6 ms·
In addition to being a crappy fighter the F-35 is also a crappy bomber and close air support aircraft. Not that it's a surprise that a plane designated fighter
by bradleyjg 13y ago
In addition to being a crappy fighter the F-35 is also a crappy bomber and close air support aircraft. Not that it's a surprise that a plane designated fighter (or 'strike' or 'fighter/attack') isn't good at these things.
We've virtually abandoned A and B line planes because the testosterone blinded fighter mafia in the airforce would rather have fun toys than useful equipment, and the navy is right there with them because heavy planes can't take off from aircraft carriers. It doesn't help that the one bomber the air force begrudgingly agreed to acquire is an obscenely expensive hanger queen, designed for nuclear bombing runs deep into the Soviet Union.
If the army wasn't barred from operating fixed wing aircraft by the pernicious Key West agreement, maybe they would operate as a voice of reason.
We should be working on a replacement for the AC-130 (1968), the A-10 (1977), and B-52 (1955!). To the extent we actually need more air superiority fighters they can bring back the F-22 line.
- 650REDHAIR 13y agoWhat? I think you may have missed the B-1 and the enormous focus on UAVs by all of the branches.
- bradleyjg 13y agoThe B-1 was an even bigger debacle than the B-2. Its development time and cost overruns were enormous, and involved a curious scandal where the Carter administration tried the kill the project, but the Pentagon illegally kept it alive off budget so that it was still around to be revived by the Reagan administration. When it finally did roll off the production line almost two decades after the RFP went out, its obsolete stealth, engine problems, and initial inability to deploy non-nuclear weapons kept it from being used in the Gulf War. So it was widely deployed in Afghanistan, 35 years after the design phase began and almost 20 years after production. After so long time had passed the stealth technology was no longer particularly effective and so the bombers were deployed after complete air dominance had been achieved, thus negating one of the chief supposed benefits of the plane over the B-52. I am optimistic about UAVs as a relatively inexpensive replacement for a lot of aircraft, but I fear that once their successes start to endanger the justifications for testosterone toys, internal factions within the military as well as politicians in the pockets of defense contractors will hit back hard.
- spartango 13y agoThere is money going toward the development of a replacement for the B-52, although the exact form it will take is still up in the air/under wraps. Suffice to say that the "Next Generation Bomber" project currently has funding. Two observations along these lines, however: * The B-52 originally was the US Air Force's all-purpose bomber when it rolled out in the 50s. It was a conventional heavy bomber, a strategic nuclear bomber, and a cruise missile platform all in one. Over time, however, the USAF's bombing roles have become split; the B-1 now takes on the role of a conventional bomber, while the B-2 is used for deep-penetration strikes and standoffs. * One big hurdle in the development of a B-52 replacement is the limitations on the number of strategic bombers allowed under the New Start treaty. The US cannot easily develop new nuclear-capable bombers under this treaty, and thus must keep a chunk of the B-52 fleet around to maintain the nuclear capability.
- jacques_chester 13y agoMy understanding is that a major role of the B-52 these days is tactical support. It can carry a very large number of small, laser-guided bombs; can loiter over a battlefield for about a day and flies high enough that it can't be harmed by shoulder-fired weaponry. Conceptually it fills the role of a very large drone.
- bradleyjg 13y agoThe nuclear triad always seemed a bit circular to me. We have three main means of delivering nuclear weapons, so it must be a good idea to have three different means of delivering nuclear weapons. I don't see it. With geographic diversity and at least one delivery system that is mobile and easy to hide we should be more than capable of asserting a second strike capability. What's really needed from a modern bomber is a high munition capacity, a large combat radius, and long loiter times. Cheap to build and operate would be great too. Super stealth as well as high speeds and maneuverability are simply expensive distractions. For the rare situation where we need to deliver something like a conventional bunker buster deep inside of territory that we don't wish to first completely destroy the AA cababilities of first -- i.e. an Osirak type mission -- we still have 20 of those $2 billion B-2s.
- stcredzero 13y agoWhat about the F-15 Silent Eagle?
- bradleyjg 13y agoI don't mean this in a snarky way, but what about it? Are you saying it will be a good bomber or close air support plane?
- stcredzero 13y agoI was thinking along the lines of an interceptor/air superiority platform. Is it really meant to be a bomb truck?
- nknighthb 13y ago> the navy is right there with them because heavy planes can't take off from aircraft carriers This seems an inadequate and/or overly-simplified explanation. The F-14 was a beast, far heavier than the F-35 or, for that matter, the A-6. And that was 1960s technology. Surely now we could build a capable, carrier-launched ground-attack craft with weight comparable to an F-14?
- TsiCClawOfLight 13y agowe did. The F14B ;)
- greedo 13y agoYep, I loved the Bombcat. Oh, and we also flew the A-5 Vigilante, which was huge. Heck, we've even had C-130 Hercules to take off and landings on a CV.
- TsiCClawOfLight 13y agoThanks for reminding me of the A-5, I completely forgot it!
- nknighthb 13y agoI was thinking in terms of something designed from the start for ground-attack/bombing, but my point is that the Navy can't possibly think it needs the same lightweight fighters the Air Force wants just because they operate from carriers, since they spent >35 years running a big-ass plane off carriers. (For that matter, there were the C-130 tests on a carrier, which was probably pushing the bounds of good sense, but it did work.)
- jloughry 13y agoWe did. See the Navy's A-12 stealth bomber, a design that never flew [1]. [1] Stevenson, James P. The $5 Billion Misunderstanding. Annapolis, Maryland: Naval Institute Press, 2001. ISBN 1-55750-777-5.
- rdtsc 13y agoDo we have to? In other words are our opponents (strategic only so far) China and Russia have aircraft that would be superior? In other words do we need to improve or it would just be nice to.
- UnoriginalGuy 13y agoRead the article. It covers this. Yes is the answer.
- InclinedPlane 13y agoThe idea that there is "one F-35" is also part of the problem, there are 3 very different planes that just happen to be named F-35A, F-35B, and F-35C, in actuality they share only 30% of their hardware with each other.