcredzero 13y agoA black hole can actually cause an additional singularity due to the blueshifting of infalling light. IIRC, one researcher studied this phenomenon and called it a "blue sheet."
- nkuttler 13y agoThere was this one russian http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugene_Podkletnov#Podkletnov.27s_gravity_shielding_experiments http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugene_Podkletnov#Podkletnov.27..., but nobody has yet managed to replicate his results.
- spenrose 13y agoSo I think this article says: - the earth revolves around where the sun is almost precisely and rules out: - the earth revolves around where the sun was ~8 minutes ago (where 8 minutes is about the travel time at c). Can anyone confirm?
- vehementi 13y agoYeah that's what it's saying. But it's not saying we get updates as to where the sun is instantly due to FTL gravity. It's saying objects rotate around a projection. If the linear path of the sun were to change, those changes would take a while to get to us to update our path, but also due to how that can't "just happen", things don't end up getting messed up.
- ajuc 13y agoBut isn't sun rotating around galaxy center? So the velocity of sun isn't line, but an orbit, so it isn't constant (it's always changing direction), and we (Earth) do orbit the place that sun would be if not for the acceleration of sun caused by combined gravity of galaxy?
- ck2 13y agoGravity is a "well" in space-time itself, it's not a wave you can benchmark? That is why it can be "faster than light" when it's not faster at all, it's just changing the path of light.
- juliangamble 13y agoIn general relativity gravity propagates at c. The rate of orbital decay of binary pulsars is, among other factors, dependent on the speed of gravity. The in-spiral rate of one binary pulsar system has been measured and found to agree with the rate predicted by general relativity to within a 0.2% margin of error. Gravitational waves haven't been directly measured yet though, so there's no direct confirmation. With multiple detectors currently in operation if a signal is detected and able to be tied to a specific location in space the timing delays between when its received between the two primary LIGO detectors (Livingston, LA, USA and Hanford, WA, USA) and the VIRGO detector (PISA Italy) should allow for estimating a propagation speed. Advanced LIGO, expected to begin collecting data in 2014 is expected to be able to detect a number of signals so hopefully the question will be settled in a few years. However, there might not be any published results for a while after it goes active. The search for pulsar spindown signals with LIGO data is done via the Einstien@Home distributed computing project; and in prior runs several years passed between when the first part of the data set was collected and when papers on it were finally published. http://physics.stackexchange.com/a/26743/9521 http://physics.stackexchange.com/a/26743/9521
- RuggeroAltair 13y agoSteve Carlip used to be my advisor in grad school and his style of writing conveys completely his beautiful way of explaining (and thinking about) deep questions in physics. One think that I believe is important to point out is that this short essay is focusing on the experimental aspect of the measurement of the speed of gravity. It gives an explanation on why this is even an intelligent question to answer and why the answer we commonly accept is that gravity moves at the speed of light. I will never have better words than him so I won't add anything to what he said. What I would like to point out, based on some comments I read here, is that this essay is not talking about whether or not theoretically would be possible to have a speed of gravity faster than the speed of light. General relativity and special relativity have been tested on several aspects, and they pretty much are in agreement with all experimental constraint. There is no other theory that can explain everything we see (some theories tend to explain a few things, but not all of them, or they are too vague). A theory in which the speed of gravity is faster than the speed of light isn't unconceivable per se, but no one has been able to write a completely consistent one yet, mostly because it would have large consequences on what special and general relativity imply for cosmology and particle physics (and causality). If gravity moved faster than the speed of light then we'd have to 'fix' a lot of problems coming down to paradoxes and stuff like that. So take this essay as a way to appreciate how elegant and fine some experimental questions on gravity (and physics) are.
- jheriko 13y agoc is a conversion factor between space and time coordinates when we project them into a space that we can intuitively grasp. the obsession with the 'speed of light' always seems a bit senseless in this context - its taking a concept which is known to break down in some limit and then applying it right at that limit. this is bound to be confusing. really the speed of light is like infinity in the geometry of our universe... it just happens unfortunately that the geometry is not as simple as an infinite euclidean space with an independent time coordinate so we end up attributing a bad interpretation to the 'speed' of light.