6 ms·
In case people aren't clear on this. He worked in an industry that takes this sort of thing very seriously. He shouldn't have even been trying to download ope
by melling 13y ago
In case people aren't clear on this. He worked in an industry that takes this sort of thing very seriously. He shouldn't have even been trying to download open source from work. You don't email stuff home to work on it, for example.
- michaelochurch 13y agoYes, he did something stupid. It's not clear that he did anything wrong, but he should have known (and maybe did) that this was a really bad move on his part. It's not worth it to take work code out of its place, especially not in finance where this will be prosecuted. Unfortunately, engineers fail to account for the fact that image and credibility matter far more than substance. This is a case of a man who really had no intention to do anything wrong, but almost certainly did break the law in a pattern that's a notorious bugbear in finance.
- uxp 13y agoDid he break the law, specifically the espionage act? I could see theft of property, possibly, but the furthest I could see it going is breaking an employment agreement, which is a contract between two private parties and doesn't bring criminal charges for violations.
- aa0 13y agoIt depends how much capital the entity you steal from has. In the case of Goldman..well you don't want to fuck with the Gold Man...he's got quite a hammer.
- walshemj 13y agoYes banks tend to be considered CNI (critical national infrastructure) the The Computer Fraud and Abuse Act (as amended 1994 and 1996) seem to indicate that financial institutions are protected computers "intentionally accesses a computer without authorization or exceeds authorized access" which this guy did.
- melling 13y agoHow do you know that he did not intend to do anything wrong? I certainly don't his intentions.
- lgeek 13y agoInitially I thought something along these lines as well. But according to the article, it was common practice: > They’d followed his case in the newspapers and noted the shiver it had sent down the spines of Wall Street’s software developers. Until Serge was sent to jail for doing it, Wall Street programmers routinely took code they had worked on when they left for new jobs. “A guy got put in jail for taking something no one understood,” as one of them put it. “Every tech programmer out there got the message: Take code and you could go to jail. It was huge.”
- RockyMcNuts 13y agoNo way. You sign away any rights to anything you come up with. You get the lecture on it. This guy Serge got shut down when he wanted to open source something. (although GS has open sourced some simple and non-strategic stuff, as a presumable PR move) By both the letter of what you agree to and industry standard it's not really ethical to dump your employer's code into Dropbox or whatever. They go a long way to block it, blocking sharing sites, USB ports, etc. I'm not saying it doesn't happen all the time, just like brokers taking their client lists. People justify it by saying 'really, I'm supposed to look these people up in the phone book?' or 'really, I'm supposed to re-implement this simple function?' How unethical sort of depends on how much of an edge you take, it's one thing if it's stuff you did yourself that would be inconvenient to recreate, the equivalent of your spiral notebook, something else if it's what other people did that would have been impossible to recreate. But I think Serge demonstrates ignorance and naivete by thinking that was normal practice, and both Serge and Lewis demonstrate an ethical blind spot. Did he deserve to be made an example of? I have no idea if he did or why that happened. Maybe there was stuff in there that was viewed as very proprietary. Maybe it was clever, or they just had an inflated sense of its value. Maybe what seemed trivial to Serge seemed extremely valuable and proprietary to GS. Or maybe he just pissed off the wrong guy. Or maybe they were getting poached a lot and decided to take a stand. I don't think we'll ever know. Certainly not based on this article.
- aqme28 13y agoBut he's arguing that he worked on open-source code, which isn't something he is legally able to sign over the rights of.
- pdovy 13y agoI would think this would be common sense at any job - unless otherwise specified in your contract the work that you do for your employer belongs to your employer, full stop. According to the article he freely admits that what he took included proprietary code - that is theft. Now, was Goldman reasonable here? No, we can probably all agree that Goldman and the government overstepped a lot of bounds chasing this guy down. That said, I don't think some form of prosecution was unreasonable.
- msandford 13y agoThat might be, but it's a CIVIL issue not a CRIMINAL one.
- BWStearns 13y agoThe commercial espionage laws might justify bringing it into a criminal case, although (and I'm only on page 7 here) it doesn't seem like they proved, or even attempted to, that the removal of the code was in the interest of using it in his new endeavor. From the sounds of it he was primarily interested in bringing out some modified libraries. So while incidentally bringing out the proprietary code might well qualify him for the civil case, the commercial espionage accusation seems pretty damned weak, especially since the laws are designed to protect trade secrets (the formula for new coke anyone?) as opposed to this blatantly more mundane potential piece of IP. Also depending on the licenses of the open source stuff (as hinted at in a prior comment), it may not have been within the guy's legal authority to hand over IP rights to GS for some of the code.
- msandford 13y agoUltimately it looks like a case of GS being able to command the government to do things. Why that's possible I have no idea. Unless they have a lot of dirt on everyone in the world.
- walshemj 13y agoBanks take security v seriously even trying to plug a usb drive into you pc to copy files will be logged and will probably get you fired.
- jonknee 13y agoGetting fired for breaking policy is fine. Calling in favors to the Feds and nailing someone for 8 years is not.
- walshemj 13y agoHe was caught bang to rights with company property how is that different to a shop worker getting caught with some of the shops goods
- jonknee 13y agoQuite obviously the coffee shop worker would not be serving time in Federal prison. He caught caught with source code, not with using the source code, selling the source code, threatening to sell or release the source code, etc etc. No actual damage occurred.
- BudVVeezer 13y agoThat must explain my bank's insistence on not having passwords greater than 9 characters, without spaces or most "special characters." They take security seriously!
- timdev2 13y agoPerhaps you're conflating the banks' security with that of their customers.
- riskable 13y agoFirst of all: Banks do not take security very seriously. I know this from first-hand experience working at banks. What they do take seriously is people "leaking" or sharing proprietary information. Secondly: Being fired is not what happened to this guy. He was prosecuted and sent to prison. Not even remotely the same thing.
- brianpgordon 13y agoThe question isn't whether Sergey did something he shouldn't have. It's whether Goldman and the government overstepped in prosecuting him. Being sentenced to 8 years in prison based on wildly ill-informed testimony is clearly not a reasonable response.