4 ms·
"They agree that two chains in contact can react but there is an activation barrier that prevents this happening readily." So, it's really strong but if it eve
by Symmetry 13y ago
"They agree that two chains in contact can react but there is an activation barrier that prevents this happening readily." So, it's really strong but if it ever actually breaks it will explode?
- derefr 13y agoIf I recall, the same is true of Gorilla Glass.
- Symmetry 13y agoI don't mean figuratively exploding as in shattering quickly into a large number of tiny fragments. I mean that I'm worried that it will literally explode, detonating or deflagrating, transforming into a different chemical substance and releasing a large amount of energy along the way.
- Dylan16807 13y agoIt sounds to me like a slow degradation, not anything that would runaway.
- Symmetry 13y agoI'm sure that it does degrade like that at normal temperatures. Normal explosives will also tend to degrade slowly over time as the chemical reactions that power their explosion also have a "activation barrier that prevents this happening readily". But as the temperature increases probability that any given molecular interaction will exceed that activation barrier increases. And if the activation barrier is exceeded, a chemical reaction happens that will release energy and increase the local temperature. In some substances if you increase the local temperature by enough there will be a runaway reaction which will quickly liberate all of the available chemical energy, an explosion. This all has to be triggered, but the strength of the substance makes me think that the energy involved in breaking it ought to be enough. Now, it might be that the energy required to get over the potential barrier is large enough compared to the energy released by the reaction that this doesn't happen. If there people with real chemistry experience here instead of just semiconductor physics and basic statistical mechanics I'd be grateful if they'd speak up. I'm mostly inferring from the prior beliefs of other chemists that this substance wouldn't be stable at all that it will tend to explode if given a chance.
- scythe 13y agoI spoke with a professor ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Walt_de_Heer http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Walt_de_Heer ) once about a question somewhat related to this topic, specifically in cluster physics, regarding the formation of stable condensates of atomic clusters. An atomic cluster is sort of a jelly ball of atoms, where the orbitals, rather than being organized into nice molecular bonds, have become nonlocal and the whole thing acts as a sort of "superatom". They can carry a charge, as in the Zintl clusters e.g. Pb_9(4-): nine lead atoms with four extra electrons. In some very rare cases the clusters form metastable compounds. When I asked de Heer's opinion on producing condensates of clusters, he said quickly "it's a bomb!". Apparently there is so much energy in these unfavorable molecular configurations that you would never want to try to isolate a substantial amount of them. I imagine a similar principle applies to carbyne.
- TwiztidK 13y agoSo it's slightly similar to Prince Rupert's Drops, where part of the drop is extremely strong but if the weaker part is broken the whole thing explodes. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prince_Rupert's_Drop http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prince_Rupert's_Drop
- acadien 13y agoThe mutual frustration imposed in PRDs is due to how it cools and the mechanics of a bulk state (tension on the surface and positive pressure in the core). What they're talking about in this paper is a chemically reactive state which is avoided due to an energy barrier. They're totally different situations, but I can understand why you'd think they might be similar from the wording of the article.
- jlgreco 13y ago> a chemically reactive state which is avoided do to an energy barrier. So sort of like how gunpowder is stable unless you introduce enough energy to get it over the hump?
- ars 13y agoYes. Basically it's flammable with an ignition temperature right around room temperature. If we can keep it cold it might have some uses.
- TwiztidK 13y agoI completely understand the difference so I almost didn't post the link, but I think PRDs are awesome and I couldn't resist a minuscule opportunity to post about them. Thanks for explaining the difference for anyone who may have been misinformed by my post.
- Roboprog 13y agoThanks. There's some pretty cool stuff on youtube about this. (I'd never heard of it before)