7 ms·
What's your point? Because you're good at something doesn't mean you're good at everything. That being said, I agree that the tone of the article is a bit too
by simias 13y ago
What's your point? Because you're good at something doesn't mean you're good at everything.
That being said, I agree that the tone of the article is a bit too harsh for my taste, but then again Linux Torvalds is revered here for this kind of tone. It's always good to think outside of the box and bring new ideas to the table. Even if they're dead ends, they keep the brains working, if only to form counter proposals.
N.B.: american friends, pretty please, consider including metric values alongside imperial, I have no idea what 1030feet means. Fortunately we have google for unit conversion...
- Dylan16807 13y agoA foot is about a third of meter, and a mile is about a kilometer and a half. That's all you really need to remember. Heck, in a discussion like this you could pretend a mile equals a kilometer and be fine. Oh, and a pound is about half a kilogram. I won't expect you to remember all the stupid volume units, but those three tiny conversions are worth knowing.
- officemonkey 13y agoAnd a liter is about 1/4 of a gallon (useful when calculating gasoline prices.)
- acqq 13y agoOr about 2 pints, useful for beer.
- jblow 13y agoOkay, but who is Dr. Drang? As nearly as I can tell from a web search, he is someone puts some code on Github and writes a blog. Has he sent rockets into space? Why does he feel like he gets to talk down to someone who has sent rockets into space, on the subject of engineering?
- mbrd 13y ago"Dr. Drang, a consulting engineer well known amongst nerds on the Internet" (from http://5by5.tv/systematic/57 http://5by5.tv/systematic/57)
- warfangle 13y agoSeems super legit
- nonchalance 13y agoNow that's an appeal to authority. Regardless of whether this person is a doctor or a billionaire or a physicist, the key points (like the issues with thermal expansion) are legitimate criticisms. "Dr Drang" presented arguments that are within the reach of high school physics. Now, Musk may have an answer to the issues, but he certainly didn't present them. The fact that there is no obvious resolution suggests that either Musk didn't think of them or he intentionally omitted the answer (both are damning)
- ash 13y ago> key points (like the issues with thermal expansion) are legitimate criticisms No, thermal expansion criticism is not careful enough. See my comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6238022 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6238022
- wheremiah 13y agoYeah, this was my initial confusion with the article and many of the comments. When I read the doc by Musk, I assumed, that the tube 'floated' over the pylons. The author seems to have assumed the opposite. The problem is that they are both assumptions. When making an argument, sometimes it is good to make an assumption and then prove the assumption is false... sometimes it is just a straw man.
- rossjudson 13y ago
- Fishkins 13y ago> Because you're good at something doesn't mean you're good at everything. How is that statement relevant here? The criticism being responded to was that he doesn't know the basics of engineering. The response was there's significant evidence he knows a lot about engineering (and his employees who looked at this proposal probably know more). It doesn't matter whether he's good at everything. edit: fixed typo and added emphasis
- simias 13y agoarethuza ninja-edited his comment after my reply, his initial reply was simply "So what about SpaceX and Tesla?", which didn't make a lot of sense to me. But my point still holds, because you're good at making rockets and electric carcs doesn't automatically make you an expert in high speed train infrastructure, so I don't really think that's a valid argument.
- Dylan16807 13y agoIt means you know a whole lot about thermal expansion.
- dragonwriter 13y agoIt might mean you should know that, but to the extent it does, that makes it more, not less, notable that your work fails to demonstrate that.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> How is that statement relevant here? Because in real life (as opposed to, say, Star Trek), aerospace engineering and civil engineering ain't the same ballpark, ain't the same league, and ain't even the same flipping sport. [1] [1] with apologies to Pulp Fiction.
- orillian 13y agoNo, but a lot of the same types of problems surface even in all these different fields, engineering does have some rather uniquely diversified fields, but at their core they still follow ...a lot of... the same laws of physics.
- saalweachter 13y ago1 foot ~= 1 nano-light-second