3 ms·
I'm replying to a review, so this is perhaps addressed in the book. 1. Couldn't public research simply be crowding out private research? If you're a company a
by jacques_chester 13y ago
I'm replying to a review, so this is perhaps addressed in the book.
1. Couldn't public research simply be crowding out private research?
If you're a company and you can use research someone else paid for ... why wouldn't you? Once that model is established, what incentive do you have to spend above your peers?
2. Is the finding stable across time and different countries?
Public funding of research grew enormously in the 20th century alongside the growth of the state and in reaction to various wars (hot and cold).
What did the mix look like in the 19th century? The 18th? What did it look like in Qing China or in late Republican Rome? What differs between Venice at its peak and the glory days of Islamic civilisation?
3. Is much research simply more expensive now?
Requiring funds that only super-profitable companies and governments can muster?
4. How does research vary between industries and problems?
Some kinds of research are more difficult or expensive than others. Is that why there's a surfeit of software companies appearing in the private sector while almost all biomedical companies grow out of government and university laboratories? How does a small business invent a supercollider?
I guess if I combine all these questions, my underlying question is:
5. Is the current configuration causal or just a surface feature of the current background environment, from which it is problematic to extract generalist statements meant to hold true for all time?
My own suspicion is that some kinds of intellectual output are just not very highly demanded in a general market. Patronage, whether by medieval nobility or modern states, is a form of demand that has given us a lot of public goods.
- chris_wot 13y ago1. Couldn't public research simply be crowding out private research? It depends. There are plenty of examples of research that private companies don't want to do that the government is prepared to do.
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoGovernments have the benefit of being able to take on lots of risk and have a very long term perspective; maybe we'll get to Mars in 2040, a private company couldn't wait that long and spend that much. The only companies who have been successful in long term research have had some kind of market dominance that was eventually tempered. E.g. AT&T Bell Labs or Microsoft. There are arguments out there that companies shouldn't become successful enough to do long term research, it doesn't really fit into a healthy dynamic market. Then you have companies like Google who are very successful in leveraging publicly funded research (self-driving cars...).
- munin 13y agospacex? oh right, government funded ...
- jjindev 13y agoYes, and, it's an "attention economy." I call a field "fully subscribed" when it has enough money and researchers to make full progress. It's over subscribed when you are far into diminishing returns. And of course, under subscribed fields lack everything. What is under subscribed today? Electric cars less than they were, but perhaps zero energy homes ...
- GlennS 13y agoThe UK government has a requirement that all new homes will be carbon neutral by 2016, so I imagine there will be some money appearing for research in this area. There are a couple of caveats: 1) You can build homes which have worse energy efficiency than the requirements if you offset it somehow, e.g. by improving existing homes. 2) The definition of 'carbon-neutral' has been diluted for these regulations. For instance, it doesn't include appliances that you plug in.
- jjindev 13y agoI was speaking from a US perspective. I think we lag. We probably could import that tech of course ... and I was really grasping for under subscribed fields. Any other suggestions?
- mjn 13y agoThe author is more of an economist than a historian, so the book probably won't take a satisfying angle in answering your questions, except the non-temporal part of #2 and perhaps #4. Some of her previous work that she cites in the book has looked at the relationship between industries, countries, sizes/stages of companies and R&D, and different kinds of state funding structures, both in terms of what factors seem to influence money being put into R&D, and whether there's empirical evidence of growth coming out of it. The main thrust of the book seems to be to defend some current thinking in economics to business and public-policy people (most of the book's points are summaries of existing studies, some by the author and some by others). For example she has a section summarizing a set of views on why the U.S. outpaces Europe in innovation, and criticizing what she sees as some incorrect popular views on that question. The book is less aimed at first-principles questions and more at questions like, "does public-private technology transfer work differently in the U.S. and Europe?" and "how are R&D risks currently distributed among different funders in the U.S.?" To the extent there's a headline thesis it's that the public-sector role in modern innovation provides some critical features that are deeply enmeshed into successful networks of innovation. note: This is based on browsing some of the author's papers and skimming through the book, not a deep read.