9 ms·
Meet the NASA scientist devising a starship warp drive
- nickff 13y agoI am often distressed by the time, energy, and resources people consume in an attempt to escape reality (i.e. video games, films, alcohol, and drugs). Reading about endeavors like this renews my optimism for the future.
- Swannie 13y ago''escape reality (i.e. video games, films, alcohol, and drugs'' ...TV, YouTube, Hacker News, works of fiction...
- eksith 13y agoYou shouldn't poo-poo escapism wholesale. Granted, the vast majority of them are used for complete non-productive rubbish, but recreation and inspiration can go hand-in-hand. After all, film and video games (and, of course, the TV series that came before) were the inspiration for this as well, no?
- andrewflnr 13y agoThey're not poo-pooing it wholesale. Recreation has its place, but some people clearly go too far and spend too much time on it. That's what GP is worried about.
- vosper 13y agoPeople need a break, and video games, films, alcohol and drugs can provide those (just like hiking, gardening, and photography). There's nothing like a bit of downtime to let your mind turn things over in the background. And with regard to film, alcohol, and drugs specifically - these can all be tools to gain a different perspective on reality, they're not necessarily mindless escapism.
- nickff 13y agoI partially agree with you, especially in the case of documentary films; and would further add that books (of literature, fiction, and non-fiction), plays, and operas are very powerful tools for understanding the world. From what I can see, these tools are generally not being used to help people "gain a different perspective on reality", as large portions of the populace do not read a book, or try to understand what any character in fiction is experiencing. As to the drugs and alcohol, I need not point out that stumbling masses of people in the streets after midnight is more indicative of their use as a soma rather than an instrument of introspection.
- solistice 13y agoDrugs can be used as a tool for introspection (psychoactive drugs for example. They can also be used as a means to counter the stress coming from other areas in life, if they are used with care (alcohol, nicotine, cannabis, maybe even cocaine, which is pushing it). And then there's the variety that acts like shocking your pleasure centrum (meth, crack, and various other hard hard drugs). Aside from the third case, I'd argue against drugs being a waste of time. Unless you abuse them, they can actually increase your quality of life.
- DanielStraight 13y agoFor another take of video games, I recommend this TED talk: http://www.ted.com/talks/jane_mcgonigal_the_game_that_can_give_you_10_extra_years_of_life.html http://www.ted.com/talks/jane_mcgonigal_the_game_that_can_gi...
- ohyes 13y agoI take issue with video games and film being a waste. The entire idea of a warp-drive comes from science fiction and people daydreaming/trying to escape their current reality. The Hyperloop is directly out of Heinlein. Subterranean cannons on the moon as a public transport device... Without escapism we lose the essence of human creativity, imagining a future that is different from the present. Do you think we would have bothered to build rockets and go to space/the moon if science fiction hadn't whetted the public's curiosity? If anything, the problem is that current escapism kind of sucks and we need to do it better. edit:lose/loose
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Jach 13y agoWell, a lot of people still consider the whole notion of trying to warp space to get around the lightspeed issue as nothing more than an attempt at escaping reality. ;) Also some people really like doing math as much as other people like watching Game of Thrones.
- superuser2 13y agoOne of my favorite points from Ira Glass's lecture: Ideas come from other ideas. There is no such thing as creativity in a vacuum. Your output of ideas is related to the quantity and quality of information you take in. HN is a good bit better for that than reality TV, but not all resource consumption is bad. This endeavor in particular smells of a fairly cheesy "waste of time" low-budget, low-brow television show.
- deerpig 13y agoBut the question remains. How did he drop the energy requirements by orders of magnitude, and from my fuzzy memory of such things, would that even be enough to make a warp drive practical? If he's right, it would be at least, a step in the right direction....
- mjfl 13y agoHe is only testing the ability to warp space. The setup is extremely simple actually. All he is doing is splitting a laser, one part goes through an extremely charged toroidal capacitor and the other goes through nothing. If the path lengths of these two lasers are the same, but the interferometer reads that the lasers are out of phase, then you have possible warping of space. Most of the cost is probably in the high-precision interferometer.
- tiglionabbit 13y agoIf you notice a discrepancy, isn't it more likely that one laser was "slowed down", rather than sped up? You'd get the same effect by shining the laser through a thick pane of glass: it arrives out of phase on the other end as if it were slowed down.
- mjfl 13y agoAssuming this experiment is done in a vacuum, I've never heard of a static electric field changing the index of refraction of a vacuum.
- larrydag 13y agoApparently the toroidal ring has some property that allows it to reduce the energy requirements. "and in particular a ring around it that is key to its propulsion system — in a way that he believes will greatly reduce the energy requirements" http://www.nytimes.com/2013/07/23/science/faster-than-the-speed-of-light.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2013/07/23/science/faster-than-the-sp...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- portmanteaufu 13y agoI would love it if there were a straightforward way to donate money directly to NASA. I'd happily fund an indiegogo project for warp systems.
