5 ms·
It's the Alcubierre drive. First paper on the idea was published in 1994, and everybody seems to think it's legit according to relativity, though with large pra
by DennisP 13y ago
It's the Alcubierre drive. First paper on the idea was published in 1994, and everybody seems to think it's legit according to relativity, though with large practical difficulties. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alcubierre_drive http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alcubierre_drive
- Steuard 13y agoLarge theoretical difficulties, too! To the best of my knowledge, nobody has ever been able to write down a complete mathematical description where an Alcubierre bubble "turns on" or "turns off": instead, the math always seems to describe a scenario where the warp bubble exists (and is inaccessible from the outside) into the infinite past and infinite future. Also, all versions of Alcubierre's model that I am familiar with require forms of matter and energy with properties completely different from anything ever observed (and different from most mainstream ideas for possible new types of matter and energy as well): namely, they require violations of various "energy conditions". http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_condition http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_condition The vast practical difficulties are in addition to the enormous theoretical challenges. I would absolutely love it if something like the Alcubierre drive could be made real, but there are multiple steps between here and there that would each deserve a Nobel prize. If I were White, I'd be talking about how I'd solved all of those problems (or any of them!) before jumping straight to trying to generate a warp bubble in the lab.
- EthanHeilman 13y ago>If I were White, I'd be talking about how I'd solved all of those problems (or any of them!) before jumping straight to trying to generate a warp bubble in the lab. Why not try to generate a bubble, if it works great, otherwise try formalize it in greater detail. If warp bubbles are possible than it may be that they are already being created through random chance at the micro-level in the natural world.
- VLM 13y ago"Why not try to generate a bubble," Missing the part from the paragraph about having no idea how to generate that condition, although if it existed in the past it would presumably be "sorta stable" in fact it would never be able to shut off as presently understood. A good analogy would be trying to talk to the original Lada Ada about silicon based computers without the folks of that era knowing enough solid state physics to contemplate whats going on in a simple transistor. "So if you could magically understand how to create a transistor, which won't happen for a century, then logically it follows that such and such array of those magic devices would make a great full adder circuit to add binary numbers"
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- tekacs 13y agocf. Shor's algorithm in that: this could at least be useful busywork/speculative preparation?
- Someone 13y agoSo what? Half of number theory (I don't know enough of it to say whether that _is_ an exaggeration) does right that: "If the generalized Riemann hypothesis is true, ..."
- VLM 13y agoIts a more fundamental problem. Like "Wouldn't it be cool to be able to multiply. At least for reasonable small integers, if you could add, which you can't at this time, then you could multiply simply by repeated addition. But, of course, you can't add, so ...".
- DennisP 13y agoI just meant that the basic idea doesn't violate general relativity. Your link mentions that negative energy density has been observed at very small scale as a result of the Casimir effect. It's difficult to see how that could be scaled up, but I suspect that's what White is using here.
- joe_the_user 13y ago"...some physicists have presented arguments to suggest that a theory of quantum gravity which merged the two theories would eliminate those solutions in general relativity which allow for backwards time travel (see the chronology protection conjecture), of which the Alcubierre drive is one" [emphasis added] (wikipedia)
- DennisP 13y agoThat's one possibility. Another is that time travel is fine, and never results in paradoxes: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Novikov_self-consistency_principle http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Novikov_self-consistency_princi... The thought experiment: imagine a billiard table with a wormhole which curves around and goes three seconds into the past. Roll a billiard ball into the wormhole such that it will emerge three seconds earlier and knock itself off the path, so it doesn't enter the wormhole. Instead, the ball emerges along a slightly different path, striking itself merely a glancing blow that allows it to enter the wormhole. And why did it emerge with an altered path? Because it was struck a glancing blow.
- Gravityloss 13y agoThat's a brilliant explanation by example.
- joe_the_user 13y agoInteresting discussion. I can only imagine this kind of thing happening in a reversible, constant entropy system and a system without intentional processes. For example, imagine a programmable drone. It is programmed to enter the singularity if and only if nothing seems to emerge and to then avoid collision with anything once it emerges - and transmit a signal announcing it's emergence to boot. Maybe you could do setup a fancy scenario for not winding up with two (or no) drones at the "end". But things not longer seem very plausible. And you could probably arrange for a thing to carry entropy backwards if you had a varying entropy a system. But that's left as an "exercise for the reader".
- icambron 13y agoI get why the glancing blow is a "stable" solution, but I don't understand what stops me from aiming the ball so that it hits dead on...