5 ms·
US doesn't know what Snowden took, sources say
- ohwp 13y agoIf they didn't know they wouldn't destroy Guardians' hard disks but would take them with them to check out the data.
- sp332 13y agoI thought the Guardian destroyed their own hard drives, to prevent them from being taken?
- ohwp 13y agohttp://ca.news.yahoo.com/britain-forced-guardian-destroy-copy-snowden-material-222933670.html http://ca.news.yahoo.com/britain-forced-guardian-destroy-cop...
- sp332 13y agoThat's not what the Guardian says happened. "But once it was obvious that they would be going to law I preferred to destroy our copy rather than hand it back to them or allow the courts to freeze our reporting." http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/aug/20/nsa-snowden-files-drives-destroyed-london http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/aug/20/nsa-snowden-fil... Discussion https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6245419 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6245419
- coldcode 13y agoIf they don't audit what people have access to, who knows what those people are doing with it. That's even scarier than the NSA recording everything, that their employees and contractors can do whatever they want with the info.
- sp332 13y agoI think they know Snowden accessed a lot of stuff, but they don't know what subset of it he took.
- rdtsc 13y agoBut who audits those who set up audit systems? Presumably he was one of the "system administrators" from what I understand. I guess they haven't solved the problem technically yet as they have instituted "no lone zones" policy. They'll just have everyone work with an accountabil-a-buddy.
- 616c 13y agoIf it was one of the standard Windows file servers, and not a SMB/CIFS appliance, the audit controls are very-detailed and fine-grained from 7/2008 up. Previous audit controls were so. You need to modify which ones you want logged, and then you would need some central sink to log all the Event Log events on all the servers, and review those of interest. I have never worked in an area with that level of paranoia. However, if NSA contractors are put under the same Federal Desktop Core Configuration requirements [0] at a minimum, I would imagine the client and/or server (if he was required to use Windows) are known, or the NSA contractors are not in compliance. What they do with that information is another story. That said, any admin could change local policy settings, reboot with the computer, and reconnect it to the domain later. I got clever with such things to disable security policies like those when troubleshooting lab computers. We shall never know how smart/dumb Snowden was and they were. [0] http://usgcb.nist.gov/usgcb/microsoft_content.html http://usgcb.nist.gov/usgcb/microsoft_content.html
- lambda 13y agoRemember, there is a difference between not auditing access to their internal fileservers that they keep their PowerPoints on, and not auditing access to their wiretap data. Now, a big concern is that even if they do audit access to the wiretap data, there are still too many people who have "legitimate" access to it, and it is still hard to prevent a rogue sysadmin or programmer from bypassing those controls. Merely having all of that data makes it a high value target for attack.
- skue 13y ago> Another [official] said that the NSA has a poor audit capability, which is frustrating efforts to complete a damage assessment. Wow. The NSA spent untold billions building advanced tech to snoop others but never bothered to set up proper internal controls for their own systems? Of course this also raises the question, how can they continue to insist that there are reasonable controls in place to prevent abuse when they can't even determine what Snowden accessed, after he collected thousands of documents over a span of years?
- desbest 13y agoIf you can read something, you can copy it.
- tytso 13y agoSure, but why isn't all data encrypted at rest? And access to the keys heavily logged? There are ways to allow sysadmins access to backup, and repair file systems, and yet still not have any access to the (plaintext) data stored on those systems. Sure, eventually the key server (whether it's Kerberos style or X509 certificate style) is going to be something where a single trusted individual can do great harm (if by no other means than by checking in some obfuscated code that introduces a bug that releases keys, and then gets this past the code review process). But you can limit the damage that can be done by "thousands of sysadmins". It sounds like there are cloud services providers that are doing a better job at this today than the NSA. And we're supposed to trust them with their audit controls? P.S. My undergraduate thesis in 1990 designed a symmetric key system that would allow data at rest to be encrypted, such that access could be controlled (and logged) via single key server system in which you invested all of your trust. This is not rocket science...
- mjn 13y agoThey do put some effort into internal controls, e.g. SELinux came from the NSA originally. But apparently not enough!
- eli 13y ago
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- timdiggerm 13y ago>By using a “thin client” computer he remotely accessed the NSA data from his base in Hawaii. Oh no, not a "thin clinet"!!!
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- contingencies 13y agoI think Hollywood would do it more like this: "Set the Command and control server to engineer a virus to backdoor the system return code with a thin client." "... oh no, not a thin client!"
- Keyframe 13y agoIt baffles me how poor PR damage control there is from NSA/government. All they had to say was something along the lines "yeah, some of it is true, but we can't comment any further", same with wikileaks leaks. "some", and you can't be sure anymore what's true and what isn't from that source and end of story, only speculations.
- alan_cx 13y agoSo, they don't know if anyone else has take anything either? Snowden could in fact merely be the one they know about. And on the face of it, Snowden has risked everything to let the world know whats going on, an act of human patriotism, where as others unknown may well just sell the data to actual enemies. Maybe Snowden's error is doing the right thing as opposed to making a few Renminbi.