4 ms·
The fifth amendment was only ever intended to be dealing with testimony - you couldn't be called as a witness against yourself (the history of why it exists mak
by DannyBee 13y ago
The fifth amendment was only ever intended to be dealing with testimony - you couldn't be called as a witness against yourself (the history of why it exists makes this clear). That is, you literally can not be asked to testify against yourself, in a custodial interrogation, court, or other setting where it could be used as evidence against you in a criminal trial.
It was never intended to prevent evidence you were stupid enough to write down from being used against you.
So basically, "insane or not", the fifth was clearly not intended for this purpose, despite your attempt to view this as "an extension of yourself".
- cgshaw 13y agoAttorney here. DannyBee is absolutely correct. To my knowledge, data on a computer would be handled like an offender's diary, and that is certainly admissible in court, assuming authentication that the diary was actually written by the offender. Data is interesting because authentication can arguable be harder to prove. (handwriting is pretty easy to attribute) The truth is, the founding fathers likely could not have imagined in their wildest dreams that we could have all of human history on a flash drive with us at all times. Trying to apply "how they would have thought" or "WWFFD" to every new technology is kind of insane.
- DannyBee 13y ago>Attorney here. So am I, though not a criminal one :) >The truth is, the founding fathers likely could not have imagined in their wildest dreams that we could have all of human history on a flash drive with us at all times. Trying to apply "how they would have thought" or "WWFFD" to every new technology is kind of insane. While entirely true, i think, given the history around the fifth amendment, it would be quite a stretch anyway.
- cgshaw 13y agoSweet. I had to jump off last night, but I did some criminal appointments in both federal and state court to get some courtroom experience while fresh out of law school. Certainly not an expert, but capable of having a fairly deep discussion on search & seizure. I completely agree with what you wrote above about how just because folks like you or I say "oh, this is/isn't legal" doesn't mean we agree with it.
- mikhael 13y agoI read GauntletWizard's point as that such devices are becoming like "brain prostheses." If the device were embedded in your skull/brain, but could be wiretapped, would it be subject to the fifth amendment? If technology develops to read information from another's brain without their consent, would that be subject to the fifth amendment?
- DannyBee 13y agoAn interesting question. Again, the main historical reason for the fifth amendment was torture, not to avoid knowing the truth, or that you were somehow magically sacred. If you could read it out of people's brains, harmlessly, painlessly, etc, i think that would be fine. Now remember, the fifth amendment protections apply in custodial settings (and similar), so you would already have to have been arrested/etc at this point (IE probable cause would have existed). In that situation, if i could read your brain to get the truth, harmlessly, and painlessly, I have trouble seeing how that would be against the reason the fifth amendment was created (now, it may arguably run afoul of the fifth amendment as written, though things like blood tests, etc, are not considered testimonial. I don't believe literal memories would be either)
- nitrogen 13y agoIf you could read it out of people's brains, harmlessly, painlessly, etc, i think that would be fine. I must state that this sentiment sickens me slightly. I sincerely hope that this interpretation is absolutely unthinkable by the time technology reaches that point. I don't believe that any world in which one's thoughts and memories are not private can ever be free.
- DannyBee 13y agoSorry, I should have been clear: I meant fine legally, in the context of the fifth amendment. It is not a statement of what I believe the social view/norm/etc should be, or whether it should be allowed. Only an objective assessment of whether it would fall within the context of what was currently protected and the intent of protecting that. Personally, I would find it abhorrent, but that is not particularly relevant to the law.
- samstave 13y agoQuestion: Assume the year is 1790. DannyBee and PG are having a conversation in a sewer beneath Boston. DannyBee tells PG that he is going to rob the town bank and set it afire. This was a verbal communication between the two. There was a USG agent around the corner in another tunnel. He heard an echo of the two talking. This is the only evidence of the two communicating about the matter. How is this prosecuted? (please forgive the weak analogy - and improve if you can... but please tell me the 1790 equiv argument for what we are dealing with where the snooping is either protected or denied)
- edanm 13y agoCould you explain the history of the 5th ammendmment in this context? I understand from some light Wikipedia reading that it was originally around mostly to prevent tortured confessions. Why is it still relevant at all?
- flagnog 13y agoummm, waterboarding?
- linuxhansl 13y agoAt least that means that I would not need to help them searching my phone. Is that correct? My phone needs a pass code to allow any interaction and I could conceivably encrypt data on it. What if I get arrested, but on grounds of the 4th amendment won't reveal the pass code? Oops. Meant to reply to cgshaw, the child comment.
- DannyBee 13y ago"At least that means that I would not need to help them searching my phone. Is that correct? " This varies right now. Essentially, it depends on whether your giving the password would tell them something they can't otherwise prove, and that thing is testimonial in nature: That you maintain ownership of the item, etc. Basically, if they can authenticate the existence of what information is on the phone, and can authenticate your ownership, you may very well be compelled to give the password. That said, they are very fact specific inquiries, and, AFAIK, the world is still up in the air here. See U.S. v. Boucher, United States v. Fricosu, United States v. Kirschner, etc.