- DennisP 13y agoThis is just indirectly related to space travel, but there will probably be an indiegogo project for aneutronic fusion in the near future: http://lawrencevilleplasmaphysics.com/index.php?option=com_lyftenbloggie&view=entry&year=2013&month=08&day=07&id=100%3Aplanning-for-crowdfunding-campaign-underway&Itemid=90 http://lawrencevilleplasmaphysics.com/index.php?option=com_l...
- dnautics 13y agowow, that's simply amazing. One thing I can't find though, is: Who will own the patents?
- damian2000 13y agoIs this anything like cold fusion?
- DennisP 13y agoQuite the opposite, it's extremely hot. They got a paper published in Physics of Plasmas saying they'd reached temperatures of 1.8 billion degrees C. That's hot enough to fuse boron-11 with hydrogen. You end up with three helium nuclei and some x-rays. There are several attempts underway, though the one I linked above is the cheapest and apparently the furthest along. I wrote up some descriptions with references here: http://www.climatecolab.org/web/guest/plans/-/plans/contestId/10/planId/1304006 http://www.climatecolab.org/web/guest/plans/-/plans/contestI...
- mathattack 13y agoSounds like they need funding for 100 years. That's a lot of money! It's actually basic science like this that I think is a defensible form of public research spending.
- tocomment 13y agoDoes anyone know how they will test it in the lab? I thought we haven't discovered negative matter yet?
- jared314 13y agoThe White–Juday warp-field interferometer http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White%E2%80%93Juday_warp-field_interferometer http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White%E2%80%93Juday_warp-field_...
- tocomment 13y agoBut how can a charged capacitor warp space? I thought only matter could warp space?
- lcampbell 13y agoI don't understand physics to any degree, but I was under the assumption that EM fields also warped space (albeit orders of magnitude less). I found some explanations that are way above my head on Quora: [1] http://www.quora.com/Physics/Can-a-large-energy-field-other-than-gravity-warp-spacetime/answer/Tu-Anh-Tran http://www.quora.com/Physics/Can-a-large-energy-field-other-... [2] http://www.quora.com/Physics/Can-a-large-energy-field-other-than-gravity-warp-spacetime/answer/Frank-Heile http://www.quora.com/Physics/Can-a-large-energy-field-other-... The second seems to suggest that energy fields, in general, do warp space.
- robertfw 13y agoconsidering e=mc2, it's not surprising that matter and energy can both accomplish the same thing - they are the same thing
- ars 13y agoNot matter. Energy. Energy warps space. Matter is just a kind of energy. But all energy warps space, and has a gravitational field.
- dandrews 13y agoHe mentions the 100YSS Symposium, which was conveniently held in my neck of the woods in 2011. It was exciting to be among a couple hundred smarter-than-average people who wouldn't so much as crack a smile when the word "starship" came up in conversation. Outside-the-box ideas, lessons taken from ISS, Orion, nuclear propulsion, radiation shielding, social engineering, violation of the 2nd Law, other cool stuff. It was a brainstorming excuse, and an opportunity to dream big. If you live near Houston, and you'd care to rub shoulders with some not-stupids who think seriously about this stuff, you might check this out. http://100yss.org/symposium/2013 http://100yss.org/symposium/2013
- mapt 13y agoSpace exploration is not handicapped by technology, but by societal willpower in the absence of an existential crisis like the Cold War. The Alcubierre Drive is fine as a theoretically impossible physics plaything, but the expansion of the species beyond the Earth only requires funding to achieve using much more modest means. For every one space science mission that goes forward, our academic system produces 500 concepts that are judged too impractical or too expensive, and 50 that arrive at group consensus that it would be productive to move forward and submit proposals. 5 of them get funded into fully developed systems, and 4 are cancelled just shy of completion through because the JWST has cost overruns or the new Majority Leader / President wants to make his mark with an arbitrary decision like cancelling the 6 year old 20-year-plan for a Mars base in exchange for a 20-year-plan for a Moon base (that will be cancelled in six years). The path is there, the end discoveries (relative to many other fields) relatively certain, we just don't like to make the effort in any concerted way, and our government is broken; Congress would prefer it if they could just run NASA on a soundstage.
- simonh 13y agoI do agree with your overall premise, but societal willpower in this case is really just a proxy for cost. Space exploration is fantastically expensive. Of course it doesn't help that the Space Shuttle and therefore the ISS were hopelessly cost inefficient, but even without the shuttle tax space exploration is still very costly. This is why SpaceX's plans for substantially reusable launch vehicles is so exciting. They have a credible roadmap towards cutting launch costs by a factor of ten or more. We're in one of those situations where yes, we could spend more billions on space exploration right now, but there's a very real chance that if we maintain current space spending for just a few years those extra billions could buy us a huge amount more. I bet projects like the planned asteroid mining venture are watching SpaceX's technology development program with bated breath.
- leokun 13y agoWouldn't an Alcubierre drive just always take you into the past? If you leave Earth using this drive and get to some distant star at FTL using this mechanism, maybe you escape relativistic effects, but you'll still get there before light from our star arrives there. And then when you go back wouldn't you arrive before the light left? It doesn't seem to make sense to me. Maybe someone can explain away my misconception about how that works?
