7 ms·
>they could not have been expected to re-read the entire contract looking for alterations // I don't think a bank will want to go down the line of arguing the
by pbhjpbhj 13y ago
>they could not have been expected to re-read the entire contract looking for alterations //
I don't think a bank will want to go down the line of arguing the contract shouldn't be binding because they shouldn't have to read the small print - that sounds like an overall loss for the bank in general.
- smsm42 13y agoThe argument is not that you shouldn't read the small print - the bank lawyers know what the small print means - the argument is that they can't look for tiny changes in known small print if they're reasonably expecting it to be identical to what they sent. That's like I would initiate a contract with you and after we read it together and you agree it's what you want to sign I covertly slip a page into the pack that completely changes the terms and trick you into signing it without you actually knowing it's there. You can reasonably claim you intended to sign the original one, not the one I secretly modified - and I expect the court be more sympathetic to you than to my claims "you should have watched my hands all the time!" Of course, it'd require you proving that I did this, but if you can, your case sounds pretty strong to me.
- krichman 13y agoSlipping in an extra paper is not the same at all; you are adding terms to the contract that the signer could not possibly have seen. By changing the small print you are being sneaky, but they had a chance to fully examine what they were agreeing to and were lax in that.
- mrweasel 13y ago>The argument is not that you shouldn't read the small print - the bank lawyers know what the small print means - the argument is that they can't look for tiny changes in known small print if they're reasonably expecting it to be identical to what they sent. Doesn't this case show that they cannot reasonably expect the contract to be identical to what they sent, in respect to all future contracts?
- zenith2037 13y agoThe difference is that this. 1 - The bank signed a copy then gave one to the customer to sign. If the customer changed the print at this point, it would no longer be valid. 2 - What this guy did, the bank gave him a copy, he modified it, then signed it, then sent it back, to which the bank approved. Which is still technically valid.
- gcb0 13y agoYeah, because that's not what banks do every year... Your contact probably has aterm about them being allowed to change the contact and probably not even notifying you.