4 ms·
> To put this claim in perspective, we are still unable to simulate a single cell by modeling everything we know from biochemistry, even if we ignore molecular
by gwern 13y ago
> To put this claim in perspective, we are still unable to simulate a single cell by modeling everything we know from biochemistry, even if we ignore molecular dynamics. Mostly this is because we don't know what many genes and the proteins they encode do.
To me, this mostly shows that naive beliefs about difficulty aren't really accurate ('but it should it harder to simulate a brain than a cell, because it's bigger right!').
But of course, progress is being made on simulating cells: http://lesswrong.com/lw/drk/paper_simulation_of_a_complete_cell/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/drk/paper_simulation_of_a_complete_c... It's a high-level enough model that you can do it with only 1 core per cell.
- foobarbazqux 13y agoSure, but that's also for a bacterial cell. We have 50 times as many genes and you can't easily culture humans on a Petri dish for experimentation. A single gene can take years of work to understand. Yes, you can simulate anything if you abstract away enough. But if the goal is a convincing replication, you'll need to include lots of intracellular effects. In the end, I believe that practical simulation of a whole brain that you can have a conversation about its existence with is more difficult than the development of quantum computing powerful enough to break all existing crypto. The work is still interesting, if only because it pushes the limits of what we can do. But I might want to start with an ant brain.
- Dylan16807 13y agoWhy does it show that the belief isn't accurate? This isn't simulating a brain, it's simulating the connections in a brain and pretending the neurons are about as complex as wires. That is a model that is possibly correct, but there's certainly no evidence it's correct.
- gwern 13y agoIt shows, at a minimum, that 'simulating' is not a binary either-or proposition, and that the higher-level a simulation, the easier/more efficient the simulation can be, and so it is perfectly possible to have a high-level simulation of a 'big' thing which is easier to run than a low-level simulation of a 'small' thing - both of these points, as obvious as they may seem to you or me, are badly underappreciated by a lot of people.
- dnautics 13y agothen why is the modeling attempting to recapitulate biology? Why not run a simulation at a level higher than 'cells'?
- Dylan16807 13y agoWhen people say 'simulate a brain' they mean a very specific thing: simulating it in enough detail that it can have thoughts in fundamentally the same manner as a fleshy brain. >it is perfectly possible to have a high-level simulation of a 'big' thing which is easier to run than a low-level simulation of a 'small' thing While this is true, it's not being shown here until we know that this particular high-level simulation actually works. If it doesn't work then it's more of a failed attempt at creating a simulation.
- dnautics 13y agoI happen to work in the synthetic biology lab at the venter institute, although not on this project - two of our researchers are coauthors on this paper - and my personal opinion is that this paper is a joke. Note that the guys who made the simulation didn't even pick the correct organism. The cell that we have synthetic control over is M. mycoides, not M. genitalium. Lest this seem like a nit-pickey detail, until they rewrite their software for mycoides, in broad strokes the model is essentially untestable, since we don't have broad-scale control over the genitalium genome like we do mycoides. Also note that: "The model accounts for previously observed gene essentiality with 79% accuracy." This is REALLY bad. Considering they are 'seeding' the model using a biased structure that automatically "knows" that certain genes are essential (for example, they have a 'module' for replication that probably zeroes out if you are missing an important replication component, as opposed to simulating how those genes work at a low level) this is probably somewhere close to as good as flipping a coin.
- gwern 13y agoWhat did your colleagues make of your criticism?
- dnautics 13y agoA common theme where I work is me making a vociferous criticism, being ignored, and the things I say coming true later. (this is not to say that all of the objections I make wind up being correct)
- moocowduckquack 13y agoYou didn't refuse the advances of Apollo by any chance?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]