4 ms·
I think the trick here is that lavabit can't share data even with a warrant. Their inability to do so is pretty much their entire business model. That protects
by tootie 13y ago
I think the trick here is that lavabit can't share data even with a warrant. Their inability to do so is pretty much their entire business model. That protects people from unwarranted intrusions, but it also insulates people from legitimate investigation. If they build a backdoor for only duly authorized warrants, they are no more or less obligated to comply with an NSL.
- mpyne 13y agoI would hope that if they've received an NSL ordering them to wiretap their own email, that the NSL is at least limited to specific targets of an investigation. But some people do strongly believe in throwing out the whole bathtub if that's what it takes to keep the data safe, and to those people I will certainly tip my hat, even if I disagree myself.
- Dylan16807 13y agoI can accept a company complying with a warrant and divulging data for some customers. I will not accept a company that promises complete security and then sends a trojan to customer computers. Anyone that betrays the security promises made to the entire user base (eg. hushmail) should be ostracized.
- mpyne 13y agoAgreed.
- tootie 13y agoI'm thinking now that if he had just been ordered to turn over some data, shutting down his service wouldn't let him off the hook. They must have asked for a back door or some other ongoing intrusion.