4 ms·
I do think this looks interesting, but the second bullet point makes me cringe (my emphasis): - Secure: optional SSL client cert authentication Reading the se
by e12e 13y ago
I do think this looks interesting, but the second bullet point makes me cringe (my emphasis):
- Secure: optional SSL client cert authentication
Reading the section on SSL in the guide makes me feel slightly better, although I'm worried that it doesn't mention anything about revoking certificates and/or online status checking.
Perhaps we need a (better?) library for TLS-PSK and/or TLS+kerberos for these types of uses of HTTPS? That or a compact stand-alone CA that simplifies certificate management and enrolment to the point where it is both usable, deployable and reasonably secure.
I'm guessing a compact "master CA"-service that only deals with maintaining (optionally) off-line root certs, that only certify intermediary on-line CA(s), that deal with enrolment and revocation of service and client (ie: "principal") certs.
Of course, at that point, you've pretty much created a kerberos work-a-like on top of TLS (for some extra spiffy-ness, set the intermediary CAs to issue certs with 10minute life-times...) -- and I'm not sure if such a system would really be better than just using kerberos in the first place...
[edit: formatting]
Maybe the ease of interop with other rest/http-based services and clients would be worth it -- maybe not.
- philips 13y agoWe want to make the SSL setup even easier. The big hurdle is the current lack of easy to setup CA management tools. Any suggestions on tools? openssl's CA tools work but are pretty difficult to setup and use. It would be great if someone built a CA tools on top of the native Go x509 API. I would love to have a discussion (or patches!) around revocation and status checking in the next version. The project is young but we want to get security right from the beginning.
- e12e 13y agoThe last time I checked, I couldn't find any projects that looked very appealing. There's (now defunct) python CA-project: http://www.pyca.de/ http://www.pyca.de/ Then there's http://www.openca.org/ http://www.openca.org/ (which I've not go any experience with), and of course plain openssl -- which I've always felt is more of a proof of concept than anything really useful. We need a simple, opinionated project, something along the lines of salt/NaCl -- and I suspect go would be a great implementation platform. The only sane option I know of, would be Microsoft AD w/CA setup -- but that's not Free, not open, and not really a good fit for this purpose either [edit: to clarify - it's much too big, and does much more than needed. I'm also not sure how well it works in a setup where you want to keep the root keys offline as much as possible].
- SEJeff 13y agohttps://fedorahosted.org/certmaster https://fedorahosted.org/certmaster It is python, but this is actually really good stuff.
- philips 13y agoThat looks interesting. I will check it out. I will collect other ideas over here: https://github.com/coreos/etcd/issues/99 https://github.com/coreos/etcd/issues/99