- crayola 13y agoThe light doesn't go back.
- leokun 13y agoI don't see anywhere in my post where I suggest that it did. I think though you could use this device to at least outrun light and then use a telescope to look into the past.
- crayola 13y agoI mean – unless you have in mind some complicated relativistic effect, in which case my answer may be a bit naive, it feels a bit like you are overlooking the fact that, as you go back, you will kind of receive double your share of photons from the planet and play fast-forward on everything you missed on your way out. As I said, I suspect this is not how it would end up happening, as I remember reading somewhere some weird stuff about how the speed of photons hitting you was always the same regardless of your speed.. But that gets too weird for me to comprehend.
- mratzloff 13y agoSay we are having a swimming race and both leave the same starting side at the same moment. I get to the other side of the pool and return to the starting position before you reach the opposite side of the pool. Just because I lap you doesn't mean I travel back in time.
- 13y ago
- mathattack 13y agoAt first I thought he would be a quack, but his technical credential look legit. http://www.icarusinterstellar.org/team/harold-white/ http://www.icarusinterstellar.org/team/harold-white/ I just wish he would explain a little better why this was an allowable violation of relativity.
- Tloewald 13y agoI think the problem with the warp drive is topological. His drive relies on expanding space behind you and contracting it in front. OK. But what happens when you turn the drive off? Assuming all this squashing and stretching doesn't involve discontinuities, at best you're back where you're started from. At worst, you're in some kind of weird messed up crappy nook in spacetime where you're a long way from your starting point and your destination.
- zeckalpha 13y agoSo it's more of an improbability drive?
- themstheones 13y agoYes, of the infinite variety.
- Tloewald 13y agoOr infinitely ;-) But, hey, I'd love to be wrong.
- mistermcgruff 13y agoMy understanding is that using a substance called "spice gas" you're able to enable this drive through a process called "folding."
- textminer 13y agoHN-as-a-hivemind really should approve of this sort of snark. It's nerd-snark!
- tiglionabbit 13y agoHow do we get this "negative vacuum energy" stuff?
- Steuard 13y agoWhite claims to have calculated a way to substantially reduce the energy requirements to form a warp bubble, and without reading his papers I suppose I should provisionally believe him. But the required energy has to be negative (as he confirms here), and I have never, ever seen him or anyone else suggest how he plans to accomplish that. Negative vacuum energies like what he's relying on have never been observed in the universe (directly or indirectly), and would violate a number of "energy conditions" commonly believed to hold for realistic matter. It would be very exciting if those energy conditions really were violated, but it's an extraordinary claim that backed by zero evidence. With that in mind, I continue to be puzzled by the amount of press that this story seems to receive.
- chunky1994 13y agoAs far as I know, negative energy is theoretically still sound; I may be quite mistaken though. What "energy conditions" would negative energy (or mass for that matter) be violating?
- solistice 13y agoNegative refraction is just as strange a concept, and we seem to be slowly getting there technologically. So I'm actually hopeful this will happen someday.
- VLM 13y agoUnfortunately negative refraction a secondary effect where you have negative permittivity and permeability at the same time. Negative permittivity is no big deal, metals act like an electron plasma gas around certain frequencies and get all weird, something like the color transmitted thru thin films of gold and how weird gold, silver, copper act in the THz range and all that. The "magic" is creatively negating both .. At The Same Time. Then the negative refraction / metamaterial effects take hold. Kind of like you can compress ammonia (a bit) and nothing terribly interesting happens, and you can cool ammonia gas (a bit) and nothing terribly interesting happens, but do both at the same time and you've invented liquid ammonia and refrigeration and all kinds of nifty stuff. On the other hand energy/mass seems rather fundamental. There are no multiple "easily" negatable components you can play with mixing together. There's no "add a to b to get the mass" going on. So you can't get sneaky with combinations and initial conditions to magically make negative mass/energy. It's really a different kind of problem. The whole topic is pretty interesting to me because the first metamaterial stuff was constructed out of printed circuit boards with weird etchings right around the ham radio microwave 6cm and 9cm bands, which is right up my alley (doing weird ham radio things involving PCBs and such around those frequencies) Unfortunately I have been unable to figure out any practical engineering demo (like, an antenna or a waveguide or some such) that would be ham radio applicable in a real world demonstration. I guess I could make a really weird lens and place it in front of a 6cm horn waveguide antenna, but I can make a much simpler microwave lens antenna using about 1940s tech. Lens antennas using plates of styrofoam and aluminum foil work pretty well at 10 GHz ham radio band for example, but I digress. Metamaterials are kind of a solution in search of a problem right now, like lasers in 1960s or home computers in the 80s or whatever. Most likely, much like the examples, it would be pretty hard to predict today just how important they might be in the future. Or maybe we're seeing the next "magnetic bubble memory" or magnetic amplifier technology or fluidic analog computing or whatever. Hard to predict.