6 ms·
Taxed at what percent? Ludicrous.
by bluedino 13y ago
Taxed at what percent? Ludicrous.
- sgk284 13y agoI agree, the thought of merely holding money being a taxable event seems weird (speaking as an American). That said, it's a great way to ensure that people don't hoard cash and instead spend it or invest it (in theory, keeping the economy moving).
- justinhj 13y agoWell if you put it into a bank account the money will actually be being invested by the bank anyway.
- threeseed 13y agoWhy ? Seems like a great tax to me. The people who are most likely to be hoarding large sums of cash are the type of people who you want to be taxing.
- jafaku 13y agoSo that they take their money somewhere else?
- jasonlingx 13y agoSeems like a great way to discourage saving and keeping people living hand to mouth.
- cookiecaper 13y agoWhich, of course, is the basis of modern macroeconomics -- keep people spending as much as possible.
- maaaats 13y agoYou are making assumptions on a system you know nothing about (otherwise you wouldn't have written what you wrote). Read about how this tax work before complaining about it, please. It's only for generally big amounts of money, and your mortgage and other stuff is subtracted, making it a non-issue for almost everyone. And you can fine invest the money instead.
- rsynnott 13y agoIndeed. Why, if the government applies small taxes to cash savings of over 125k, I just won't save at all! Wait, what?
- lmm 13y agoWhich is how you keep the economy growing.
- WalterBright 13y agoNobody hoards large sums of cash. Cash is deposited into a bank, and the bank loans it out to someone who spends it. That's how banks make money, and why they are able to pay you interest on your deposit.
- beachstartup 13y ago> Nobody hoards large sums of cash i completely disagree. first of all, you're arguing semantics, and you know very well that there are many fractional reserve bank accounts with lots of accumulated cash available for withdrawal at any time. that is a working, popular, valid definition of "hoarding cash". second, do not underestimate the amount of cold, hard, paper (polymer?) cash hidden in safe deposit boxes distributed around the world. you can bet your bottom dollar (har har) that this cash isn't being lent out to commercial banking clients and mortgage buyers. it's sitting in boxes, unused. in a certain sense, it's an anti-inflationary savings mechanism. that's not even counting the gold, platinum, pearls, diamonds, precious gems, and etc.
- WalterBright 13y agoI understand fractional reserve banking. It's a percentage (I think around 10%) of the deposits the government requires a bank to keep on hand. The rest of the deposits are all loaned out back into the economy. Note that the government requires this reserve because otherwise the bank will loan it out, i.e. the bank doesn't actually desire to keep cash on hand. Neither do rich people. Even drug lords don't want cash hoards, it's why they launder it. It's not splitting hairs over semantics. People who have money in the bank do not have a cash hoard that they are withholding from the economy. As far as people keeping assets in safety deposit boxes, nobody has any idea how much is in them, so it's rather pointless to talk about them. I do find it hard to believe that Apple's billions in "cash" is really a hoard in a safety deposit box that's withheld from the economy. >that is a working, popular, valid definition of "hoarding cash". Not in the sense we are discussing of it being withheld from the economy. (For fun, watch Breaking Bad, where one of Heisenberg's biggest problems is trying to convert cubic feet of cash into something he can spend.)
- 13y ago
- npongratz 13y agoSeems like a horrible tax because it's not your property. It doesn't matter if the person in question has many resources or few, those resources are not yours to steal (or "tax", or whatever euphemism for aggression you want to use).
- vidarh 13y agoIf you insist of using politically biased terms like "steal" for it, conversely your opponents can just as easily justify reaching for Proudhon and his "property is theft".
- colanderman 13y agoHow is that any different than controlled dilution of a fiat currency, like the Federal Reserve does? The net result is the same.
- jchrisa 13y agoIt's actually sort of the opposite. Interest based money is designed so that the numeric value grows over time. A tax on holdings makes its numeric value decrease over time. See http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demurrage_(currency) http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demurrage_(currency)
- colanderman 13y agoNo, it's the same thing, as that link points out: Both inflation and demurrage reduce the purchasing power of money held over time, but demurrage does so through fixed, regular fees while inflation does so through expansion of the money supply by a central monetary authority distributing newly issued currency or through endogenous money creation (such as fractional reserve banking).
- kaonashi 13y agoThe Fed controls reserves, not net financial assets. The net result from a fiscal injection and a financial composition shift is not the same at all.
- colanderman 13y agoExactly how do they differ? My impression is that the net result (depreciation of cash assets) is the same.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- kaonashi 13y agoIncreasing the amount of available reserves doesn't really transmit to inflation as it's constrained by demand for loans. The loanable funds model which says that increases in reserves leads directly to increases in loans doesn't really apply under a floating-rate non-convertible currency regime.
- e12e 13y agoAround 1%. The reasoning is partly to encourage reinvestment (stocks are taxed differently).
- roel_v 13y agoIn the Netherlands, all assets over €21K (roughly $28K) are taxed at 1.2 %. This includes cash, bonds, stocks, real estate held for investment, paintings held as investments; everything that is not for personal use (so cars and yachts are not included, nor are second homes for personal use). Yes it is preposterous.
- tonfa 13y agoSame in Switzerland. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wealth_tax#Existing_net_wealth.2Fworth_taxes http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wealth_tax#Existing_net_wealth....
- e12e 13y agoHow is it more ludicrous than property tax?