4 ms·
Would freight hyperloops make more sense than those for people? Trains are still the cheapest form of freight transport in the US, but I assume radically faste
by adventured 13y ago
Would freight hyperloops make more sense than those for people?
Trains are still the cheapest form of freight transport in the US, but I assume radically faster speeds + even cheaper costs + lower pollution and environmental impact would generate a net win for a freight hyperloop. Freight doesn't care about inconveniences like lack of toilets or being cramped. Do the benefits begin to rapidly erode under much greater weight, or will that scale?
- untog 13y agoI'm not sure that speed matter for a lot of freight. Fresh food, perhaps. But a lot of stuff is shipped around the world on shipping containers that take weeks to get to their destination, and no-one particularly seems to care.
- dragonwriter 13y agoAside from the issues with perishables (of which fresh food isn't the only kind), delivery times for inputs (and finished goods to the market) combined with inventory (which has a cost) constrain response times to changing market conditions; how important this is depends on the market and the other constraints on response times in that market.
- randomsearch 13y agoApparently (I'm no expert but my Dad is) it makes far more sense to transport people by train and goods by car. People will autonomously complete the rest of their journey when dropped at a station, but goods will not. At least, so far.
- inthewind 13y agoI'd personally like more local storage depos. And keep freight off of the road during the day. Night time would also be a good time to shift freight. The last mile could be done with a small electric vehicle, or over pneumatic tubes. What makes buses and trains so attractive is that they take up far less space (if filled) compared with say a car carrying one passenger. It might be too late in the UK to get cargo and freight back on the canals. Also our local post offices are being closed down, which would be the natural choice for a local pickup point. I for one wouldn't mind a text to say I have a parcel to go and collect. I'd probably be happy collecting my mail once a week (bar the spam.) Side tracking further, I heard some old dears the other day, lamenting that they could no longer afford to send xmas cards. It now costs about a dollar to send mail by first class.
- larrydag 13y agoJust an aside. The Musk Hyperloop is not a pneumatic tube. The pnuematics in Musk's Hyperloop is to reduce friction and provide stability. It's not for propulsion. Musk's Hyperloop is more akin to an air hockey table.
- lmm 13y agoFreight doesn't care about speed, and does care about how much mass and volume you can transport. The capacity of the hyperloop capsules is tiny compared to a modern train.
- larrydag 13y agoThat's not true. Freight consumers care a lot about speed. Think of it like a triangle and each corner is cost, reliability, and time. Each one pulls on the other as a decision process in the supply chain.