4 ms·
Does your spouse have homework? My mother was a teacher. Her time in the classroom was nominally from about 8:00 - 2:30. Her time actually at work was from a
by nostrademons 13y ago
Does your spouse have homework?
My mother was a teacher. Her time in the classroom was nominally from about 8:00 - 2:30. Her time actually at work was from about 8:00 - 4:30, because there would be students with after-school activities that needed supervision, or staff meetings, or parent/teacher conferences, or putting away classroom activites, etc. Her time away from home, including commuting, would be about 7:30 - 5:30. Her time actually working or commuting to work would be 7:30 - 5:30 + 8:00 - 10:00, because she'd frequently have to spend another couple hours grading papers, or writing up feedback, or planning the next lesson. She would often end up going back to school up to a month before the kids came back, too, to research and plan lessons.
I think the "teachers don't work all that much" meme gets confused by equating time in classroom with work. If you're doing it right, teaching involves a lot more than just delivering instruction to kids. It requires that you really understand each of your students (which could be 20 in elementary schools, but up to 100 in high schools), and where they're at, and that you understand your subject enough to bridge the gap between student and subject. That takes a lot of time, probably more than most industries.
Of course, this all gets confused because there are many, many teachers who don't put in that effort and just deliver a pre-canned lesson plan to 20 bored minds every day. They get up, talk, and go home. Those are the teachers that made my childhood hell.
The unfortunate part is that the way economic incentives are set up, there is no reason for a teacher to act like the first description, and every reason for them to act like the second. Anyone who's willing to actually understand the job they're tasked with doing will put that effort into a more lucrative job (well, except for a few poor schmucks for whom teaching is a calling). So you do, in a sense, get what you pay for.
- rayiner 13y agoSo in debates about teacher pay, remember that the teachers' unions are fighting as hard as they can to make sure that people like your mom get paid exactly the same as the slackers who deliver pre-canned lessons to 20 bored minds every day. And based on my personal experience with K-8 in the U.S., there are a lot more of the latter than the former.
- nostrademons 13y agoI'm not exactly fond of the teachers' unions, and I don't think my mom was either. I actually went to a charter school where the teachers were non-unionized, and the vast majority of my teachers were more like my mom than the boring slackers. (They still got paid very little, though.)
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoSo the solution is to pay less so all of the slackers stay (it's still a good deal for them) and all the good teachers get pushed out?
- tptacek 13y agoNo, the solution is to revoke the privilege of "unfireability", which the unions fight every bit as hard for (in fact, probably more so) as compensation.
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoI can agree with that, I hate entranched interests just like the next person. On the other hand, making the system more responsive on the employer side is going to unmask problems on the employee side related to market pay: get rid of all the dead weight teachers, then you'll have to fill class schedules with effective teachers, and how many do you think there really are who will work for $60k/year in New Jersey?
- dylangs1030 13y agoAnecdotally, I know many. Both my parents would work for that amount all their lives if they had to because they're good and love the profession. More importantly, $60,000 is enough for a middle class income. It's also not the reasonable maximum for being a public or private school teacher in metropolitan areas. You can realistically earn $90,000-$120,000 as a teacher if you're good, network for connections, and stay in the loop for jobs. Seniority and having a degree go a long way to raises.